ABOUT THIS BLOG

In Field Notes, NBC News will shed light on the stories that don't always make the headlines as well as offering analysis on the big and small stories of the day.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the country and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind this blog.



Pioneering ‘domino transplant’ doctor changes lives

Posted: Tuesday, August 04, 2009 3:52 PM

WASHINGTON, D.C. – Just after sunrise on a recent Friday morning, Dr. J. Keith Melancon had a large Starbucks coffee in hand and was gearing up for a long and busy day.

Melancon, 40, was getting ready to spend 12 hours on his feet in an operating room at Georgetown University Hospital where he is the director of the medical center’s thriving kidney and pancreas transplant program. 

Talking to Melancon was Larry McPhatter, who himself was preparing for a big day – McPhatter was about to undergo surgery to donate one of his kidneys.

VIDEO: Donation chain gives hope to transplant recipients


"Don't worry we are going to take good care of you," Melancon told his patient, clasping his hand. "And once again, you’re a hero my man, this is beautiful."

A kidney transplant is a surgery that places a healthy organ in a person who has suffered from kidney failure. Lots of kidneys are needed – more than 485,000 Americans are being treated for kidney failure, according to National Kidney Foundation. 

And the need is higher for minorities – due to high rates of diabetes, high blood pressure and heart disease, African Americans have an increased risk of developing kidney failure.  

In fact, out of the 85,458 Americans currently on the U.S. waitlist for a kidney transplant, 35 percent are black, according to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.  

VIDEO: Dr. Melancon in his own words: 'We can perform thousands more'

McPhatter was getting ready to donate a kidney to a total stranger – so that his wife Elizabeth, who has struggled through kidney dialysis three times a week for two years, could receive a new kidney from someone else.

They were just two people out of 14 involved in the recent kidney transplant chain at Georgetown and MedStar Health's Washington Hospital Center – most of the organ recipients were African American.

‘Domino transplant’
The so-called "domino transplant" matched a group of incompatible donor-recipient pairs (a willing donor whose blood or tissue is not compatible with their loved one in need of a transplant) with other pairs of donor-recipients facing a similar challenge.

In domino transplants, a patient in need of a kidney brings a donor who is compatible with another recipient.  That donation allows the patient to receive another organ from someone else in the kidney swap.

Six males and eight females participated in this particular kidney swap over the course of four days – including two "altruistic donors" who actually knew none of the organ recipients.

Melancon was part of a pioneering team of doctors at Johns Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore who conducted the first six-person kidney swap in April 2008.

The swaps are made possible by using a process called "plasmapheresis," a procedure which filters the recipient’s blood plasma, and makes the likelihood of the recipient’s body rejecting the new organ less likely.

VIDEO: Kidney recipient: 'My life...will be better'

"The whole purpose of the plasmapheresis for these recipients is to remove the harmful antibodies and allow them to be safely transplanted," Meloncon explained.

It was at Johns Hopkins where Melancon, who is African-American, took a special interest in using the process to treat minorities, who have a genetic tendency to build up a lot of antibodies – making it more difficult for them to find a matching organ donor. African Americans in particular have a difficult time building up antibodies.  

During his time at Johns Hopkins, Melancon gained invaluable experience working with a wide variety of patients – many of whom had different blood types and high levels of antibodies that make organ rejection more likely.

"Over four years [at Johns Hopkins], I saw more of those types of patients than most doctors ever see in their lives," he said.

Melancon first became interested in transplant surgery during his residency at Tulane University in New Orleans.

There were two reasons for his interest.

"I actually did a research project when I was in med school on transplant patients. It was the first time I became exposed to young people in New Orleans who had kidney disease," he said. "A lot of them looked like me and were my age … It piqued my interest as to why they had renal disease," he explained, using another term for kidney failure.

The second reason was closer to his heart.

"I had a good friend, Bernard Hurst, one of my fraternity brothers who had kidney disease [and] wound up having a kidney and pancreas transplant."

Changing lives

It was in New Orleans where he met his wife, Lisa.

Melancon said he told her on their first date that he was planning to be a transplant surgeon and if their relationship was going to last, she would have to understand that. They have been married for 14 years now and have four boys between the ages of two and nine.

"My wife is a special person to understand how demanding this career is," he said. "If I am on call or not, even on vacation, I get calls about patients…Your family winds up making these sacrifices along with you."

While the hours are difficult – he sometimes works a 100 hours a week – Melancon loves what he does.

"I feel like the luckiest man alive because it really is a blessing. You get to change people's lives forever," he said.


VIDEO: Kidney donor: 'It's more of a blessing for me'

 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

As a kidney recipient from a living donor, my mother, I can attest to the magnitude of what being a living donor is all about!  I am blessed in so many ways.  Thank You Mom and the University Of Minnesota for this new lease on life. I will celebrate my 10 year Anniversary of my transplant this October!
Until seeing this story, I hadn't realized a person doesn't need both kidneys in order to function (what do I know about kidneys?) That means maybe I can be a kidney donor too.  Maybe someone else's life can also be saved.  I'll be asking my doctor about it tomorrow.  Thank you, and thanks especially to the people in your story for their inspiration.    
HI, MY NAME IS OSCAR I'M 43 YRS OLD AND WAITING FOR A KIDNEY TRANSPLANT. THEY TELL ME I WILL WAIL AT LEAST 4-6 YRS. WILL BE STARTING HOME DIALYSIS WITHIN THE NEXT FEW MONTHS.WE NEED TO EDUCATE MORE DONORS ON HOW SAFE AND LIFE SAVING TRANSPLANTS ARE AND HOW BOTH THE RECIPIENT AND DONOR CAN LEAD NORMAL PRODUCTIVE LIVES. THIS CAN MEAN A SECOND CHANCE AT LIFE FOR THE RECIPENT.  POLYISIC KIDNEY DISEASE RUNS IN MY FAMILY IT IS IN OUR GENES SO FAMILY MEMBERS OF MINE CAN NOT BE DONORS.THE LEAPS IN ANIT-REJECTION MEDICATIONS AND TECHNIQUES HAVE ALLOWED FOR A 96 PERCENT  SUCCESS RATE . THERE ARE FAR TOO MANY PEOPLE WAITING FOR A KIDNEY TRANSPLANT THAT AROUND 43 PERCENT OF US WILL DIE WAITING FOR A TRANSPLANT.I INCOURAGE LIVING INDIVIUALS TO DONATE. I ALSO SEE A NATIONAL NEED FOR LOVE ONES TO DONATE THE ORGANS OF LOVE ONES WHO HAVE DIED. A PART OF THE DONORS LIVE WILL CONTINUE PROVIDING LIFE TO SOMEONE WHO WOULD OTHERWISE DIE WAITING FOR A KIDNEY, LIVER, HEART OR OTHER VIAL ORGAN OR TISSUE.GIVE THE GIVE THAT KEEPS ON GIVING, ORGANS AND TISSUES, GOOD LUCK TO ALL WHO WAIT DAY BY DAY AND NIGHT BY NIGHT FOR A SECOND CHANCE IN LIFE.THANK GOD FOR ALL THE DOCTORS AND THEIR STAFF AND FAMILY. THANK YOU,OSCAR IN TEXAS
God Bless all of you!  You people exemplify what God meant when he said to love others as yourself.  What pure love.
I have thought about becoming a donor many times in the past but I don't know how one gopes about doing that.  If you have any suggestions or knowledge about that perhaps you could provide the information to other potential donors?  Thank you for the story
I have thought about becoming a donor many times in the past but I don't know how one goses about doing that.  If you have any suggestions or knowledge about that perhaps you could provide the information to other potential donors?  Thank you for the story
in light of the current debate over health care, the question needs to be asked:  how were these kidney transplants paid for and how would the reforms being discussed affect this extraordinary undertaking?  thx
I am no scientist.  Armed with an Ivy League degree with no required math or science, I am still intrigued...What is the methodology employed to filter antibodies from blood?  (Talk about a "teachable moment!")
I'd like to see more stories like this on your air. Clearly you spent a long time investigating and following the issues at hand, and for a change, I felt you gave a story the time it deserves. Thank you.
This story touched me so much.  I have a son that has had 4 kidney transplants.  He was only 12 when he got his first (I was his donor) and his fourth when he was 26 (1998).  All the others were cadavers.  
We have always wanted to meet the families of the donors but lifebanc resisted.  The last was a 12 year old girl and we will finally be meeting her parents in Nashville next week.  To see these people that can do this for someone else is a tremendous sacrifice that can literally save a person's life.  Dialysis is so harsh but the only way to stay alive.  Last year Dave was considering going off dialysis knowing that he could not live more than a couple of weeks if he did that.  
He lost the last transplant 2 1/2 years ago and was back on dialysis but it was only removed last Sept.  I hope the story that was done will encourage more people to become donors.  When Dave lost his first kidney, he was on dialysis for 6 years before a second kidney could be found.  There is such a need.
Thank you for the story and thank God for this doctor!
Thank you so much for the wonderful story about people who voluntered to have one of their kidneys taken out to help someone who desperately needed one.  I'd like to find out how I could help others in need of a kidney. What I need to do to donate one of mine to help someone in need.  Thank You.  
I saw the news today and praised God when I saw the  Making a Difference segment n NBC News. I've been sick since 2002 with an autoimmune disease called Scleroderma. 2 months ago my pulmonologist told me that the disease has destroyed both lungs and I was referred to Univ. Hospital in Denver, Co. Everything was going great and then I went in for 3 days of tests. All the tests went well and I thought I would be put on a transplant list. A week later the hospital called and said they found antigens in my blood that would cause me to reject 85% of the donors.Everthing came to a halt!!! Dr. Melancon has discovered this to be true with his kidney transplant patients, BUT he has found a procedure to stop it so they can still have the transplant.WOW. Is there some way that Dr. Melancon can give this information to my doctor here in Colorado!!?? His name is Dr. Zamora at Unive Hospital..720-848-2241 the Fax is 720-848-2242
This broadcast may have saved my life...I had given up hope!! Thank You..

Lydia Constant
5180 Coneflower Lane
Colorado Springs, Colorado
719-638-6095 (home)
719-466-1708 (cell)
This story actually brought hope to my somewhat hopeless situation. I have had ESRD for over 30 years. In that time I have had 2 kidney transplant the at age 13 last 10 years and the second at age 27 last 18 months. Now at 43 I have been on the tranplant waiting list for 10 years.
My husband is waiting for a kidney transplant and hearing stories like this gives us a very precious thing- hope. Thank you so much for bringing this issue to the forefront.  Knowledge is power and knowledge is hope. Just wish you guys had mentioned that kidney donation has been definitively proven NOT to shorten the life expectancy of the donor!  Thank you, thank you!
Thank you for your report ..After 10 years of kidney dialysis I just recieved a life giving kidney on June 19th, my birthday, at the UCLA Medical Center. I pray that people will see the report, get tested and give someone that second chance of life. The sacrifice given by my young deceased donor will allow me to see my daughters and young son married and my future gradchildren. Perhaps you were created for such a time as this.
IT IS GREAT - IDONT KNOW ALL THIS PROCEDURE. I HAVE PROBLEM WITH MY KIDNEY,
Dear Dr. Melancon.
I have my sister in law which is a doctor in Israel in need for a kidney transplant. Is it any way she can benefit of having a donor. She is 63 years old on dialysis still working helping the arab population in Nazareth Illit. Is it any way we can help her so she can continue working helping people.
Thank you for sharing your experience with us. Many years of good practice giving people a chance for a second life.
Sincerely,
Carol Oximberg
This is a great effort.  We know that we need more African American organ donors in general.
Dear Dr. Melancon,

Thank you so very much for your tremendous dedication to what you do. Thanks to your family as well for giving up so much time they would otherwise spend with you. It's a beautiful gift you help give your patients and it makes better lives possible. Clearly so many people do not get a kidney donor in time (as well as many other transplant patients in desperate need) and that takes precious lives. It's a tragedy.
Your family must be extremely proud of you. You are indeed a very good person. Here's a heartwarming shout out to the people who donate organs. Everyone involved is very brave.
This is fantastic.  Such wonderful people to give life to strangers.  My son is 48 years old and has been on dialysis 2 yrs.. 3 times a week.  He is on the transplant list, but he is getting weaker.  I just pray that he can live long enough to receive a kidney.
I am a kidney donor myself and think that this whole domino donation process is a wonderful thing. It is a blessing that this doctor makes this happen and that people can come together for this.
I live in Indiana and I am about to undergo the same donor chain operation with me recieving and my husband is giving a kidney so that I can recieve one. I have been on the transplant list for 3 years. I have O+ blood and a high antibody count. I am also a 37 yr. old African-American female with 3 kids. Before this opportunity came along I had tested 6 members of my own family who ended up not matching me. It has been very frustrating to say the least. I have been scheduled for this procedure in less than a month and I am praying nothing goes wrong. It was a good samaritan donor who started the process along with another husband and wife. This will be the first donor chain procedure in Indiana I am told and I am thankful for people like the good samaritan ,Dr. Melancon, and my transplant coordinators and doctors at Indiana University who have continued to strive to find ways to improve the lives of "all" dialysis patients they are treating. Please add us to your prayers.
This is a report from Tuesday's NBC Nightly News but it is incomplete.  I would like to know the costs involved in this project, who paid for it and how such a project might fare, hypothetically, with health care reform.
I'd like to learn more about being a kidney donor.  Can you please tell me how I can contact someone on Dr. Melancon's staff so that I can ask questions.
I was a kidney recipient in July 2007. I never was able to personally thank the family of the woman who was in the accident that I received the kidney from. It must have been extrememly hard for a family to cope with a decision like this.  God Bless them and thank you.
My wife has received a kidney and pancreas. Keith actually performed the pancreas surgery (yeah it's me Keith, I'm gonna talk you up) My wife and I (and Kailyn our daughter) can't thank Keith enough for what he's done for us. He's been a lot more then just a doctor, he and his family have become good friends. I was luck enough to match my wife and actually donated my kidney to her in 2003. She then received the pancreas in 2005. A persons quality of life is the main issue here and is the reason why we do a lot of work trying to get the work out about organ donation around home here. Everyone should at a minimum be a registered organ donor, and should really consider living donation to people on the kidney list. It truely is something you can do to save anothers life. Again, thanks Keith and thanks to all the people that work in the clinics and follow up after the surgery. They don't get enough thanks. If anyone has any questions about donation or receipt of an organ, my wife and I would be happy to talk to you.
My mother is on dialysis and my sister, brother & myself are not able to donate a kidney.  My brother-in-law stepped up the minute we were made aware of her situation.  My mom has the anti-bodies so that was an issue for her.  Recently, we read an article in our local paper about Dr. Robert Montgomery at Johns Hopkins Hospital who specializes in "in-compatible" patients.  This is his speciality and we've been in contact with his deparment. Since my mom HAS a donor, they quickly mailed out a packet to her to start the process.  Lots of forms to be completed by her and her doctors.  My mother is on medicare and her insurance will pay not only her expenses, but the expenses of the donor, my brother-in-law. Please check with your insurance company to see what they cover for you and your donor if you aren't on medicare.  Living donor transplants are getting more news coverage but the word still needs to get out there.  It's the most wonderful gift a person can give regardless of whether they know the person or not.  Our wish and hope is that my mom & brother-in-law get the call soon from Johns Hopkins.  Go to their website and look up this doctor.  
I'm glad publicity about this "domino" transplantation was on TV as well. I, too, received a cadaver kidney because some unknown family donated their loved one's organs so that others would have a better quality of life.  I had been on dialysis for 5 yrs. & would have passed soon without that kidney.  Sign donor cards & donate a kidney to a friend, family member, or anyone who is on dialysis.  Thank You is such an inadequate term, but it is all we can do to show how grateful we are.
This is a heart warming story and a very positive one.  Unfortunately, the author was a little misleading in regards to the overall benefits of plasmapheresis.  While it is true it removes the antibodies, it does so for only a short period of time.  The immune system will reform those antibodies in a mater of days.  It does benefit in that it allows the transplant to take place and gives the antirejection drugs the opportunity to work before rejection can happen.  It has change transplantation for the better.  However, it has not changed the long term outcome for transplant recipients.  If you are receiving a transplant, be sure to work with your doctors when it comes to your immunosuppression.  Listen to their advice and take the drugs.  Even if you are feeling great and don't feel like you need them, you do.  Too many organs are lost simply because the patient has stopped taking their drugs.  Also, be proactive after your transplant takes place.  Make sure that your doctor is taking the nescessary precautions to monitor your antibodies levels.  Research data show that antibodies that are specific for the donor organ are directly related to and the primary cause of chronic rejection.  If you are making antibodies to your donor organ(s) there are new drugs that can kill the cells that are producing those antibodies, talk to your doctors about them.  And to answer the question about payment, most likely Medicare paid for this transplant.
I've been on dialysis for 2-1/2 years now and am doing fairly well, but it's such a time-killer and is just not the same as having a real kidney. For those who wondered about payment, most insurance companies (and Medicare, which does cover end-stage renal disease (ESRD)) are glad to pay for surgery rather than pay the continuing and very high costs of dialysis treatments. None of my family members are matches for me, or they have kidney disease themselves, so I continue to wait.  
Wow, what a wonderful story! :-) Its great to know that there are people out there who will donate their kidney so that someone else can live a good life.

It will be a marvelous day when doctors can simply grow new kindeys from the donor's cells.  We already have the technology to do this; we just need a big research investment from the government.  This tech needs to be available to all! :-)
When my brother needed a lung transplant, I volunteered (they can do partials), and my insurance and his would have covered the expenses.  However, it was not to be as he developed pneumonia and ultimately died just after his 30th birthday.

Since he first was advised of his need, my family has been active in the organ donor volunteer program.  Even 16 years later.  Go Team Philly!

As for me, I was almost a donor for a friend and it would have been a swap.  However, the other donor wasn't interested in donating to a stranger.  Luckily, my friend received a cadaver transplant and is doing well.

In the meantime, I have been called twice as a potential bone marrow donor and continue to do Red Cross Apheresis donations every two weeks.
I too would like more about donating one of my kidneys.  I'm 48 year old white woman (if that makes any diffence).  Does my insurance pay for it does the recipient's insurance pay?  It would be an honor to help someone.  Thank You
My family was VERY blessed the day a wonderful, selfless family in Nebraska brought hope into our lives by donating their family members organs. My father received a kidney and is doing wonderfully. Please speak to your loved ones about become donors. You never know whose life you may save in the process!
I am not sure about the numbers but there are many patients waiting for a liver transplant. YES, you can be a live donor for livers as well. Years ago I was to donate part of my liver to my father but fortunately another donor was found in time. I wish I could thank that family personally. So everyone out there touched by this article, please, atleast register yourself as an organ donor. By God we know we can't take them with us.
Perpetual racial disinformation by not being balanced; racial victimology implied but never the total picture in the liberal media. Example : 35 percent of patients who need kidneys are black is stated here, implied under-served population based on their race; but no mention of the scarcity percentage
of black donors of kidneys or any other tissue or organ donation when contrasted by the white population.
My son, a NYC police office, recently received a kidney from my daughter approximately two weeks ago.  After being on dialysis for two years, he tells us that it is indescribable how much better he is feeling. The advances in the transplant procedure allowed my daughter to go home the day after and my son the second day after. It is truly a blessing and I hope more African Americans realize that they can lead a normal, rewarding life with one kidney. My daughter said it is the best thing she has ever done in her life except for giving birth to her children.  She feels that is was just as rewarding for her as it was for my son.  God is still in the business of miracles. God's Peace!!!
What a wonderful article.  I am 33 years old and I had a kidney transplant in April 2008.  My mom donated one of her kidneys.  I was very fortunate that I had three matches (mom, dad, sister).  I just pray that this kidney lasts a long time.  I've had kidney damage since the day I was born. When I was a day old, I was given heparin, except I was not given an infant dose, I was given an adult dose. I started bleeding internally and went into shock. I was in surgery for 8 hours. I was a miracle baby. My kidneys have never functioned at 100%.  I wish more people would consider organ donation.
For those of you interested in donating or helping:

Helpful information can  bewith your local OPO  (Organ Procurement Organization): http://www.aopo.org/aopo/

Check out the United Network for Organ Sharing as well: http://www.unos.org/

I know my local OPOO links and info: http://www.core.org/Partners.asp

I am a liver recipient myself.  I was so excited to get to meet the "Father of Modern Transplantation", Dr. Thomas Starzl recently. Amazing what they can do in medicine nowadays!
I am sure there are a lot of us reading this article that are thinking where can we go to donate? I know that there would be a line just waiting to help,myself included.  
my daughter has been on dialysis for 6 yrs and it's taking it's toll. Her sister donated a kidney to her but the organ did not get blood flow, and failed. So she is on the wait list since no other family members match. Someone asked where they could go to donate. Try going to http://www.floodsisters.org/ and register as a donor. The GIFT OF LIFE is such a precious and unselfish act of humanity. Many Thanks to NBC for the awareness of donation
I am so pleased to read this story.  I donated a kidney to my husband in May of 2000 and it lasted 4 years.  Unfortunately he got food poisoning which led to his kidney rejection.  He has been back on dialysis for about 5 years now and he is at the very top of the list but has not found a match yet. His transplant was at the Washington Hospital Center in DC which is known for successful organ transplants. It has been hard to find a donor because people (including his friends and family)have not been educated on the need for African American donors and how simple it is to donate.
As a liver recipient. i can not express the love for live donors or the families of donors. To be able to give such a wonderful gift.Donors are true angles..
In response to Diane Carpenter, Port Orange, Fla., I think you are a wonderful person to want to be an organ donor.  I will keep you in my prayers that the perfect recipient will get a second chance at life because of you!
I am so pleased to read this story.  I donated a kidney to my husband in May of 2000 and it lasted 4 years.  Unfortunately he got food poisoning which led to his kidney rejection.  He has been back on dialysis for about 5 years now and he is at the very top of the list but has not found a match yet. His transplant was at the Washington Hospital Center in DC which is known for successful organ transplants. It has been hard to find a donor because people (including his friends and family)have not been educated on the need for African American donors and how simple it is to donate.
Here a some links that may help those interested in the possibility of becoming a living donor.  

http://www.matchingdonors.com/life/index.cfm

http://www.unos.org/

http://www.organdonor.gov/

http://www.kidney.org/transplantation/livingDonors/index.cfm

http://www.donatelife.net/

When I was almost a donor, I had documents to fill out as to all the why's, and also acknowledging understanding of the rules and logistics.  

Here is the local OPO for me...
http://www.donors1.org/


To those considering home Dialysis...my sister died a few months ago.She was doing fine until the home dialysis. In retrospect and after talking to many dialysis patients, I highly reccommend that you remain with a dialysis center.
My daughter, Jessica, has recieved 2 livers and a kidney transplant.  Before the kidney transplant she was spending 5-6 hours a day/3 days a week in the hospital getting dialysis.  Afterwards she was tired and worn out.  Her mom donated a kidney and was only in the hospital 3 days.  Jessica is now trying out for the high school swim team.  Her life is not totally normal but to see her playing and being a teenager is a mircle.  If you have any questions about going through the process of getting or giving a kidney please contact us at  Tandy@jtoenterprises.com or visit our web site and click on Jessica's story upper right hand corner.
If you would like more info on kidney transplants, visit www.pairedkidneynetwork.org  There you will find info on transplantation and participating hospitals.
For all the questions on how to become a kidney donor, start here:

http://www.kidney.org/transplantation/livingdonors/infoQA.cfm


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):