ABOUT THIS BLOG

In Field Notes, NBC News will shed light on the stories that don't always make the headlines as well as offering analysis on the big and small stories of the day.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the country and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind this blog.



Subway warning doesn’t break holiday stride

Posted: Wednesday, November 26, 2008 2:30 PM

(Written Wednesday morning on the Manhattan-bound L and uptown F subway trains)

NEW YORK – I'm on my daily morning commute from Brooklyn to Manhattan just after hearing the news about a "plausible but unsubstantiated" terror threat to New York City subways, issued by federal authorities. And unless I end up staying out late and grabbing a cab, I will be on the subway again tonight. And every day and night in the foreseeable future, just like everybody else I know.

Because of all the things to be afraid of, terror attacks do not – and cannot — top my list. Cigarettes are obviously more dangerous, and riding the NYC subway is not an act of bravery. Longtime Gothamites say it was once, during the fiscal crisis of the 1970s, but these days it's a relatively cheap, fast and efficient way to get around.

Image: New York City police officer on subway platform
AP
A New York police officer walks down stairs toward a subway platform, in midtown New York on Wednesday.  

I think about asking my fellow travelers for their take on the federal warning, but I don't want to break the news about a "plausible but unsubstantiated" threat in this light pre-holiday crowd.

It's a totally normal subway scene – a wonderfully diverse amalgamation of folks reading newspapers and paperbacks, taking mid-morning naps, talking smilingly amongst themselves, typing blog posts on their blackberries. Did the hipster girl across the way just smile at me?

As the subway reached 3rd Avenue, we are held "because of an earlier incident," and the gently authoritative robot conductor voice reminds us to use trash receptacles. His female counterpart, the smoothly digital station agent, advises that a Brooklyn-bound train is arriving on the opposite track. The next one is seven minutes behind. And more will undoubtedly arrive after that.

Normal. Seven-plus years after 9/11, and this city runs and runs and runs.

The most fear I've faced recently in New York was last Sunday night, when the empty tables at a fine restaurant made my companions wonder whether we – or anyone – would ever come back. Or rather, if the depressing, vacant chairs would reinforce the despondent market psychology of diners and spiral the joint out of business.

Frankly, I'm more fearful about my parents' retirement situation – they are back in West Michigan – than I am about anything else. New York will take care of itself. 

We'll keep concentrating on our lives, stacking-up on top of each other, living for the next encounter with another talented hard-working transplant from Xenia, Ohio, or Shanghai or Malibu or Islamabad. Proof-positive, at the 14 Street stop, I walk past a mustachioed guy in a guyabera playing a plaintive Cuban guitar.

That's why I'm here – still here – with my friends. And as a buddy from Tel Aviv always reminds me: we haven't been hit again yet!

Now the F-train has arrived, and we’re reminded: "Please help us keep the subway system clean and litter-free."

Good news. Al-Qaida hasn't hit us in a while, the MTA hasn’t cut service yet, the restaurants are still open, I'll have Thanksgiving in the leafy suburbs with a tribe comprised of San Franciscans, Detroiters, Parisians and who knows who else.

I switch trains without a hitch and head north, "Rockefeller Center next. Rockefeller Center next."

I hop out and buy some smokes from the South Asian lady in the station kiosk. She gives me a "Happy Thanksgiving" with my change, and I give her one right back.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Happy and Safe Thanksgiving to all of you who ride the subways every day!
As a displaced New Yorker, now residing in Richmond, VA, I loved Stokes Young's article. It IS New York, the city that will always hold my heart. Quite frankly, my husband and I are fervently waiting for the right opportunity to come up so we can move back HOME! Mr. Young has tapped into the City's pulse, and he gets it. I look forward to the day when we can move back. Meanwhile, I'll have Christmas in NY to look forward to.  I can't wait.
Fear is a terrible thing to live with...that's why I trust God for my safety and go about my business.
Your commenttary is not false bravado but recognition that bad things happen infrequently and good things more often.I am an ex New Yorker living in Flint , Michigan . Wall street and the banks aare amore immediate concern ,but not life and death .The subway keeps everything in perspective.We have different destinations in the same system , but we are on this train together .
Typical NYC scene. New Yorkers are tough - oblivious (in a good way) to the constant threats out there. The author is right: there is much more to fear than a terrorist attack in NYC. Can it happen again? Of course. Will it happen again? Who knows? Probably.. But until then, life goes on in the City that Never Sleeps...

Happy Thanksgiving to all.
Wow. I moved from New York City last year after living there for 10 years, and it's good to know the subways have turned around so dramatically: fares are cheap; there's no more overcrowding or pushing; passengers smiling at one another; the panhandlers seem to have disappeared; and if Stoke Young's train was only held on the tracks once, the system must be running on schedule far more regularly than it was a year ago. Riding the subway used to be the most miserable thing about living in Manhattan--not as long ago as the 1970s, but as recently as last year--and I'm delighted to hear that it's improved so greatly and so quickly
Terrorists WANT us to live in fear. Their goal is to cause terror. The best thing we can do is go on with our lives as normal, and show them they won't be allowed to terrorize us and make us live in fear, like the citizens of their countries.
Exactly right Stokes, my NYC brethren :-) !! I am a born & raised New Yorker who is proud of her city and fellow New Yorkers. If we let fear rule our lives, then the terrorists will win - even before an actual terror attack. May God Bless each and every person that rides the NYC subways every day :).
I went to NY every summer. It's a huge city, but tighter than a small town in Iowa. I was told by my grandma not to point or look up, or they know you're a tourist. Well Grandma (deceased) I'd be proud to be a NYer. Brooklynn by choice. You all showed a lot a class.
Frank -- Good point about the crowding. The L train in particular is a crush during rush hour, with folks pushing to get on. Don't tell my boss, but that's one reason I tend to go to work after rush hour, and head back to Brooklyn after the evening rush. And yes, some trains are delayed, but major delays are rare in my experience. Finally, as for smiling, it really does happen, particularly amongst friends but also on occasion between strangers.
Gosh, I heart NY sub, wish I could make it work here.  I had a awesome ride recently on my summer NY trip. Nothing special except I rode the sub alone for the first time, completely unaware of where I was going...LOL...I was on the phone taking directions from a friend...pretty dang cool (no, the phone did not work down there and I panic for a while then got realistic...LOL)
I talked to strangers and was totally amazed at the hodge podge collection of people who hopped on and off the sub.  Thank you NY for being what you are, I could not have that experience anywhere else.
I meant to say this:
Happy and Safe Thanksgiving to all of you who ride the subways every day!
BORING!
This article is right on the money! To the native New Yorkers itching to return; I did just that last year after nearly 20 years living in other parts of the country. I lasted exactly 10 months! The apartment living, having to move your car to a new parking spot every night, seeing brand new dents/scratches on my brand new car almost weekly, constant attitudes and noise, the subway crowds/smells. NY will always be #1 in my heart, but from now on I will enjoy my visits knowing that I don't have to live there!
I thought the same thing about going into the City this Weekend with the family until I started watching the India tragedy unfold... Say your prayers and keep your eyes out... be aware of your surroundings.
As a southerner, even I enjoyed living in New York for a time. Its a different type of pace and for alot of people, its good.  The fact that New Yok is a neosocialist liberal bastion still doesnt take away all of the realy neat things about the place.
I'll try not to rub this in, but I'm a native of Manhattan now living on another island- Maui, HI. There are things I miss-(the subways are NOT among them, although I did have some decent naps on long rides)- theatre, live music, the arts. However, if you offered me a million $$ tax-free to move back, I would   have to think long and hard. Bless you all and Happy Thanksgiving! (and, yes, I must admit, the holidays are a magical time in NYC.)
New York has always been home to me no matter where else in the world I am!
I live in NYC.  I saw the rifles, dogs, etc.  I was asked how I felt about it.

I said that we don't take terrorism seriously, we confuse predjudice with being careful about who we allow to come to the US, and who we accomodate, and that because of lax security and people beingin denial about 5th columns in our midst and terror in general,I did expect to see more threats and successful ones.
I also said that in the main, our spirit is not cowed and I wished a Happy Thanksgiving to all.
PS I hate to disinform you, although some stops are still beautiful and have even been rebuilt, MOST are in a shocking state of filth, disrepair and train service is abysmal.  Stay in GA or TX and come here to visit the museums.
Born and raised in New York, I know there is no other city in the US and possibly the world as wonderful, and it is better then ever, and people like Stokes Young is one of the reasons it is such a fabulous place.  Although I live in Los Angeles, I still yearn for New York City and try to visit as often as possible - it's great being a tourist there too!
I've never been to NY...but as an American, I'm proud of this great city.
Happy Thanksgiving to all!
Be safe.
Ah Gotham - so like the balance of our nation, we fall down, we get up and go on. Though skies here in CA are overcast and it's raining, I am filled with hope that this nation (so like NY) will endure as it has it  has endured.
Pacem - SanGabrielKate
I'm glad to see people from NY are going about their daily with out fear. Happy Thanksgiving to you all.  
Being a native New Yorker that no longer lives there, I found the comments more informative then the article. The migration of people into and out of the city is as dynamic as any time in it's past. Now instead of arriving from Europe they are coming from all parts of the US as well as the world. New York will never loose it's allure and the people who live there will never loose their spirit because New York is where the American dream has and will always live. It takes guts to leave your home where ever it is in the world to come to a city as tough as New York and that emigrant mentality shows  itself in it's current and past residents. That is why the ones that no longer live there remember so fondly when they did. The spirit of New York is the American spirit of hard work and endless dreams of what you can achieve. I hope New York will never again be the target of terrorists but if it is, the US and the world will rally around them because in our hearts we are all New Yorkers.
Give up the coffin nails, Mr. Young.
It's not just a city, it's a "state of mind", as Billy Joel said.  As a native Brooklynite, yes I miss still being there. She's in my blood, I don't mind visiting and staying overnight with her, lots of fun! But another relationship with her, staying there? I don't know,she's pretty high maintenance if you want her to keep you happy i.e. money.  So until I got it like that, I'll remain a former and distant lover.  Happy holidays to all there, take a bite of the big apple for me.
I miss my hometown sooo much! I love to read stuff like this. I really feel like I am foreigner out here on the West Coast, Portland, Oregon.
I send my love to my hometown: New York City - you're the greatest!
I'm from upstate NY, I live in Texas now and I miss NY all the time.  That will always be my home.  God Bless all in NYC.  Happy Thanksgiving.
Whenever I have to drive trough NY to get to my native New England I just want to get through there fast and safe, I'm scared to death to be there.
I am more afraid of the fascist looking, black wearing, automatic rifle carrying, super cops that hoard around my work stop at Columbus Circle on holidays and Sept. 11 every year. One false move and alot of
everyday people could get hit. I think its very hard to stop a motivated bomber, even if you have MAJOR GEAR. I pray that it never happens. And I still get on the subway (F to the A or C, D or B) two, three, and four times a day. There's no better way to get around with a monthly metro. Buses too. NYers should learn their sub line's buses for when the train isn't going to move. Helps a lot. You can get anywhere in this city. U.S. needs a real train network.
Great article. Lived in NY for many years before moving to the midwest. I did the same trick, going in after morning rush and staying until after evening rush hour.  Nice to see things are the same, one threat or the next. When WTC hit, it did throw everyone for a loop, but so quickly (and not forgettting), the great people in the city defiantely went back to their routine, including riding the subways or the PATH. Nice to see things have not changed this day.
Born in Dallas and raised in NYC, I do long to return home because it's where I need to be. BUT, this article hits the mark. There is no other place like NYC and it still keeps on going in times of trouble. I take the F train home from Union Turnpike afer getting off the E; I take the E to the L train to get to Union Square taking a detour after work...it's an awesome place to be and I'll be damned if I let something mess up the NYC experience. You just can't let it get you down.
It's America. I guess it starts at being proud of your city, and being proud of your dollar. It votes strong, and all it stands for.

You guys got to have a happy thanksgiving.
I want a re-run of Election night, the debates, Countdown, Rachel Maddow. No Lockup marathon on Thanksgiving, pleeeeeeeease!!! Where is "the place for politics" again?
When I heard the warning on the news this morning, it made me think about all those people who died on Sept. 11. It made me sad, and yes, it made me scared. How do you prepare yourself for something that is not supposed to happen? You expect when you get in a car that you could be in an accident. But who expects to be blown up at work, or on the way to work? Who expects to never see their father, or brother, or mother, or sister again? But bragging about buying smokes like you are somehow above death?? That's just bad taste. "New York will take care of itself." What does that mean? The people are what make New York.
When we lose any of them we lose a little piece of ourselves. And riding the subway is an act of bravery. Ask anyone who rode the subway into Manhattan following Sept. 11 after hearing on the morning news that it was an Orange level terror threat day. Yes, we have a lot to be thankful for. Let's not forget how much.
I wont sell my soul for a dollar bill. But, I'll be damned if I aint damn proud of what is written on it.

In God We Trust.

You guys have a good thanksgiving and give thanks where it due.
Aloha from the Big Island Jonathan D!  NYC is a beacon of achievement for America and I wish all of my fellow citizens who live there and elsewhere a very safe, fun Thanskgiving and holiday season!
That was a really good article.  This guy has a good outlook on things.  
I have difficulty believing that well-organized terrorists would provide some form of advance notice.
REminds me of putting a rag on someone's head and having the the person pose for a video as Bin Laden.

To me this is simply more U.S. Government BS being thrown at us to distract from more serious problems so that the criminals who comprise the Senate and Congress can give more money away while furthering Imperialist activities around the world.
I rec'd a text message today about this from a local radio station on my way to the Herald Square subway station (one of the largest in the system).  It arrived as I was beginning my holiday weekend.   I'll admit I was more than a little aggravated by this message sent on the day we expect the tourist surge to begin.  

Thanks FBI.  Unlike other cities, NY's subway is not an optional mode of transportation.  We all must use it.  It's how we get around.  We must ride.   So thanks for the info, but we can't (and won't) change our behaviors.  We can't walk instead.  We can't suddenly drive.  We MUST swipe our cards, walk thru the turnstiles and ride, vague threats aside.  

What should have happened - has happened, we see the our fantastic New York City and MTA police everywhere - and that's reassuring.  The show of force is good.  

And every day, the NYPD and the MTA have done a great job reminding us - if we see something say something - The citizenry is ready to report any out of the ordinary activity.  

So save the hyperbole... arrest these fanatics and deport them all ready.
I hope the police take special care to guard Miley Cyrus tomorrow in the Macy's parade, cuz I couldn't stand if anything happened to her.  And I hope everyone else is safe too.
Well I wonder what the Keith Olbermanns and Rachel Maddows of the world are saying about this and the terror attack in India today.  I guess Bush was crazy for the wire taps in their eyes but in mine it makes sense to keep folks safe.  Rachel, I would love to see how you would handle these things.
unfortunately they got the best of my family...we were heading to nyc for the night to enjoy the awaited Macy's Day Parade and canceled. Having 2 children we felt we needed to make a choice...do we knowingly hope nothing happens? I miss new york and was looking forward to this life experience...oh well maybe next year
It's so true that NYers have so many stressors that taking a terrorist hit for the country is just one more.  
My son has been taking the subway to school since he started high school at age 14.  I am concerned about a terrorist attack but being alert to one is just one additional set of instructions I gave to my son along with, don't stare at anyone for too long, don't stand too close to the edge of the platform when the train is coming in, don't try to walk between cars, and don't fall asleep.
I visited NYC this past weekend.  It was the first time for my husband and daughter and only the 2nd time for me.  I LOVED all the beauty of the night in Times Square.  We enjoyed the MET and the NBC tour.  We mainly rode cabs and was that a ride!!  We went to Penn Station to catch a train back to Newark Airport.  I really loved the city.  I did not feel unsafe at all until Monday morning when we visited Chinatown.  We felt a little uncomfortable there.  It seemed everyone started and when we stopped on a corner trying to hail a cab we were approached several times by people wanting us to follow them to buy Coach and Gucci bags.  A little scary...but I would love to visit the city more often and take in all of the history and culture there.
Born in NY, raised in Jersey, haven't lived on the East Coast in eons, but Manhattan is still my spiritual home, and nobody better mess with my city again!  I long for the day when I can afford to come back, at least for a visit, and to feel the energy of its people again.  No other place is quite like it, and I've been all over this great country, so I know whereof I speak.  Happy Thanksgiving to all!
New York is the best.  My boyfriend Frank works in NY City and he rides the Subways everyday I'm glad I didn't know about this plot until I came home because I would be nervous with him in the big Apple and me in Pennsylvania.  I love NY and plan to keep visiting until I move there. Keep the Faith God Bless and Happy Thanksgiving New York
Interesting to learn of the suspected terrorist acts. It occurs to me, that the current United States low level economy status could possibly lower our guard against terrorist acting out their threats. But so far, that hasn't happened and I'm truly beginning to think the only terrorist that comes to mind is the one retiring come January 20, 2009.
To be honest, I thought this article was going to be about some warning to not eat too much on Thanksgiving given by the Subway restaurant.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):