ABOUT THIS BLOG

In Field Notes, NBC News will shed light on the stories that don't always make the headlines as well as offering analysis on the big and small stories of the day.

Regular contributors include NBC News correspondents, producers and staff based in bureaus across the country and on assignment.

Click here to read more about the journalists behind this blog.



Pioneering ‘domino transplant’ doctor changes lives

Posted: Tuesday, August 04, 2009 3:52 PM

WASHINGTON, D.C. – Just after sunrise on a recent Friday morning, Dr. J. Keith Melancon had a large Starbucks coffee in hand and was gearing up for a long and busy day.

Melancon, 40, was getting ready to spend 12 hours on his feet in an operating room at Georgetown University Hospital where he is the director of the medical center’s thriving kidney and pancreas transplant program. 

Talking to Melancon was Larry McPhatter, who himself was preparing for a big day – McPhatter was about to undergo surgery to donate one of his kidneys.

VIDEO: Donation chain gives hope to transplant recipients


"Don't worry we are going to take good care of you," Melancon told his patient, clasping his hand. "And once again, you’re a hero my man, this is beautiful."

A kidney transplant is a surgery that places a healthy organ in a person who has suffered from kidney failure. Lots of kidneys are needed – more than 485,000 Americans are being treated for kidney failure, according to National Kidney Foundation. 

And the need is higher for minorities – due to high rates of diabetes, high blood pressure and heart disease, African Americans have an increased risk of developing kidney failure.  

In fact, out of the 85,458 Americans currently on the U.S. waitlist for a kidney transplant, 35 percent are black, according to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.  

VIDEO: Dr. Melancon in his own words: 'We can perform thousands more'

McPhatter was getting ready to donate a kidney to a total stranger – so that his wife Elizabeth, who has struggled through kidney dialysis three times a week for two years, could receive a new kidney from someone else.

They were just two people out of 14 involved in the recent kidney transplant chain at Georgetown and MedStar Health's Washington Hospital Center – most of the organ recipients were African American.

‘Domino transplant’
The so-called "domino transplant" matched a group of incompatible donor-recipient pairs (a willing donor whose blood or tissue is not compatible with their loved one in need of a transplant) with other pairs of donor-recipients facing a similar challenge.

In domino transplants, a patient in need of a kidney brings a donor who is compatible with another recipient.  That donation allows the patient to receive another organ from someone else in the kidney swap.

Six males and eight females participated in this particular kidney swap over the course of four days – including two "altruistic donors" who actually knew none of the organ recipients.

Melancon was part of a pioneering team of doctors at Johns Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore who conducted the first six-person kidney swap in April 2008.

The swaps are made possible by using a process called "plasmapheresis," a procedure which filters the recipient’s blood plasma, and makes the likelihood of the recipient’s body rejecting the new organ less likely.

VIDEO: Kidney recipient: 'My life...will be better'

"The whole purpose of the plasmapheresis for these recipients is to remove the harmful antibodies and allow them to be safely transplanted," Meloncon explained.

It was at Johns Hopkins where Melancon, who is African-American, took a special interest in using the process to treat minorities, who have a genetic tendency to build up a lot of antibodies – making it more difficult for them to find a matching organ donor. African Americans in particular have a difficult time building up antibodies.  

During his time at Johns Hopkins, Melancon gained invaluable experience working with a wide variety of patients – many of whom had different blood types and high levels of antibodies that make organ rejection more likely.

"Over four years [at Johns Hopkins], I saw more of those types of patients than most doctors ever see in their lives," he said.

Melancon first became interested in transplant surgery during his residency at Tulane University in New Orleans.

There were two reasons for his interest.

"I actually did a research project when I was in med school on transplant patients. It was the first time I became exposed to young people in New Orleans who had kidney disease," he said. "A lot of them looked like me and were my age … It piqued my interest as to why they had renal disease," he explained, using another term for kidney failure.

The second reason was closer to his heart.

"I had a good friend, Bernard Hurst, one of my fraternity brothers who had kidney disease [and] wound up having a kidney and pancreas transplant."

Changing lives

It was in New Orleans where he met his wife, Lisa.

Melancon said he told her on their first date that he was planning to be a transplant surgeon and if their relationship was going to last, she would have to understand that. They have been married for 14 years now and have four boys between the ages of two and nine.

"My wife is a special person to understand how demanding this career is," he said. "If I am on call or not, even on vacation, I get calls about patients…Your family winds up making these sacrifices along with you."

While the hours are difficult – he sometimes works a 100 hours a week – Melancon loves what he does.

"I feel like the luckiest man alive because it really is a blessing. You get to change people's lives forever," he said.


VIDEO: Kidney donor: 'It's more of a blessing for me'

 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

If you would like more info on kidney transplants, visit www.pairedkidneynetwork.org  There you will find info on transplantation and participating hospitals.
To register as a possible donor please review http://www.floodsisters.org/
Please consider the GIFT OF LIFE
http://www.core.org/  Check out this site; Center for Organ Recovery & Education.  CORE, like UNOS, is a national organization that has other members throughout the USA.  They work with each other to match those so willing to give to patients in need.  It's a wonderful program so please, if you are willing to donate a kidney, check out this website and the many others shown above.  Ask your family doctor - since many work in hospitals, they can direct you as well.  DCI is a national dialysis clinic and they would also have information.  It's out there people and to those of you who, after seeing this news segment, are seriously considering being a living donor, I WANT TO THANK YOU FROM THE VERY BOTTOM OF MY HEART.  Spread the word.  That's the only way others will find out.  Thank you.
This article was forwarded to me in response to my story that aired on Channel 10 News San Diego last night. Links below. I'm so happy for everyone involved in the story.
http://www.10news.com/news/20284364/detail.html
http://sandiego.craigslist.org/csd/com/1304235253.html
Your story about Organ Donation highlighted the tragic shortage of human organs for transplant operations.

Over half of the 100,000 Americans on the national transplant waiting list will die before they get a transplant.  Most of these deaths are needless.  Americans bury or cremate 20,000 transplantable organs every year.

There is a simple way to put a big dent in the organ shortage – give donated organs first to people who have agreed to donate their own organs when they die.

Giving organs first to organ donors will convince more people to register as organ donors.  It will also make the organ allocation system fairer.  People who aren't willing to share the gift of life should go to the back of the waiting list as long as there is a shortage of organs.

Anyone who wants to donate their organs to others who have agreed to donate theirs can join LifeSharers.  LifeSharers is a non-profit network of organ donors who agree to offer their organs first to other organ donors when they die.  Membership is free at www.lifesharers.org or by calling 1-888-ORGAN88.  There is no age limit, parents can enroll their minor children, and no one is excluded due to any pre-existing medical condition.  LifeSharers has over 12,000 members at this writing, including 714 members in New York.

Please contact me - Dave Undis, Executive Director of LifeSharers - if your viewers would like to learn more about our innovative approach to increasing the number of organ donors.  I can arrange interviews with some of our local members if you're interested.  My email address is daveundis@lifesharers.org.  My phone number is 615-351-8622.


My father has been diabetic since he was 2 years old.  Several years ago he was placed on the transplant list for a kidney and pancreas and also started dialysis.  He could have just gone with a kidney, but decided that if he was going to go thru with this, he wanted to "fix" everything.  After one false alarm, the call came around midnight that there was a kidney and pancreas for him, so it was off to  the Cleveland Clinic again.  My parents live in Cleveland, so it was just a short drive.  My sister and I are near Chicago.  That was the longest 6 hours of my life!  After 6 hours of surgery the doctor came out and told us it was a success.  Not long after my dad was in recovery, we were told the pancreas was working and his blood sugar was stable, the kidney  had also started producing urine.  
We don't know much about the donor except that he was young.  I am very thankful to that family and sad for them at the same time.  They have lost a family member, but they also made it possible for my father to have a better life.  
To Lydia in Colorado, my mother also suffers from Scleroderma and has been for 15 years.  Her lungs have also been damaged and she is in need of a transplant.  After 3 years of testing and rejections by several hospitals (my mother also has damage to her esophagus which makes the transplant very risky) she has finally been placed on the list in our area (#1) just within the last couple of months.  We have had a couple of false starts but we are still very hopeful.  I just wanted to wish you the best because I know how difficult this disease is and I will be praying for you.
Such magnificent human beings. KUDOS to MSNBC for its great story and coverage.

NOTHING can be more important in this regard than simply getting the word out to people, especially African-Americans; nothing!

In truth, there is no actual need for living donors; more than a million people die every year in this country, no less than half of whom have great kidneys, livers, pancreas, etc.
PLEASE GET THE WORD OUT. TELL BLACK PEOPLE THEY CAN SAVE THEIR OWN RACE simply by marking their license to be an organ donor. Less talking, more doing!
I donated my kidney to my mom last July.  Before the transplant she devloped antibodies which were wiped out by a procedure called Plasmapheresis. She was fine and did not show any antibodies for almost a year, then the antibody level went up again.

Not only did she receive plasmapheresis (which was not as effective as it was the first time) she was given 4 treatments of Velcade, a medication traditionally used to treat skin cancer. It was been used and proven effective on post-transplant patients who have developed antibodies. From what I understand, the Velcade kills the cell that creat the antibodies so they won't return like they may with Plasmapheresis alone.

I hope you all are well.  
Monica
To all of those on the waiting list, hang in there! My dad had a kidney/pancreas transplant in 1996 and is still problem free to this day--it is possible!  My dad's donor was a 19 year old kid that had died in a car accident.  Thanks to organ donors, my dad got to see my 13th birthday (and many more!).  Even if you aren't comfortable being a living donor, the very least all of us can do is sign up to be an organ donor on your driver's license.  It not only saves the recipient's lives, but gives their family and friends many more healthy years.
I became a living donor to my husband on Feb. 19, 2008.  Both of us are doing very well.  I would donate again if I had another kidney to give away.  The transplant staff at Beth Israel Hospital in Boston, MA is top notch.  This was my huband's 2nd kindney transplant, the first, from his father ,lasted almost 8 years.  We are almost 18 months into this 2nd kidney transplant and he is doing the best I have seen in many years.  We were also blessed with a pancreas transplant 8 years ago and are grateful to the family that donated.  

The life changes it brought to our marriage and 2 beautiful teenagers is just inexplicable.  My husband has been able to watch our children grow and we will celebrate our 18th wedding anniversary this fall.  My now 16 year old daughter wants to be a transplant surgeon to help others just has her dad has been helped.  
God does send us angels.  Praise the Lord.
I've had my kidney transplant on November 12, 1981!!  Everything is still fine.  Fortunately I had a older brother the was a A-match so there was little rejection at first.  To people who have not donated but have thought of it I say to you "JUST DO IT". not only we you save a lief but will change yours for better.
No you don't need both of your kidneys and if you donate a kidney and later run into trouble you co to the top of the list.  Please consider donating a kidney, my brother is waiting for one (I'm unable to donate, if I could I would).
Organ donation is wonderful; my husband is a live kidney donor unfortunately, the recipient lost the kidney after only a few short years.  Those contemplating donating a kidney should also consider years down the road if they should be afflicted with a disease that would directly affect their one kidney.  How would they feel then about donating and if they are still ok with it then go for it...Unfortunately my husband now has a disease which directly affects his one kidney and grapples with the "what if I didn't donate".  I share this not to discourage, but to bring awareness.
Great article, and great people! One is prompted to ask why more emphasis isn't put on preventing the illness to begin with? What in the African american population makes their numbers so high? There must be an answer, such as preventing the obesity that must be behind a great number of these cases. Are these people trying to help themselves first, or counting on organ transplants to solve their problems? If given transplants, what prevents a repeat if there are no changes in their lives?
I know first hand the incomprehensible joy of helping someone else through organ donation.  On Dec. 6, 2001 I donated 55% of my liver to a person who was a stranger at that time.  She is now a good friend of mine and has lived to see 2 granddaughters born.  I had no problems with the donation and incurred no expenses.  My recipient's insurance paid for it all.  The need for organ donation is great. 19 persons die everyday waiting for an organ.  Register with your BMV to be a donor or contact your organ/tissue procurement organization to register.  Donation is the gift that keeps on giving and you will be rewarded in the knowledge that you did something wonderful for a person in need.
Sonebody, anybody;  please, tell me WHO is paying the tab for ALL of this surery??

I don't believe that the tax payer should be shouldering the tab.  Nor do I believe that the average medical insurance patient should pay higher fees just so such s very small percentages of Americans should have a new lease on life.

But please, tell me, who is paying?  Is this why my insurance rates are so high?  I have never had a medical claim even approaching what I have to pay my dentist for the generic root canal or crown, but yet my medical insurance premiums are sky high, and going higher every year - without filinf any claims.

So please, again, tell me, who is paying for these transplants.  If it is ME, then I demand a vote on how my dollars are being spent.

My brother dies of polio, and none of you came forward to pay the medical bills.  I know, because my parents went bankrupt for him, and I ended up paying the creditors to clear their name.

So please.  Tell me: WHO IS PAYING FOR THESE SURGERIES????????
I am a white female, 54 years old and mother of 3.  Happily married too after 33 years!  Most of these comments come from the mid-west and east coast.  I live in Portland, Oregon.  I have PKD and have about 20-30% kidney function.  My disease also includes my pancreas and a VERY large liver.  When I reach 20% for sure my doctor will then put me on a transplant list.  Does anyone know anything about the programs here in Portland?  I am in the nursing profession and would love nothing more than to give but I never will. Thank you to all who give, either families of loved ones, gone or living, your sacrifice is angelic.  My love and prayers to all of you and all of us who need you, you are truly blessed.
I am a transplant recipient for 14 years, diabetic, and doing very well.  My sister was the donor.  I am very greatful for the donors, she went through some discomfort but I'm here due to her and she is very healthy and doesn't miss her kidney.  Thanks to her I am healthy.
A long with my above comment, can a white person give to an Afro American person or vice versa?
I love the idea of the domino transplant surgery,  What a wonderful concept.  I would like to see that practiced in every state.  I have had the same transplanted kidney for 29 years.  Knowing my time is coming where I will need another kidney in the next few years.  I only hope that is in practice when I an in need of the next transplant
my pretty daughter pass a way on 8/25/95.from a car accident.she was only 24yrs old.she was the mother of a 3yrs old child.i didnot think twice about donating her organs.my baby saved 5 people.i only heard from one person.she was so happy.i worked in transplant for 15yrs.all these patient wont to do is live.i have always been a donor.i wish every one would donate their organs.
In response to the readers who wondered how much kidney transplants cost and the impact on health care reform - please consider that the cost of dialysis averages about $70,000 per person per year. A kidney transplant costs about 4125,000, then the care is about $25,000 per year. So the break-even point is around two years, and then the government begins saving money.  People who receive a living donor transplant generally fare much better, as kidneys from living donors last, on average, twice as long as deceased donor kidneys.

I work with the Alliance for Paired Donation, the organization that pioneered Non-simultaneous Extended Altruistic Donor Chains in 2007. For more information, please visit our Web site at www.paireddonation.org.

Thanks for this wonderful story and congratulations to all the participants in the chain.  
What a "hopeful article".  I am in my 4th year of peritoneal dialysis, waiting also for a transplant.  I have done 2 round of IVIG treatments to help my anti-body problem.  I'm due to see the transplant doctor and will ask about plasmapheresis, besides doing my own research.  More education needed regarding kidney donation.
I recieved a kidney from my sister 3 years ago. People need to know just how important it is to be an organ donor. Thanks for the story maybe it will help save a life.
I am a kidney donor. I gave my kidney to my mother in April of 1976. The transplant to took place at UPMC Medical center in Pgh.. Pa.. My mother, 5 of my 9 siblings, suffer from PKD. Three of my siblings  received kidneys from accident victims. Two have them have passed from other than kidney related problems. My baby sister is doing very well. I understand that I was the first child to give a kidney to a parent in the US. Prior to my surgery a federal law existed that prevented it. I was on actve duty in the Air Force at the time. So when you think about all of the cards that had to fall exactly into place for my mother such as federal law changing, the surgeon general approving my request to give my mother a kidney, the Air Force approving my request, me being 1 of 10 children and not having PKD, and then the successful surgery in 1976 when transplanting organs was not as common or successful as it is today. It's nothing short of miraculous. We live in amazing times.
I am 55 years old and have been back on dialysis for two months after a failed kidney transplant.  I received my first kidney from my sister two years ago.  I, too, went through plasmapheresis due to the many antibodies I have.  I am back on the transplant list and awaiting a new kidney.  I do not have any more matches in my family, but my son and husband are going to be tested to participate in the domino transplant program.  Even with the issues I had with rejection of the first kidney transplant, I must say that my quality of life was so much better than it is when on dialysis.  Anyone interested in participating should contact any of the links posted in above comments.  If you're in Indiana you can also contact the Indiana University Hospital transplant center, 800-382-4602, and inquire with a transplant coordinator.  The recipient's insurance pays for any expenses related to the transplant for the donor.
I saw this story on NBC Nightly News and the recipients, donors, Dr. and other staff touched my heart. Thank you.
My husband and I are both kidney donors. He gave a kidney to his dad in 2003 and his dad is still doing very well. I gave a kidney to a stranger (now my "kidney sister") last July. She is also doing extremely well. She is black and I am white. She told me that she had prayed for a white donor, having something to do with the higher incidence of kidney problems in African Americans. I didn't understand it, but this article makes it a bit clearer. I am so thankful to have been able to do this and consider it one of the biggest gifts I could have ever been given in my lifetime. Now my husband and I raise awareness for organ donation through a non-profit called Team Donate Life.
I have a brother in law at Tulane who is Chief of Renal and dedicates many hours away from MY sisiter na dchildren to take care of others He was a hero during Katrina, risking his own life to try and get care to all the hospital pts on dialysis during the storm.My sister is a hero too to understand his dedication to his work and the help he gives to others. I am proud of both Dr Lee Hamm and his wife Connie. P Meadows Decatur Al 3


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):