ABOUT THIS BLOG

In Field Notes, NBC News will shed light on the stories that don't always make the headlines as well as offering analysis on the big and small stories of the day.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the country and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind this blog.



Subway warning doesn’t break holiday stride

Posted: Wednesday, November 26, 2008 2:30 PM

(Written Wednesday morning on the Manhattan-bound L and uptown F subway trains)

NEW YORK – I'm on my daily morning commute from Brooklyn to Manhattan just after hearing the news about a "plausible but unsubstantiated" terror threat to New York City subways, issued by federal authorities. And unless I end up staying out late and grabbing a cab, I will be on the subway again tonight. And every day and night in the foreseeable future, just like everybody else I know.

Because of all the things to be afraid of, terror attacks do not – and cannot — top my list. Cigarettes are obviously more dangerous, and riding the NYC subway is not an act of bravery. Longtime Gothamites say it was once, during the fiscal crisis of the 1970s, but these days it's a relatively cheap, fast and efficient way to get around.

Image: New York City police officer on subway platform
AP
A New York police officer walks down stairs toward a subway platform, in midtown New York on Wednesday.  

I think about asking my fellow travelers for their take on the federal warning, but I don't want to break the news about a "plausible but unsubstantiated" threat in this light pre-holiday crowd.

It's a totally normal subway scene – a wonderfully diverse amalgamation of folks reading newspapers and paperbacks, taking mid-morning naps, talking smilingly amongst themselves, typing blog posts on their blackberries. Did the hipster girl across the way just smile at me?

As the subway reached 3rd Avenue, we are held "because of an earlier incident," and the gently authoritative robot conductor voice reminds us to use trash receptacles. His female counterpart, the smoothly digital station agent, advises that a Brooklyn-bound train is arriving on the opposite track. The next one is seven minutes behind. And more will undoubtedly arrive after that.

Normal. Seven-plus years after 9/11, and this city runs and runs and runs.

The most fear I've faced recently in New York was last Sunday night, when the empty tables at a fine restaurant made my companions wonder whether we – or anyone – would ever come back. Or rather, if the depressing, vacant chairs would reinforce the despondent market psychology of diners and spiral the joint out of business.

Frankly, I'm more fearful about my parents' retirement situation – they are back in West Michigan – than I am about anything else. New York will take care of itself. 

We'll keep concentrating on our lives, stacking-up on top of each other, living for the next encounter with another talented hard-working transplant from Xenia, Ohio, or Shanghai or Malibu or Islamabad. Proof-positive, at the 14 Street stop, I walk past a mustachioed guy in a guyabera playing a plaintive Cuban guitar.

That's why I'm here – still here – with my friends. And as a buddy from Tel Aviv always reminds me: we haven't been hit again yet!

Now the F-train has arrived, and we’re reminded: "Please help us keep the subway system clean and litter-free."

Good news. Al-Qaida hasn't hit us in a while, the MTA hasn’t cut service yet, the restaurants are still open, I'll have Thanksgiving in the leafy suburbs with a tribe comprised of San Franciscans, Detroiters, Parisians and who knows who else.

I switch trains without a hitch and head north, "Rockefeller Center next. Rockefeller Center next."

I hop out and buy some smokes from the South Asian lady in the station kiosk. She gives me a "Happy Thanksgiving" with my change, and I give her one right back.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I had the opportunity to be in NYC for New Year's 02, one week after serving a tour in Cuba. The subways are the lifeblood of the city, and they show how the city lives; the old grimy New York, ready to mug you for five dollars, is still there. But the newer New York is there too, ready to take advantage of the new millenium and move forward. New York will persist, and thrive.
It's safe here!  Arkansas, the Ozarks.  BUT no theatre, classy restaurants, and if you're aren't from here, everyone knows it and talks about you!  I can't wait to get out of here again (WHY do I keep coming back, thinking it'll get better?), and as soon as I get my Christmas presents, I'm heading to Tampa, FL....not as big as NYC, but more liberal!  AND warmer!  
Anchorage Alaska,  never has to worry about the Subway,
Just keep out of the way, so a Moose does hit your Truck....... Ellen H.
getting on the 4 train at atlantic avenue every morning is both the best and worst part of my day.  i know that at 8 AM i'm going to be crunched between 9 different people and have my personal space wildly violated, but i also know that 8 million others are willingly doing the same thing.. knowing people out there want to harm us, want to disrupt our way of life, or just want to give us a good scare.  there really is no stopping it, of all the things i've been blessed with, i rank being a part of new york as one of the greatest privileges.. And a great article herein to boot.  happy tgiving all
As I wake up this Thanksgiving with my cup of Joe I so pleasantly stumbled upon your column.  Sometimes as a new New Yorker I need to be brought down to earth and realize what a privilege it is to live and succeed in this wonderful city. Sometimes it's so easy for me to become desensitized and not realize the greatness around me.  Thank you for reminding me how great it is to be in New York City.
It's crushingly expensive to live here, but I don't think I can live anywhere else!  Though I have to admit, I try not to stand too close to the garbage cans on the subway platforms.  I wouldn't call it fear, merely risk management.
We visited NYC for a few weeks about 3 years ago.  My crazy family....the highlight was the subway system.  They wanted to go everywhere in the citys burroughs (sp?)...just so they could ride the subway.  We live in rural TN. farms are quite common, we visited a farm in some burrough that took 3 trains and 2 buses to get to, just becasue it had the longest subway line.  We rode every line at least once, and I would agree some were fantastic and some made me pretty nervous.  But we never had any trouble and all thought NYC is great.  Planning another trip soon, winter this time.  Stay real NYC.
How right you are. Cigarettes kill more people than terrorism. Maybe you'll quit? Go "cold turkey" today. Then we can all enjoy your articles for years longer.
I've been to the magical city that never sleeps a few times.  I was born and raised in the midwest that is probably is big as some of your living rooms.  I had great experiences each time.  I can't say as I could ever live there, but it is one of my top destinations for travel.  It is truly the best.
Whenever I travel internationally people ask where I'm from. I always respond that I'm from New York as opposed to saying that I'm from the USA. Without fail I'm received as if I'm from the place I'm visiting before I'm told about a friend, brother, cousin, nephew etc. who is living in New York. I'm treated like a welcomed guest from that point on. Perhaps the people are reciprocating for the way that New York and its people accepted their friend or family member. Humankind will achieve its intended condition when the Spirit of brotherhood between New Yorkers and the rest of the world spreads to all the people of the world so that all people see each other as fellow New Yorkers. New York's mass transportation system makes interaction among its ridership both necessary and possible. Maybe New York's mass transportation model should be emulated around the world to achieve tolerance among people and peace among nations. Happy Thanksgiving.  
good people cannot let evil people upset there lives, we carried on, in london when i was a child in ww2 ,its the way to win,
I am New York born and bred, now living in Virginia.I go back periodically, for those of you with negative comments...take a trip,spend some time,get to know us. You will be pleasantly surprised.
The people that want us to live in fear are the crimiinal elements of this rouge government we live under.Do not be fooled by their warnings.They are not sending out this information to protect us.They are masters of "False Flag Terrorism".They love "Shock and Awe" This is how these rouges control us.The enemy is among us.This enemy is the same enemy that told us that if the House did not pass the so called $700 biillion bailout(reality $5trllion) that we would be headed for another Great Depression".Always remember and heed these warnings .Ask yourself who will benefit from this terrorist attack.Americans please read your history.This nation is under the control of the banks and their crimiinal patsies.We allowed them to fool us and deceive us with lies and propaganda since they establishhed the phony Federal Reserve system.
I think that decent and law abiding  Americans must take back their government through education and involvement to rid the natiion of these criminals Once the people wake up and become a righteous nation then these criimiinals will face the Judgement they deserve.
This is still a great natiion.I am thankful of tiis great nation and the principles of the founding Fathers.Big Government and a Central bank was not part of this plan.I am greatful for the education and opportunities that I have experienced.I am greatful and thankful for New York City.It is one of my favorite places in America next to Gettysburg,Pa.
The article written was very good.It remided me of the reasons that I love New York City.It reminded me of the things that I love and want to be thankful for.
Happy Thanksgiving to all freedom loving Americans.
I love visiting New York and have many times; several of my relatives live in and near the city. I admire the bravery and celebration of life I am hearing from the NY folks, but I agree with Alex above as well. As a mother of two young children, I was afraid on a recent trip riding the subway. Not of 99.9 percent of the folks around, but of that crazy misguided element that is wreaking havoc in nations around the world. It isn't worth it to me to risk my children's lives out of bravado or any other reason. Not to say we should cower in fear. But if there is any kind of credible threat, I don't think that we should ignore that....it hints at the youthful arrogance and ignorance even that Americans are known for around the world, and I don't mean this disrespectfully at all--I know it comes from a better place, but perhaps also a naive one...I don't know what the answer is, but all of you are in my thoughts today, as are the victims of the latest terrorist attack in India. My heart breaks for the family members hurt so badly, and I pray that the appeal of Islamic militancy will soon wane. With greater global justice, perhaps that may happen.
My son is fourth generation New Yorker, attending NYU. Each day he commutes from LI, and each day I worry.  But nothing can compare with the experience and education he is receiving.  Bloomberg and President Bush have the awesome responsibility of keeping him safe.  God Bless them both.
Years ago I rode the subway from the Bronx down to the Battery every day and each time it was a different experience due to the different kinds of people riding the car that day.NYC is a paradox,sometimes you hated it but in retrospect you came to miss it for all the neat things going on.
Born, raised, live, raised family in NYC. Of course our city is a terrorist target; the terrorists are terrified of us. We have the drive and the diversity that drives all fanatics nutsy. They can't deal with anyone or anything that isn't as narrow, terrified and crazy as they are.
I lived in NYC all of my life prior to joining the military.  I remember well the feeling that NYC had just after 911.  It was not fear - it was a feeling of sadness.  You could actually feel it around you.  NYC will remain as is as long as it does not have to deal with weekly explosions in public transit buses, subways and discos.  911 proved that we were not untouchable.  The years to follow also showed a lack of memory.  Our open society is wonderful.  I wish others would share in it without using it against us.  But, "wishing" will not make the threat go away.  It's not a matter of "if"; it's a matter of "when".  God Bless NYC.
....to borrow from Gertrude Stein; I'm a Missourian, but NYC is my home town. I recently moved to Manhattan, and I love it. For someone middle-aged whose kids are grown, what a great time to get out and experience all that New York offers.
I'm reading all the comments and wondering why most of our 'native NewYorkers' live somewhere else now. They crave to be back, and yet live in other states?
I'm not really believing New York, or the subway is as wonderful as it's portrayed. Been there once and will never go back.
I'm reading all the comments and wondering why most of our 'native NewYorkers' live somewhere else now. They crave to be back, and yet live in other states?
I'm not really believing New York, or the subway is as wonderful as it's portrayed. Been there once and will never go back.
In my lifetime I lived in Athens, Greece, London, England and small towns in Italy and Wales, UK.  I have visited Paris, Cannes and Toulane, France and many other cities.  I have been in many cities throughout the United States. No I am not a business man and do not work for one of those Wall Street banks.  I served in the Navy for twenty years and I was fortunate enough to travel the world.  Why do I bring all this up?   I grew up in Astoria, Queens and left there to join the Navy at the age of 20. Well, I can tell you there is no city or subway like in NYC. The people, the smell, the experiences.... This article touched me a lot.  It brought back a lot of memories and they were great.  My experiences were awesome and especially in the subway. There was one time that I followed my friends and we jumped and did not pay and guess what we got caught.  The cop scared the hell out of us and I learned never to do it again.  Nothing is free in this world and always try to do the right thing.  Articles like this reminds me how strong the people of NYC really are.  Fearless...knock them down but not out.  They will always get up just like the rest of America.  Terrorists I hope you learned something on 9/11.  Happy Thanksgiving and Merry Christmas (Happy Holidays for all the liberals)
I am thankful for rotary engines. While not the best for everyone I really enjoy mine! 400rwhp @ 16LBS of boost!  Happy Thanksgiving from RotaryCarClub.com
the subways are in disrepair because the transit workers are always never around and the only thing that comes out there mouths is 'we want more money' but,they are doing a terrible job.that said,there is not anything like new york! happy thanksgiving!
Everyone should go to NYC at least once I did a year ago and I loved it Time Square ,subway,crowds and, more crowds it was great,something to do every single day I plan on going back soon if not sooner. I am from Dallas,TX but I can now tell everyone here to go to NYC at least once you won't come back the same. Dallas does'nt hold a candle to NYC. Dallas is boring full of shallow people,racsist people of all color,everyone has a car but I never see a car pool,food is over priced,and jobs don't pay well at all everything else is just fair. Dallas is okay to visit but don't live here. Go live some place else take it from me I have lived here all my life.

I am going to India in January.  With all the recent terrorist attacks there, it is troubling. I have never been to NYC, and feel this new development is disturbing as well.  However, I feel there are many who have commented before me stating it better than I.  We cannot live in fear and if we put our trust in God he will guide us on the path that he sees fit.  So what is everyone so worried about?  
Happy Thanksgiving to all and a special Thanks to all who ride the trains.  "Thanksgiving"...Give thanks to our transit workers, officials, law enforcement, fire, emergency, government, and every operations, maintenance and construction workers on the lines.  Please bear in mind, most delays are due to the constant effort of those trying to get their work done on the tracks and signal system without interfering with the train schedules, and sometimes it just doesn't quite work out. Other reasons can be attributed to mechanical failures and the like.  So, the next time you experience a delay, remember, the trains are stopped for your safety, the passengers. Please don't get upset, remember, you have arrived safely. The Maintenance and Construction forces work mosty at night for the critical work, under difficult time pressures, with everyones safety a MUST...Every Day... So you can arrive on time, Safely. So they give thanks as well. Again, Happy thanksgiving to all and lets all be safe out there...
ana Doe, "I said that we don't take terrorism seriously, we confuse predjudice with being careful about who we allow to come to the US, and who we accomodate,...." I agree with you completely, along with Americans now seem to have a acquired a misplaced sense of guilt about protecting ourselves, at the expenxe of needing to be perceived as a nation where anything goes, as long as, it meets the expectations of nonAmericans.
I am a native New Yorker born and raised but unfortunately moved away sevreal years ago . Now i,m in Lubbock Texas and still going thru culture shock! No matter what terrorists try New York is the place to be and were a different breed from all the rest nothing impedes our daily commute....
Just another da in the life of your average New Yorker.
My most recent visit to NYC involved two trips on the subway. Ist ride, my group couldn't find the stop and were looking at a map, so a native passerby led us to it. Second ride was PACKED; bodies pressing from all sides, but everyone made sure that the people around them had something to hold onto. So many people living so close together can be stressful and chaotic for a country mouse like me, but from what I've seen people mostly want to help each other get through the day. And the subways were no dirtier than Boston or San Francisco.
The only thing I fear is that the Wall Street bankers who raped our financial system and took multi-million dollar bonuses in the process will go unpunished.  They should be charged with pre-meditated fraud and have their assets stripped.  And sent to jail.  They are disreputable fraudsters who are no credit to their MBA-mills of Wharton, Harvard etc.  In fact, shame of Wharton and Harvard for training such slime!
The only thing I fear is that the Wall Street bankers who raped our financial system and took multi-million dollar bonuses in the process will go unpunished.  They should be charged with pre-meditated fraud and have their assets stripped.  And sent to jail.  They are disreputable fraudsters who are no credit to their MBA-mills of Wharton, Harvard etc.  In fact, shame of Wharton and Harvard for training such slime!
I am a native New Yorker. Born on Staten Island, lived at Sheepshead Bay.  Military family, we returned to the mid-atlantic area.   I have made many trips to New York. Went to school in Melville, ate dinner in Hicksville, love Long Island also. Just prior to Christmas one year a friend and I rode thru Central Park on horses that were rented, and in one of the most beautiful snowy days ever.   Really miss going Junkin' on Saturdays, entertainment, the people are unique.  I am still like a kid when it comes to NYC----I will always love the place deeply.  
As a New Yorker who rides the subway multiple times a day, I just live a life.  A person is more likely to be hit by a city bus than by a terrorist plot.  If you live a life in fear you live half a life.  
I think this author has his transit systems mixed up. Clean, safe, uncrowded and friendly! He's describing Boston. I am in NYC on a regular basis and the only place it is safe, sorta clean but definitely crowded is the 5 to 10 block area around 57th street. Boston on the other hand is safe, clean and friendly. Far more pleasant to travel on the Boston subway.
My wife and I are transplanted New Yorkers now living 250 miles upstate. We go back with our children as often as possible. We feel safer having them take off together from  Battery Park where we always stay than we would ever feel about them walking around the cities of Syracuse or Buffalo. Having so much culture and diversity is an experience we could never deny them. Where else can one see both top flight public and private museums 2 great zoos, fabulous food and top it off with a Broadway show or the Christmas show at Radio City in the same day? How sweet could it be? Aware of our surroundings?; always, terrified?;never. Go to this city , you'll love it too.
I spent a weekend in New York last August. I flew up to see the Today Show. I took a small backpack with me, with food and a change of clothes. I landed in Ipsland, quickly found a shuttle that took me to a nice comfy train, which in turn took me to the subway. I wrote down the street names where I was dropped off so I could find my way back. I walked around all night, took the subway here and there, slept in Bryant Park and generally had a fabulous time. I loved the subway and wish we had decent public transportation with a nice place to wait underground, out of the weather.
I grew up in New England and have ALWAYS been afraid of New York City. I turned down several trips to NYC and even a Broadway show because of my fear. And that was long before 9/11. But I have to admit, there is something so elegant, so charming, so AMERICAN about NYC. I have to confess I did visit the Statue of Liberty and desperately wanted to stay and see more, but once again fear prevailed. I hope I'll have the cahnce to visit NYC soon.
Born and raised in Brooklyn, New York and I miss it everyday.  The one thing about living in Delaware is that New York is only 3 hours away. Maybe one day I will be able to move back. Great story.
  Happy Thanksgiving
I have been living in NYC for two years. It does have many wonderful things and use the subway several times everyday. One thing I have noticed and said MANY times already is the police do not check people in the subway. They set up station and stand around and talk to each other. They do not use thier time to check out bags and boxes. It is a mess waiting to happen... In two years, I have seen them check two people. Both beautiful young women,only with a small purse- while thousands of people walk right by, some with huge packages and boxes unchecked.
I am always the first to speak highly of our officers but I want to be honest. The police need to get more vigilant and serious about their job to help avoid a possible disaster.
Wonderful article! I just returned from a two-week visit to NYC where I subwayed and hotfooted all over Manhattan and parts of Brooklyn day and night. Whether on city streets, in parks, subway stations or just on foot, I never for one moment felt threatened or uncomfortable. New Yorkers were welcoming, helpful and friendly. I lived in the city during both the early and late 1960s, loved it then and love it even more now.  How sad to say that back home in New Orleans and living two blocks from the famed French Quarter, I feel unsafe outside my building at night and, indeed, at times during the day. Anyone in Manhattan wanna rent a (reasonable-rated!!!) room to a very independent 65-year old arts person?  I'm ready to move back!! The greatest (and maybe safest?) city in the world!!!
Very well said. Living in fear in NYC? Gimme a break!
I have been in New York in more than one occation and I must admit that once there you get the feel of being in the capitol of the world. I to my young family there in 1987 to visit the world trade center. Funy, in one of the noisiest cities in the world the top of the world trade center was pretty quiet.when 9/11 occured I was living in Puerto Rico and remember watching  news of the attack on cnn wile my tears where coming down my face. thank you young for sharring you experience with us and taking us the readers along for the ride and reminding us that we shall never live our lives to the beat of terrorist. But to the beat of the greatest Nation in the world. the United States of America. God Bless us all.
My husband works with the MTA and has to go there every day.  I worry here at home in Pa.  He drives there every morning and comes home every night, most times after working double shifts.  But I am so scared that one day he won't make it back because of these kinds of people.  I knew President Bush would keep us safe, but I'm really worried that this new administration won't do that because they don't want Europe to see us as not cool.
People laugh at me when I say this, but I truly believe that crime is down and the subways are safer because they no longer reek of urine.  Thank you Mayor Giuliani

I'm not kidding...what do you think casues those soccer riots you hear about?
Exactly!  I am not going to stop taking the subway.  Or maybe I should just stay at home every day.  NOT!  

Now instead of being "Amber" or "Orange" afraid, we should be "RED" afraid.  I don't think so.
being prudent is one thing, being fearful and afraid another.   life goes on, with or without us..... sad but true.... the temptations made great music after david ruffin left, and nyc city will continue to thrive despite the threats everyday; the only thing that stops us is ourselves.....
Nice article. I could almost feel I am there. I just got back after a month's visit and wish I could go back for the holiday seasons 'cuz no place looks as beautiful as NY at this time of the year. I pray that the subways stay safe for the NYers there who ride them daily. I worry about my friends and family members who are there.
Have a safe and happy holiday NY!
I grew up in Brooklyn in the fifties when the subway was 10 cents and was clean, safe, fast, and reliable. There was no such thing as a delay nor track fire!. It has been a gross political boondogle ever since. I lived in Queens for 18 years til 1998 and much prefer Queens over Manhattan where I live now but the subways in Queens are abominable. But the MTA execs travel in limos! I can not wait to retire to Florida and let the yuppies and transplants dream as they did in the eighties til they left when the bubble burst in 1987.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):