Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Dave, LV — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 13:14:59 GMT

It's good to know the word "honor" still has meaning.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

SSG Andrew McCulloch USA (RET) — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 13:17:11 GMT

Semper Fi! A fine tribute to a fallen Hero. May his soul rest on Fiddlers' Green.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Gary Gaudioso Brookfield, CT. — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 13:51:18 GMT

The raising of that flag on Iwo Jima guaranteed that there would be a United States Marine Cor. for the next 100 years. God bless the USMC. and all of the men who fought and died to give us the freedom we have today.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Raymond Murray — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 13:53:52 GMT

God bless this man for giving his life for this country.
Why did it take so long to recognize what he did for us?
I think we need to name a special holliday in his honor.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Raymond Murray, South Carolina — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 14:01:01 GMT

God bless this man for giving his life for this country.
Why did it take so long to recognize what he did for us?
I think we need to name a special holliday in his honor.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

David P. Manchester, Connecticut — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 14:11:30 GMT

My Father-in-law is an ex-USMC WWII Marine. A lot of his friends died in the Pacific Theater. He talks very little about the war. I've read up on the battle of Iwo and Michael Strank. Great story and truly fitting to a hero.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Lary Freeland, Atlanta, Ga — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 14:34:18 GMT

There were six Men who raised the flag, not five. Three were killed on Iwo Jima, before the remaining three were sent home to participate in U.S. Bond Fund Drives. Sgt. Michael Strank, USMC, was on of the three Marines killed.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Lary Freeland, Atlanta, Ga — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 14:35:11 GMT

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Paul Barr, Williamsport, MD — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 14:39:34 GMT

So many brave men from that generation. Its no wonder the US prospered so greatly after WWII. Its nice to see this one man remembered and more comfortable to know he is resting in peace on American soil. God Bless him for giving his life for our great country.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

John, SSgt, USAF, Whiteman AFB, MO — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 14:47:37 GMT

Interesting fact about Iwo.. The picture taken was one of two. The "famous" picture was actually the second one taken. The original flag was put abourd a Navy ship off the island. This is according to a book called Industructible that I read.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

C.S, Owings Mills, MD — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 15:03:39 GMT

As he supported to raise the flag,
he did so not knowing his commemortive statue
that would adorn Our Nation's Capital forever.
I know the "picture has a thousand words", but the look of hoe and victory is seen in those men's eyes.
They will never be forgotten and no one will ever achieve such a highlighted moment. It shows what America is made of and if everyone would see, the honor our Armed Forces bring, to this country, it would be a more peaceful nation.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Ernie Temple, South Plainfield, NJ — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 15:06:30 GMT

Kate Smith, an old singer from the 40's said it the best, "GOD BLESS AMERICA". Semper Fi Sgt. Strank!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Joe Pelot, HMC(SW/FMF), USN, Ret., MD — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 15:11:10 GMT

The write-up says 'Strank, a Navy Corpsman and four other Marines are depicted on the huge bronze memorial hoisting the flag over the volcanic island on Feb. 23, 1945'.

The Corpsman was Pharmacist Mate Second Class John Bradley. Strank, to best of my knowledge was a Marine Sergeant.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Byron, Dublin NC — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 15:24:20 GMT

Without a doubt an inspiring story of dedication and heroism however, the lead point of the government taking 63 years to confer citizenship on this hero should not be forgotten.
Nor should the hundreds if not thousands of immigrant service people who have served our country in battle and out since World War II who are still waiting for their citizenship be made to wait any longer. Contact your Senators and Representatives and ask why any service person with an honorable discharge is not given priority and respect in their goal of US citizenship.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Amy Nona — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 15:26:43 GMT

These men and even women were so devoted to the nation, and so brave--they paid a high price for us to be doing what we do today. Most people today take everything for granted and don't even stop to think of the past.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

R Tesch, Salt Lake City, Ut — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 15:26:58 GMT

Its nice to see this honor finally given to this soldier. I am so appreciative of all those who serve this country in these delicate times. It is important that Sen McCain who understands the importance of a strong military be elected - not pretty boy Obama

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

A Humble Son — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 15:41:39 GMT

No person "Gives" their life. They knew what they were up against and the odds that they may not make it out alive. It is not a willing handover of your life. I hate the phrase that someone "Gave" their life. IT WAS TAKEN FROM THEM! Their honor is in knowing they put themselves in harm's way with the full knowledge that each second may be their last when they were in the midst of hell on earth. No wonder our WWII veterans (including my Father and my Father-In-Law) never once spoke of what it was like. To relive even one second of the absolute horrors of war and to burden their loved ones with the terrible knowledge of what war is like was something that they just soon try to forget.

Every one of us should stop and take a moment to honor those brave soldiers who never came home to enjoy the freedom and life we so take for granted in this country.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

JW — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 15:50:42 GMT

This man and many like him were very brave. It is sad so many people Die in war. I hope this system comes to and end soon and the God of this world (Satan) is also destroyed for ever. then there won't be any more useless wars that kill millions.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Igor Quinlan, San Leandro, California — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 15:53:46 GMT

Michael Strank was born in FORMER Czechoslovakia. Jarabenia is in Eastern SLOVAK REPUBLIC.

That should be known.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Bob Trabosh, Media,Pa — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 16:05:21 GMT

Semper Fi.....................

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Roy Montelongo--Grandview, Washington — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 16:06:15 GMT

Every man, women and child living in the United States should know the meaning of the Raising of the flag in Iwo. Freedom in the U.S. has cost many American lives even today. I am an Army veteran and proud to have served my country back in 1967.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Rick Turnbull, London Ontario Canada — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 16:09:33 GMT

I have read Flags Of Our Fathers and of Sgt Strank. He was clearly a mans man and a soldiers soldier. It is gratifying to see his memory along with so many on all sides who sacrificed so much for their respective countries is remembered. I think of the young men and women today who continue to sacrifice their personal safety in order to keep us free and safe. Well Done!LEST WE FORGET!!!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Craig Roseman, Cresco, PA. — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 16:18:10 GMT

Sgt. Strank fought and died for this country. Why Did it take so long for him to be recognized as an american citizen. Semper Fi

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Erick Tangen, Orting wa 1st infantry div 1965 — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 16:39:44 GMT

why in the world are our military men and women treated like 2nd class citizens or not citizens at all.They do thier jobs protecting this great country and without wanting to be heros,but everyone of them are heros everyday

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

ian musgrove. cambridge. UK — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 16:42:48 GMT

WAR a great word,for old men to sending young men to their deaths

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Franklin G. Meyer, Toms River, New Jersey — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 16:42:51 GMT

We have our country because of the brave men and women that served and we have to only look at the graves of the fallen to know what price freedom cost.
Thanks to Sgt. Strank and all who gave their all for us. God bless the United States of Amewrica

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

M Torok — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 16:52:03 GMT

My father is a retired Marine, and an Iwo Jima combat survivor, along with being a combat veteran of the Korean and Vietnam Wars. Also an immigrant, but from Hungary, he became a naturalized citizen in 1937. Imagine his shock when several years ago he received a call from immigration, demanding that he produce his naturalization papers or he would be deported. My poor dad... he was about 85 at the time... searched everywhere, even climbing into his attic to try to find his citizenship papers. He offered the INS agent his honorable discharge papers after serving in the USMC for 27 years, he showed her his top secret clearance papers after having worked for a defense contracter for another 30 years... and still, she insisted that nothing less than his naturalization papers would do. Finally, he managed to find them in his attic, in a box from his childhood. The indiginity of how he was treated, after all his years of service of to this country was unimaginable.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

patton434 — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 17:19:54 GMT

There would be no USA without the USMC!!!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Greg Skavinski, Herndon, VA — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 17:32:29 GMT

Western Pennsylvanian's have always answered the call to duty and therefore, the area has a very high number of veterans. An example of this is the rural church in which I was married. It has gravestones from the French and Indian War. Western Pennsylvania also has a high number of East Europeans who worked the coal mines and steel mills. Sgt. Strank is both. Giving the family his citizenship papers is a noble gesture but he earned those papers the first time he set foot on a Pacific island. Semper Fi from one Sergeant of Marines to another.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

John P. Arthur — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 17:45:11 GMT

Let us not forget the "Gunny" doing state Dept.duty who exhibited "Semperfi" for another Marine. He exemplified The fact that Marines are brothers in the finest sense, and that Marines take care of their own. Proud of my Marines.
Former First Sgt. J.P.Arthur, USMC

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

T. Weaver Hartford, Ct. — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 18:03:58 GMT

" remember that this greatness was won by men with courage, with knowledge of their duty, and with a sense of honour in action, who, if they failed in any ordeal, disdained to deprive the city of their services, but sacrificed their lives as the best offerings on her behalf.
So they gave their bodies to the commonwealth and received, each for his own memory, praise that will never die, and with it the grandest of all sepulchers, not that in which their mortal bones are laid, but a home in the minds of men . . . . For the whole earth is the sepulcher of famous men; and their story is not graven only on stone over their native earth, but lives on far away, without visible symbol, woven into the stuff of other men's lives."

God Bless Mike Strank and the Unites States Marine Corps !
Taken from Pericles Oration over the Athenian Dead
Thucydides: The History of The Peloponnesian War

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

stephen voss, Boca Raton, FL — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 18:17:45 GMT

Could we leave partisan politics out of this please? When I see a world war II veteran like my dad, the first question out of my mouth is not "What party are you?". My gratitude to our veterans does not depend on their political party.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Tom Trujillo, New Milford, CT — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 18:24:31 GMT

Very nice and about time!

Tom T.
USN

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

AB, Michigan — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 18:30:01 GMT

The poster who said it's no wonder America became great after WWII is right on the mark. These brave men who fought, and the women who served equally honorably themselves both in the service -- for there ARE women WWII vets out there too -- and by sacrificing on the "home front" by keeping their families and the country itself going -- truly were the "greatest generation." And when the war was over they built everything that made our country great, both tangible and intangible. To all WWII vets out there, and to their families, thank you.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

L.B. Lor Merced, CA — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 18:35:36 GMT

What good does it make, the citizenship certificate after decades, for someone who paid his life to path million others for their freedom and glory. Is this truely an honor? Why?

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

L.B. Lor Merced, CA — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 18:37:35 GMT

What good does it make, the citizenship certificate after decades, for someone who paid his life to path million others for their freedom and glory. Is this truely an honor? Why?

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

R Jackson — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 18:45:38 GMT

Remember the others, One Indian named Ira Hayes needs to be honored too. May they all rest in peace

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Mark, Memphis, TN — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 19:11:12 GMT

What about the Congressional Metal of Honor?

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Rob W. Chicago, IL — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 19:12:49 GMT

Its amazing that he was a son of an immigrant who fought for his new country and that todays youth feel they are entitled to what those brave individuals provided them with, with no recollection or thanks to the selfless acts. I am currently in the IL Nat'l Gaurd and have served active duty in Europe and the 101st and feel that were it not for these soldiers, I would not have the pride that I feel for our country and flag. Yes, God bless America. If you can read this, thank a teacher, if you can read it in English, thank a soldier. Only two people will lay down their lives for you, one is Jesus Christ and the other is the American Soldier.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

April — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 19:27:23 GMT

Stories like this, make me wonder why it took the U.S. so long to honor this man? Any one that is willing to fight for this country should be given immediate citizenship papers upon honorable discharge. We have too many people in this country now that aren't willing to fight for this country. Specifically speaking, Mr. OsamaBama. He is a disgrace and if all of our fallen heroes knew that this disgrace of a man was able to run for president, they would probably wonder if their fight was in vain.
He practically apologized for the Berlin Airlift and he never mentioned that it was American's that did this, instead he basically says we have to get rid of nuclear capabilities and trust our enemies. I feel for our soldiers who gave their lives for FREEDOM! Surely, we cannot let their sacrifice be in vain!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

April, Victorville — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 19:36:42 GMT

"Strank, four other Marines and a Navy corpsman are depicted on the huge bronze memorial hoisting the flag over the volcanic island on Feb. 23, 1945. Why bother to make such a comment such asing 'it was 6 not 5..." and "Strank was a Marine, not a Navy corpman...". If you read that correctly, it says STRANK, (plus) 4 OTHER MARINES and a Navy corpman....that equals 5 Marines and a Navy corpman. 5+1=6! Maybe Larry needs to go back to reading class and math class. I second the "God Bless America" and says "God Bless our troops" regardless if Navy, Marine, Army or Air Force! We love you all!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Dan Jardine — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 19:54:18 GMT

As a Marine, I take great pride in the Iwo Jima flag-raising. The story regarding Sgt. Strank is a terrific one for all Americans. It is sad that some are attempting to add political commentary to the event. I am certain that Sen. McCain and Sen. Obama are equally pleased with the events, and equally honor Sgt. Strank's service and sacrifice. Let's keep the focus on Sgt. Strank and the fellow marine who noticed the problem and got it corrected. TRULY "semper fidelis" ("always faithful").

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Elijah Michael.......Los Angeles, Cali — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 20:10:00 GMT

Unfortunately the US has changed since those days. People sacrificed then because they believed in what America's idealism stood for. An Idealism Shattered by the profiteering in Vietnam and now Iraq, with US soldier's lives sacrificed in the process. All in the name of freedom, but in reality GREED!!
As far as McCain vs. Obama? As Gen. Wesley Clark put it: "Getting in a fighter plane and getting shot down is not a qualification to become President."

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Kurt Oswald, Apple Creek,Ohio — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 20:16:06 GMT

In all do respected to Sen. McCain. He was shot down in his jet fighter over Vietnam and spends the rest of the war a POW. The Hero in my mind are the Men and Women in the Army and Marines, who face the emery on the ground having bullets going over their heads and the rest of their body’s

My great Uncle Henry Hershberger, who served in the Army in WWII against the Germany Nazi’s in Europe was cut-off from this unit behind Germany lines and was not caught because of this training in the Army stayed on his bully during the day hiding under brush and at night pulling his body towards his buddy’s on the American line to safety.

I don’t want to hear about McCain again about being a great Commanded-in-Chief. He could not escape from the VC as a POW even try unless you know something I do not
. My Uncle would be a better Commanded-in Chief and he’s in this 90’s than Sen. McCain in all do respect.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Annette F, Kent, WA. — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 20:21:27 GMT

I may only be 49 years old but when ever I read something like this I cry. I am so glad that another one of our fallen heros has been honored.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

BobS — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 20:29:26 GMT

My uncle was on Iwo and I'm so proud that he's my uncle, but he won't say much about Iwo either..

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Bob Silseth — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 20:29:58 GMT

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Bob Silseth Balto. MD — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 20:31:03 GMT

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Bob Silseth Balto. Md. — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 20:32:48 GMT

my uncle was on Iwo and I'm so proud that he's my uncle. He won't say very much about Iwo either.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Fred (USN Retired Master Chief Petty Offier) Kerrville Texas — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 21:08:11 GMT

As a retired Navy Veteran and proud of it, if you want the whole story of the flaf raising, read Flag of Our Fathers" by Doc Bradley's son. A stirring story to say the least - AND QUIT THE POLITICAL BS ON BOTH SIDES> It disrespects what the men on Iwo did. WW2 was a differwent war and a different generation. And there is no comparison. I do not disrespect Senator McCain who served honorably, and neither do I disrespect Senator Obama who served the country in other ways than joing the military. AT LEAST HE SERVES!!! Those who want to politicize the flag raising on Iwo should just shut up and go visit the memorial in DC.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Gina C. Laredo, Tx — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 21:18:18 GMT

As the wife of a Iraqi Veteran, second tour, it amazes me that some people still have the decency to thank our military personnel. Before knowing my husband, I was studying political science as my major. I thought our country, the great U.S. as something royal. After knowing my husband, and hearing such despair stories about his platoon and how the US Army wouldn't provide, it got me thinking about how we run our country. Don't get me wrong, I would rather live here in this great country, no matter what, but it does sadden me that WE could do more for these soldiers. Not too long ago, the existing living Navajo "wind talkers" were awarded the Congressional Medal of Honor. The highest honor to anyone. My question: Why couldn't they have given it to them any sooner...before they were left with two. Why not give it to all the platoon..when they were younger. Now this story of Iwo Jima. I know the soldier had passed, but why until now. Why not sooner!!! It's difficult being a veteran's wife. Now can you imagine how difficult it is for a veteran. We live in a wonderful country. We live here because of people like them, the soldier's that never complain back home. The soldier's that are never tired, never hungry, because their life depends on it. I stopped going to our local annual parade. They would re-create a scene from Vietnam. In the audience, ignorant people that don't have the slightest idea how it feels to be a P.O.W. let alone a proud soldier would boo them and make fun of them. It fills me up with anger and emotion to have to listen to ignorant people that do not deserve to enjoy the very same freedom that our past soldiers as well as our present soldier's have give us.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Anonymous — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 21:25:03 GMT

I just wanted to add: There are never ex-marines, once a Marine always a Marine....Semper Fi 4ever!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Joseph J. Ruggiero; Peoria, AZ — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 21:45:58 GMT

God Bless the United States and its Armed Forces. Iwo Jima produced many heros. Many of those heros are unknown. Let us not forget that the only people who gave their lives for us were Jesus Christ and the American Serviceman.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Rita, Minneapolis, MN — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 21:52:44 GMT

God be with all our armed forces and my greatest thank you goes out to them. also, It is NOT the Congressional Medal of Honor either. Just MEDAL of Honor. I would not want anything at fantastic as the Medal of Honor have anything to do with CONGRESS.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

L.B. Lor Merced, CA — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 22:12:47 GMT

Please everyone out there; before putting any comment, please read the above advise paragraph. "Use appropriate language and not attacking others comments". We know that we all are good and equal or done something valuable for the community we live in and the country we are in right now. Please foccus on Mr. Strank's and his fellows' deed only and stop the saying, Mr. A is better then Mr. B and so on. Thank you.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Charles Hudspeth — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 22:13:59 GMT

congratulations,to the sgt.and thanks for helping raise the Flag.
Shame on the Goverment slaggards for taking so long in correcting this error.
Adm.Mccain may or maynot be a hero but he certianly deserves our respect for his service pow or not!

and to M.Torok That INS agent should be fired And thanks to you father for being there.
C, Hudspeth USN

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Daughter of a unsung Hero ,Mora, Minnesota — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 22:20:38 GMT

My father was in the northern area of Japan he never talked about it much only said he fought alongside of America’s best and lost a lot of friends... he was 15 when he joined the army air corps and latter the army.. He set up radar posts among other things... It is sad it took so long for this solider to be recognized... but I am sure just as my father would be that it is truly appreciated that he is recognized. And at peace. Least we forget any of our unsung heroes in every service of this country The United States of America.
None of them ever think they are heros...

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

AJ Dibble, Chambersburg Pa,, MSG US Army, Ret — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 22:46:23 GMT

All service members, regardless of conflict or branch of service, whom have paid the ultimate price , are worthy of the highest respect.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Wyo — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 22:47:58 GMT

There is nothing on this Earth more impressive than a Soldier, Marine, Sailor, Airman,etc. willing to put himself in harm's way, answering his country's call, without any expectation of fame or glory. Many, like Sgt. Strank (Marine)and others, and those men who were not a part of the photo, even shunned any attention for their heroics. That is true honor: a willingness to risk life and limb for country and not basking in the lime-light for war service or polishing medals for photo ops. These people deserve our gratitude.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

JD Sweeney Phoenix,AZ — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 22:49:16 GMT

Elijah Michael: Thank you for your liberal Democratic slant and the quote from General Wesley Clark, frequently quoted by the Washinton Post and NYT as a " military expert!" Being a US Senator from Illinois might qualify you to be a dog catcher in Chi-town but little else! Get real Liberal!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

David — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 22:51:16 GMT

To Sgt. Strank and all the others of the greatest generation. I'm sorry we squandered the promise you gave us. But at least you tried. God bless You All. Semper Fi

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

TJ - Florida — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 23:11:57 GMT

Michael Strank's story is one of millions who served during WWII. He was granted citizenship at the age of 3, according to the story, so it is not like he was not given citizenship (the papers were never given to him, but the story fails to tell why or if they were given to his father). Regardless, he was a citizen (and I do agree with all of the posters who state that citizenship should be given automatically upon a dishonorable discharge). As for the poster who stated he should be given the Congressional Medal of Honor, so sorry, but that is for truely self sacrificing deeds (that usually end in the death of the honoree) not for being in the right place at the right time for a historical moment (besides, the flag raisers of Iwo Jima will be known long after most individual CMH honorees). As far as politics, it's bound to seep in - we have a candidate for whom the military is in his family history vs a candidate who fumbles over giving praise and honor to the military of today (sorry dude, that's what you get when you shoot hoops rather than go see injured troops ... regardless of the reasoning behind it). My father-in-law was a WWII marine 3rd Div and served in Tarowa, Iwo Jima, Okinawa and although I was never in the service, I feel very grateful that these fine men and women of WWII rose to the occassion and gave us the country we have today. I am also deeply saddened that we have largely failed, as a nation, to live up to the goals and ideals that they fought and died for.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Larry Taylor Antioch california — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 23:17:52 GMT

He didn't need a piece of paper to be reconized as a citizen. He was truly in ever sense of the word a citizen and a patorit of these United States,and I thank him and his family .

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Kathy Pederson, Detroit Lakes, MN — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 23:20:33 GMT

My dad was in the Korean conflict and patrolled the DMZ. My brother in law served in Vietnam and is less two fingers for the experience. When I look at the way my father is remembered for the Korean conflict and his response when he returned from home and how proud he was of his service and then of my brother in law it is truely amazing and only about 20 years difference. Vets talk to each other about their experiences and they rarely talk to non vets about their experiences because how could we even relate to the horrors of war? Now I see another generation coming home from Iraq. At first they were met with great ceremony and lately little is done except complain about the cost of the war. When do people realize that FREEDOM IS NOT FREE. We need to pay either with resources of cash money, service to ones country or the lives of our loved ones? We are all responsible for the current state of our country. We allow there to be so many languages and we do not stress that English is the primary language. When immigrants came to this country they used to learn our language and customs NOW we are EXPECTED to bend to the immigrants. If you want the life in the USA do as the AMERICANS do. Remember your heritage but join the AMERICAN SOCIETY. Thank to Sgt Strank for his and his family's sacifrice to our country. Maybe if we start to stand up for ourselves and our way of life we will see some of that OLD patriotism we all talk about. God Bless America!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Kathy Pederson, Detroit Lakes, MN — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 23:22:24 GMT

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Marty — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 23:27:47 GMT

The Japanese attacked us on Dec 7, 1941, my 3 brothers all signed up that week, 1 came home, the other 2 did not make it, the one that did come home was minus his leg, this family will never forget the horror of war, but the pride that went with serving your country and knowing that these service people were and still are fighting for our freedom, fills me with awe. Remember Sept 11, we were attacked again, a war is not pleasant, but to sit back and talk about it without helping is an atrocity. I am sure that in Gods hands, that this Marine knows his country honored him and that we hold dear his thoughts of freedom. Semper FI Marine and Thank You

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

chris, Illinois — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 23:37:57 GMT

You know it is utterly pathetic when you read something like this and then see the likes of Kurt and Elijah turning it into a political event. I am retired Army but let me put in a plug for the zoomies as we call pilots. Pilots face death every time they launch into the air, in peace or war. Piloting any flying mchine is one of the riskiest things going expecially when it is a high performence jet designed to fly deadly rather than safely. Flying off of the deck of a carrier is even more deadly and many pilots are hurt and killed every year even in peacetime. During WW2 and beyond pilots died in extremely high numbers and in the case of bomber pilots over Europe in much higher percentages than the infantry. Ask any infantry vet of the war and while they envied the airmen their comfy beds at night they did not envy them being shot out of the sky like flies on some raids. You two need to get a real education on history (and grammar, yours is pathetic). I would bet neither of you have served and your lack of service removes yout ability to judge any military members service, period, and I have NO respect for someone who would publish your type of rubbish. Sign me, US Army Retired....

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Gary Moore, Phoenix, AZ. — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 23:46:56 GMT

Selfless acts of patriotism have in the past and continue to this day to promote, protect and achieve freedom for all people around the globe. All gave some , some gave all ....without this , it would be a truly different world we live in. Thank you and God bless Sgt. Michael Strank!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Gary Anderson Salem, Or — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 23:52:48 GMT

What nobler way for man to die
than facing fearful odds
For the ashes of his fathers
and the temple of his Gods.

Horatius at the Bridge

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Peter Beck, Charleston, SC — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 00:21:14 GMT

Yes, Strank was a hero, as were all those who served in that war and the present one. Let's never forget to honor those who defend our country whether we agree with the cause or not. They did not choose the fight then and they did not choose the fight now, but they have chosen to fight for our country. That's bravery.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

chris anthony, des moines, ia. — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 00:50:22 GMT

i'm afraid we don't have that kind of 'heart' anymore and it's a shame. they were indeed 'the greatest generation'.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

W. A. Varnell — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 01:09:12 GMT

One of my closest friends, MGYSgt A. P. Brock, was there, done that, and came home to serve in the USMC Reserve. The Few, the Proud, The Marines. God Bless "Em All!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

John F. Reilly, Cpl, USMC 1967-69, Philadelphia, PA — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 01:11:08 GMT

"And when he gets to heaven
to St. Peter he will tell,
one more Marine reporting Sir,
I served my time in hell."

Well done Marine, come on in !

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Avant McMillion — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 01:11:17 GMT

When it comes to those avoiding military service,why single out Obama? Our Vice President received 5 deferments,and our President joined the National Guard to avoid Vietnam.If you don't want to vote for someone that is your right,but do not be so disingenuous as to your reason.In comparison to the general population,only a very small percentage of us are veterans.I have noticed that those who avoided the draft are the loudest flag wavers.
I am proud to have served my country.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Avant McMillion Bronx,New York — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 01:12:08 GMT

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Avant McMillion — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 01:12:20 GMT

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Daughter of WWII vet — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 01:13:57 GMT

First, I want to thank all our military for their bravery, their service, and their sacrifice. Our debt to you can never be paid, but may we always hold you in the honor you deserve.

To some of the posters, please read the article. Sgt. Strank was merely given his citizenship papers. He was AUTOMATICALLY a citizen when his father was naturalized, but the papers just had not been sent to him. This was not a posthumous honoring of his service in the war.

FYI, it is more than possible that the original article was incorrect in its label for Sgt. Strank, USMC, portraying him as being in the Navy which was later corrected. Please, before posting, use some reason.

As for McCain, no one should be elected solely on his/her service to this country. However, leadership qualities ARE criteria for a president, and McCain's tenure in the POW camp is evidence of magnificent leadership! If you have not read of his imprisonment ordeal, it should be required reading for you. I would offer the same accolades for candidate Obama were I to know of the same type of leadership evidenced by him, but I do not. Leadership qualities are part of the criteria, but certainly and by no means the only criteria. But to diminish the sacrifice McCain gave to this country, and if you read of his tenure, you'll understand the word "gave", is wrong and pathetic. While he is not my first choice for president, he has earned my respect and I honor him for his sacrifice to this country! He understands those words, "sacrifice", "honor", and "freedom", he is a testament to the meaning of these words.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Ranger Dan — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 01:16:42 GMT

Semper Fi, God Bless Michael Strank and God Bless America

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Arlie Wood — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 01:19:31 GMT

IAW the story as written, Sgt Strank became a citizen in 1935 at the age of sixteen years: He just didn't recieve his papers. Many men fought for the USA in WWII who were not citizens. All, including Me, did their DUTY DUTY DUTY with no thought of being heroes.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Joe Quinlan - Cortland, New York — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 01:22:02 GMT

My dad was at Pearl Harbor on December 7th 1941. And he and his ship were at several other important battles of the Pacific during WWII. He never spoke a word about it until some shipmates contacted him in the seventies about a ship's reunion. I love, respect and miss him. He died in 2005. My respect extends to all of our vets from all conflicts. God bless you all.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

RangerDan — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 01:24:57 GMT

Let us all remember that "The Greatest Generation" also lived through the Great Depression. So if you are not happy with America now remember what that brave generation lived through.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

George Rotell, Brandon Fl — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 01:54:22 GMT

Hey Kirt oswald.Try bailing out of a fighter plane doing 500 or 6oo mph with it falling apart from a missle hit and all sort of triple A all around you. Then you still have to get on the ground. Your parachute makes a NICE BIG TARGET and the people on the Ground Hate your Guts so there throwing everthing but the kitchen sink at you.And when you land in water there are no bushes to hide under. SO STOP TALKING SO DAMMED Foolish! Until We have been there, lets just Be thankful for those who serve and not those that opt for Canada.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

John Coburn, Signalman 3/c, USN — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 01:57:42 GMT

If ever a tribute was deserved this has to be it. Semper Fi, brother Strank.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Heather Lee-Kita, St Clair MI — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 02:06:21 GMT

All of the men and women who died, were injured or fought for our country are heroes and should never be forgotten. The raising of the Flag at Iwo Jima is an incredibly moving moment in our history that emphasizes our strength and determination as a country. The story of these men should never be forgotten, the sacrifices they made. The ones who didn't make it back; and the ones that did and were always haunted by the horrors of war; as Ira Hayes was. I am an Air Force Veteran myself and enlisted during the Cold War, and my husband is a Veteran of Viet Nam who also served in the Air Force; his father, Richard P. Kita was a Marine that fought at Iwo Jima, and perhaps it is incorrect of me to say so, but I agree, "Semper Fi"

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Wayne Borawski, Villa Park, IL — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 02:06:56 GMT

One of the best books I ever read was Flags of Our Fathers which tells the story of the Iwo Jima flag raisers and would recomend it to everyone. I know it's a movie too but like most books made into movies the book can't be beat. Truly these men were our greatest generation.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Proud Teacher and E-5 USAF — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 02:10:34 GMT

I am grieved when I read some of your comments. Did you attend school? Did you learn to read and write? Did you learn how to spell? Apparently not! As far as the comment about what Clark said. Gen Clark is an idiot. I worked with a man that served under him and Clark was as incompetent then as he is now. The man I worked with is a retired Major in the Army. Some of the stories he told me made me wonder how Clark wasn't discharged in disgrace. He was simply "reassigned" over and over.
Please! Please! Please! proof read your entry before hitting submit and get a dictionary for heaven's sake!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Ron Neece — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 02:16:07 GMT

I too oppose war for power and profit. I served in the military with peide in the early and mid fifties. I do not think I could serve in todays environment.Honoring This mans memory is good. That is all that matters here. I honor most of our service people yet today, but that does not apply to those who place them in harms way for financial and political gain.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Annie, CA — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 02:16:37 GMT

In all DUE respect. He SPENT... too many errors to list! You should be ashamed of yourself! You put down all POW's because they didn't escape? Everyone has the right to be stupid, you simply are exercising that right more than the rest of the world!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Ron Neece, Williamsport,PA — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 02:18:16 GMT

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

April, Victorville — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 02:23:15 GMT

Politics cannot be left out of it. I am glad this man is honored but what is going on around us today make many soldier's deaths in vain. Our founding fathers are probably mad as hell about what is going on in this country right now. If you turn a blind eye to it, shame on you.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

John Sikes — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 02:24:28 GMT

So, the child of an illegal immigrant raised the flag
over Iwo Jima.....that's interesting. Too bad folks aren't praising the illegals and their children
today....

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Charlie Carnago Arnold, MO — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 02:25:40 GMT

My Dad passed 25 yeqars ago and only in the last few months My Mom passed on to me his Navy Log Book and I find he was in three major invasions during WWII and said very little about them. I am glad to know men are not forgotten for what they had to do and see.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Jack Sikes — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 02:26:21 GMT

The son of an immigrant (probably an illegal one at that for a time) raising the flag over Iwo Jima....
too bad folks can't seem to get that into their heads when we talk about today's immigrants, illegal or otherwise.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Dan Brinkman — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 02:27:14 GMT

I agree with Byron from North Dakota. Immigrants have served in all of our wars and they should be respected for it. Right now, we have about 70,000 US permanent residents (green card holders)who are serving in the US military and they are not full US citizens yet; many are in Iraq as we speak. They are all modern day immigrants like my wife of 13 years, Tatiana.
My father was a Marine and Semper Fi to him and Sgt. Strank from WWII. I love the USMC. Always have, always will. I love all Americans who serve in the US military, when so many Americans today who are young, will not even consider it. Immigrants should then be given special status for serving in the US military even though they are not yet full US citizens. From the Irish, to the Mexicans, to the Italians, to the Czechs, to the Slovaks, to the Japanese, to the Koreans, to the Central Americans, to the Poles, to the Thais, Russians, and Vietnamese and many more nationalities that have been in the US military while not yet being full US citizens: God Bless You All. Our country is better with you in it and in service to our nation. That is for sure!
Always remember: This is Your Country Too. America needs you all!
Dan Brinkman/Portland Oregon

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

E. Chambers, Statesboro, GA — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 02:32:11 GMT

My father served with the 101st Airborne in WWII, and although he is no longer with us, he will always be my hero. He spoke little of his experiences, like so many WWII vets. God bless Sgt. Strank, may he rest in peace with all the others whose sacrifice has given us our freedom.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Ewald Franz — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 02:37:39 GMT

This Is a good thing that a country vcares enouht to give him his citizenship . I was Born in Munich Germany and faught in Viet Nam and I am still not a citizen. Well maybe after I am dead they will give it to me. But I am happy for him.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

dan brinkman — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 02:39:03 GMT

M Torok,
I am so sorry to hear how your father was treated. Please write your congressperson and both senators from your state and demand a written apology from the INS. Please do this for your father. Let your father know that I appreciate his service to America and that he is more American than most Americans!!!!
Sincerely,
Dan Brinkman

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Dan, Bay City, MI — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 02:39:16 GMT

People seem to forget that America didn't become great after WWII. America has always been great. America will always be great, even when her citizens and government lose their respective ways. America is, and always will be great because there will always be those that are willing to sacrifice everything for their friends, family, and people that they will never even know. Even today, the news is almost always bad, but the soldiers are still the finest example of what America is. Terrorists can't destroy America, because America will never be 'just a place'. I am proud of those who have served, am proud of those now serving, and will be proud of those who will serve. Army, Navy, Marines, Air Force, doesn't matter, they all know the risks, and they risk everything for us.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Gary P, Utica, MI — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 03:06:04 GMT

This is a touching story, however I doesn't seem fair to criticize the government for taking so long, simply because no one (not even his own family) knew that he did not receive the documents. As the article states he became a naturalized US citizen in 1935, but never received his papers. The fact is he made the ultimate sacrifice as a citizen, but US citizen or not we should honor and respect all soldiers from all Allied countries that worked together to defeat the terrible tyrany of the Axis powers during WWII. Likewise soldiers who answer the call to fight the battles necessary to protect our wonderful way of life should always have a special place in our hearts and minds.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Andy Schoffer San Antonio, Tex — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 03:11:21 GMT

Elija Michael, You are the ONLY one who makes sense, God bless your clear thinking and keep you for a long time... I would vote for you...

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

JD Seattle, WA — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 03:30:32 GMT

What a change from japan to Iraq.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Scott, Washington DC — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 03:46:47 GMT

Anyone who would denigrate McCain's service to this country should be challenged, including that general who was roundly reproved by many including Senator Obama. At the same time, I have no reason to question Obama's loyalty to our country. Instead, give thanks to the US armed forces from known heros like Mike Strank to the unsung private doing his duty.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Sgt, of Marines — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 03:56:55 GMT

Sgt. Strank was indeed a true hero. Despite this technicality that everyone is blowing out of proportion he has been memorialized in countless photographs, statues and, urban legends. He has been idolized by marines of all generations including myself. Furthermore VFW post 15909 in Johnstown, PA is named in his honor. To my knowledge this is the ONLY VFW post ever named in honor of a US Marine. Semper Fi!!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

ChrisH, Phoenix — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 04:09:36 GMT

"Sgt. Strank, you may rest in peace with your fellow warriors now". A hat-tip and salute to the Gunny that made this wrong a right. Semper Fi is sometimes overused except by those of us who know what those words really mean. And to those fearless naval corpsmen attached to USMC, "Semper Fi" and God Bless to you always.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Drew Rock L. ACali — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 04:10:21 GMT

God Bless America, Despite All Her Faults, Still the Greatest Country OF All....

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Chari Mercier, St. Petersburg, FL — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 04:25:57 GMT

I'm so glad that Michael Strank finally received his citizenship papers posthumously. It's so sad that he didn't survive WW2 to see this happen for him, but I'm glad that his sister, Mary Pero, was alive to receive those papers in his memory and honor. At least she can give those papers to her adult kids whenever she passes away so that they will remember what Sgt. Strank did and how he lived his life as a Marine and as a person. I hope that we will remember this lesson in remembering and honoring our current military personnel that are serving here in the USA and around the world, especially those that are currently fighting this war against terrorism in Iraq and Afghanistan. And, we must always remember with honor the military veterans who have fought all of the wars that our country has been in over the 232 year history of America, and the new military vets that have fought the war against terrorism. We need to keep supporting them in all of their efforts, and make sure that our vets are treated fairly in housing, jobs, education, insurance, and medical care. Keep remembering and honoring them every day!
Chari Mercier :)
St. Pete, FL

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Carrie Valentin — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 04:37:18 GMT

If all comments must approved before appearing in the thread why is this being inappropriately used as a forum for political comment? And if he reads further comments, I hope the poster who wrote about his 85 year old father having to produce his naturalization papers would get in touch with 60 Minutes or another investigative show about that. With the millions of illegal aliens in this country I cannot understand why they would go after an 85 year old man?

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Tom Morris, Prospect Park, Pa. — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 04:46:13 GMT

Real, real tired of "the greatest generation" crap. No disrespect to those who served in WWII, they kicked ass. But truth be told, many of them were drafted. Anyone serving now VOLUNTEERED. Every generation has it's share of brave young men and women willing to serve. I'm the father of a soldier.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Ric hard Anaya, San Diego, CA — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 05:22:23 GMT

As a young Marine in boot camp (MCRD San Diego 1958) we learned of the valiant and couragous efforts to overcome a well fortified enemy by Marine on Iwo Jima. Where the phrase "Uncommon valor was a common virtue" was coined. I was honored to have my first two 1stSgts in L/3/5 be WW II veterans. One was a survior of the Battan Death March and the second spent 6 years in a Japanese prison camp in Tokyo. The stories they told were both heroic and horrifing. They passed Marine Corps lore of dedication to duty and honor for God, Country and the Corps. Those same values exhibited by Sgt Strank, Top Kowalcki and Top J. Z Miller, are still alive and well in the Corps as our young Marines defend freedom for not just us but all people. 1stLt Richard C. Anaya USMC (Ret) 1958-1978

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Thu, 31 Jul 2008 05:41:44 GMT

May our enemies go to heaven along with us. Amen.

We are all citizens of Earth.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Michael — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 05:53:28 GMT

Miss April, Your comment at 30th of July 2008 was really an absurd one.
Your comparison of Mr. Obama with an international terrorist was really giving a bad taste to people who want peace. I bet the guys who fought or are fighting yet for the country don't want to kill or to be wounded or even killed. It is certain that they want peace as Mr. Obama said. Mr. Obama's comment is not only talks, he actually means that, first try to convince through conversation and even though if it is out of reach and besides if the issue is bad as possible as global destruction, than with no choice we can attack any terrorising actvity.
But the main point is "HOW TO SAVE LIVES" that is what Mr. Obama makes us clear about.
I hope you know that every war has it's own destruction and creates shortages of varieties that effect the whole world. Why do you think the gasoline price is raising????? undoubtfully it's the war!!!!!!.
Why do you think the world is facing more and more conlflicting issues?? cuz a war creates a lot of evengeful characters, that's why!!!!!

If any one want's to protect you for a long era, He becomes similar to a criminal. That's fine. Be with it and some day you'll find your mistake. it is better to be wise than regret later.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Michael — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 05:54:02 GMT

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Joe Lom — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 06:01:19 GMT

With gratitude and respect to Sgt. Strank and all who have served and are serving our nation.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Joe Lom, Staten Island, NY — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 06:04:36 GMT

With gratitude and respect to Sgt. Strank and all who have served and are serving our nation.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Randy — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 06:08:14 GMT

Imagine how much of American history would not have happened if anyone without proper papers were immediately removed/deported? I am guessing that these "immigrants" are what makes America the wonderful country that it is. Please think twice before voting on a candidate that wishes to hunt down all illegal immigrants with the vengience that the nazis did to the "others" back in those historic days. God Bless this soldier and all soldiers that have fought on the right sides throughout history. Immigration officers can always state that they are merely taking orders. So similar, it makes ya think?

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

David D. — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 06:28:32 GMT

Kurt Oswald....a "hero" can belong to ANY service....including the Coast Guard & Merchant Marines. Your obvious political hatred for McCain is a poor excuse for belittling the many brave souls that have fought & died in service other than with the Army & Marines.

I'm a 13 year, 2 conflict, Disabled Vet myself & I can tell you that Air Force pilots & Naval Aviators are VERY well trained for survival & combat. They even get shot at twice if they are unlucky....once in the air, twice on the ground.

Just our of curiosity, how many years did you serve your country?? How long were you a POW like McCain?? Did they treat you really well??

Take your hate-speech somewhere else...it's not welcome here, as I'm sure the great majority of us who have read your disgsting post will agree.

David D.--SFC (Retired/DAV)

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Lao Shi — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 06:34:08 GMT

Getting shot down does not qualify one for president, but it does build character.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Bruce Warner, Colorado Springs, Colorado — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 06:52:05 GMT

I would have to agree with Mr. Jadine in keeping this article about Sgt.Strank apolitical. This is not the forum for such. This is about a Marine receiving his citizenship papers, and the Marine 'Gunny' that so dutifully did the right thing for a fallen comrade. As a Navy corpsman attached to the First Marine Division during the battle of Hue, Vietnam, I can recall the exileration of raising the flag at the citadel after the horrendous battles to get there. Do not dishonor such moments with political diatribe. Semper Fi!! HM2 Warner USN/USMC

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

John Couillard, Maine/Georgia — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 07:21:42 GMT

Semper Fi to all of my brothers and sisters, especially to 2nd Bn 4th Marines.
Former Marine, SGT John M. Couillard
Formerly of Greene, Maine
Now in Kingston GA

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Matthew Reuben, Tampa FL currently over sea's — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 07:48:13 GMT

Heres to you Sgt. strank! (always faithful)
please stop with the politics on this one, it`s not
the time or the place people.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Patrick Little, Duncan, BC, Canada — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 07:53:59 GMT

For those of you who would be critical of your
Government, know that Marine Sgt. Strank and his family were unaware of his not having a certificzte of citizenship until another Marine discovered this fact many years later while researching Michael Strank's history.

Back at the time of Michael Strank's Father's naturalization, the children automatically became citizens but one had to apply for separate certification, it wasn't an issue. I know because my own Father was naturalized.

Iwo Jima was especially important to those of us born and raised in Hawai'i who, like me, personally witnessed Pearl Harbor's bombing and grew up in the constant shadow of martial law, continuously surrounded by the machinery of war and the impending fear of invasion.

We were the next generation who held the Soldiers, Sailors and Marines in high esteem as they came and went to the Pacific battles. We will never forget and our lives were shaped by our respect for their duty, honor and sacrifice.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Howard B. Smith Austin, Texas — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 07:57:46 GMT

A big Semper Fi to Sgt. Strank and all the brave men who fought and died on that now sacred ground called Iwo. There is no doubt all Marines, then, now and in the future will always honor those fallen heroes. A special kudos to the Gunny that brought this oversight to light and help bring official citizenship to this brave Marine's sacrifice for his country, family and Corps. Christ died for our sins, Sgt. Strank and brave men like him died for our freedom, Semper Fi.
Former Marine,
H.B. Smith

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Carlos, Long Beach, CA — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 08:20:56 GMT

An immigrant who gave his life for this country. Wow I wonder what Lou Dobbs would have to say about this. Oh never mind it's a white immigrant!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Joseph E O'Hanlon Jr — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 08:28:04 GMT

As an experienced Army gound officer in Vietnam with two tours, with TET in the middle, when given orders to move anywhere around the DMZ, my first question in reply was always :"Where are the Marines?"

As for using this wonderful story about one of the many millions of patriotic Americans --- like my Dad in the USAAF and my Uncle, who was badly wounded at Bastogne while a member of the PA Guard's BLOODY BUCKET-- who willingly put their lives on the line for OUR freedom today to take cheap shots at McCain for being "only" shot down, try being all alone and abandoned by OUR government of BOTH parties and going through all that misery and STILL keeping faith with America. Why don't you take your Elijah name and volunteer for a tour in Iraq??? Our pilots were poorly trained to survive being a POW during Vietnam and to come back sane and not angry at the world makes ALL those wonderful pilots REAL HEROES to me. I am surprised, however, that Sen Schumer hasn't tried to DISARM McCain as I KNOW he has had some really bad nightmares, like most of us COMBAT vets have experienced, and have been "disarmed". Sure I am, Schumer. Stop by the house for coffee and to take my gun!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Joseph E O'Hanlon Jr Pittsburgh, PA — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 08:29:33 GMT

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Joseph E O'Hanlon Jr Pittsburgh, PA — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 08:30:24 GMT

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Joseph E O'Hanlon Jr Pittsburgh, PA — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 08:32:00 GMT

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

c kohm — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 08:36:01 GMT

Sgt. Stank, Thank you for your sacrifice. Uncle John, Thank you for your sacrifice.

Freedom should not always have to be paid for with life. Maybe someday the world will not have to bear the scars of war nor the loss of life to keep freedom alive for all of us fortunate enough to call ourselves Americans.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Darlene R. Wrigley 3365 Buena Hills Drive, Oceanside, CA 92056 — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 08:51:36 GMT

I was very touched by this story. I truly believe the USMC has kept and is keeping this country free. Camp Pendleton is our neighbor. They are great neighbors. One of our city councilmen is a retired colonel.A very fine example of our marines.He is still serving his country!!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Dennis Cook, Vancouver, B.C. — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 10:02:27 GMT

Most Americans do not know that thousands Canadians fought in Vietnam as volunteers in the U.S. Military, against their own government's refusal to take part, and only recently were they accepted as vets in Canadian Legion Clubs, alongside those from WW1, WW11, and Korea. Many died in Nam.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

LucyB, Philadelphia, Pa — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 11:02:51 GMT

Finally--justice and honor for a real American !

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Master Sergeant Dino — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 11:27:34 GMT

Kurt oswald... you are an idiot... it is too obvious a statement of fact that you have never served your country. Being held a prisoner of war for over six years and leading the men he served with is a good reason to be commander-in-chief. We are in a world in which almost everyone wants to do us harm so you must be willing to elect a commander-in-chief first, and then the president second. i'm sad for you

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

John Harris, Cross Creek, FL — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 11:35:57 GMT

Semper Fi Marine.We always take care of our own.

John Harris
Sergeant
United States Marine Corps, 1961-1967

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Debbie Miles, Ann Arbor, MI — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 12:06:07 GMT

Thank you to Sgt. Strank and everyone that has given their life for me, as well as those that are still fighting for my freedom. I treasure that gift!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Bob L Kettering, Ohio — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 12:06:24 GMT

Every individual in the United States Military are HERO'S From Senator McCain and Sgt Strank to Audie Murphy.
Getting shot at is, getting shot at.
To Sacrifice ones life so that we may lead our's in a Free Nation is the ultimate sacrifice.
Congratulations Sgt. Strank on your accomplishments.
I would have loved to met you.
R.I.P.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Robert Ellis - Milwaukee — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 12:08:27 GMT

Our history is repleat with stories of those who came here to seek an opportunity and made the most of it. To bad so many born here cannot see what they have and waste their days chasing possessions. We are free because brave men believed in the rule of law. Such a shame to see so many willing to sacrifice those laws and our freedoms that so many Americans and immigrants seeking the hope of American paid the
last full measure for.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Ray Johannsen Atlanta, Georgia U.S.A. — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 12:38:53 GMT

Thank you my fellow American for your services,,,,,,
you will always be remembered, appreciated, and loved.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

OD — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 13:02:34 GMT

Thank God for the few real Americans that still work within the US gov't., that had the understanding and compassion to do this.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Gary Farmer — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 13:05:04 GMT

A few thoughts -
The person who suggested the Medal of Honor. Very nice of you to suggest, but it would not be appropriate. The CMH is only awarded to someone who exhibits extreme valor under fire at a risk to their life in such a manner that it has a direct effect on the course of an action or in defense of the lives of others. While Strank was, in my mind, a hero - someone who should be looked up to and his actions emulated, he was not a Hero - someone to be celebrated above others who were there.

This same idea goes for the person who suggested a holiday in his honor: again, not appropriate except on a local scale (i.e., his home town could have a "Strank Day" with some mayoral proclamation or such). Holidays in celebration of persons are reserved for persons who have a significant national impact, theoretically above all others who have had similar impact. Washington, Lincoln, even King - appropriate.

One final thought: as a formerly active Marine, it always gives me great pride to see the memorial in Washington or the picture from which it was created and remember my father's generation and the guts they had, the sacrifices that they made and were willing to make in the cause of freedom. And it saddens me to wonder where that has gone in our current "me first", "sue 'em if I get a hangnail", "blame everyone else for my problems but me", "expect simple solutions to complex problems" country. I know it's still there - dormant, but still there. I wonder some time if it's going to take another Pearl Harbor or 9-11 to finally bring it back out.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

David Cohen — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 13:24:04 GMT

Semper Fi Michael Strank. It was Michael's type of heroism that gave my Uncle the hope to forge on in the battle for Iwo. My Uncle survived the first days landings when few people did and he pushed on day after day in what seemed to be a futile exercise, but the one thing he will talk about is the raising of the American flag on Mt. Suribachi. My Uncle talks about how seeing that flag gave the Marines hope when it seemed there was little hope. I have seen have seen both "Flags of our Fathers" and "Letters to Home" giving us what the Japanese experienced. A lot of good people died on that miserable little island in the pacific, so let us hope that our Marine don't have to do that one again. Semper Fi

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Gene, Richmond, VA — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 13:25:11 GMT

Fitting tribute to a fallen hero, also kudos to the Marine who discovered and initiated this honor. Just another example of Marines looking out for Marines.
The original Flag is currently on display at the Marine Corps Museum in Quantico, VA. If you get a chance you have to visit this interactive extrordinary museum. Semper Fi

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

tom from PA — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 13:32:31 GMT

Pennsylvania veterans served with honor and gallantry during the Second World War. One of every seven deaths on D-Day was a soldier or sailor from PA. By the war's end, one in ten soldiers serving broad was from the state of Pennsylvania. God bless Sgt. Strank from the small town of Franklin, PA. PS: President Truman stopped his train when it was traveling through western PA and personally vistied with Strank's mother. He was deeply affected by that visit.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Jim Cannon, Pittsburgh, PA — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 13:43:02 GMT

It's interesting that our ultra-liberal Pittsburgh newspaper, the Post-Gazette, has no mention of this story. Considering that he was from the Pittsburgh area and that his sister still lives here, this shows the paper's continued contempt for war veterans.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

OHIO — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 13:46:30 GMT

The sacrifices and heroics of these men make me embarrassed to belong to my generation of gen-x

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Kevin Synnott, ND — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 13:49:33 GMT

One of the 3 Marines killed on Iwo Jima was killed by US Naval gunfire. 'Flags of Our Fathers' by James Brady. I believe Brady was the son of the corpsman.

According to Brady, the batallion commander had carried the first flag in his back-pack for the purpose of raising it on Iwo Jima. Some higher commander gave the order to someone that he wanted that flag. The Btn Commander didn't think that was right; so he ordered another team of men to retrieve 'his flag' and replace it with another one for the higher commander.

The 2d flag raising was not staged as some say. It is the flag raising that was photgraphed. Of the hundreds of photographs sent to the US for the papers & magazines, this one photo caught an editor's attention and was published. Once published it caught the attention of the American people. The photographer, did not know for some time that he was famous.

I read the book, but I don't own a copy or I would be more specific about the names.
I recommend everyone to read 'Flags of Our Fathers.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Bootz Mercer, Randallstown, MD — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 13:49:56 GMT

One of the respondents quotes the words of Pericles honoring the Athenian dead, and they are elequent. But the miltary epitaph that I find most moving is the laconic memorial to the 300 Spartans who died delaying the Persian army at the pass of Thermopolae.
"Go stranger, tell Sparta that we lie here in obediance to her command".

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

CPL FIG, TABB, VA — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 13:51:37 GMT

It is sad to know that something like this was "over-looked" by the United States Government. BUT it happened. I would like to thank the Gunny who brought it to light. But that's what our beloved Marine Corps instills in all who step on those yellow footprints--a sense of honor, respect, and devotion for those who came before us. Those who earned the title of US MARINE--they are part of OUR history as American's and especially as MARINES. Sergeant Strank will continue to be remembered by ALL Marines for generations to come--he was and is our brother.
"From the halls of Montezuma to the shores of Tripoli..."
SEMPER FI DEVIL DOGS!!
(USMC VET: '99-'02)

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Mary Moch, Garland, TX — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 13:51:43 GMT

Absolutely heart-warming. Thanks for sharing this. We owe so much to our Armed Forces. God Bless to this man's family.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Mr. John Taylor 76 Greenbush st. Pittsburgh Pa. — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 13:56:15 GMT

We speak english,not japonese or german because of all the men and women who gave of themselves in ww11. This is the higest honor thay have given us. I as a us marine thank them ALL!!!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

O.P. Atlanta, GA — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 13:58:11 GMT

America is great! The demagogues and the bureaucrats that run the country are not great. How could they take so long to honor this man (a foreigner) until made a citizen? It shows that wether you are illegal or foreigner you still love this country, no matter what, do not politicize a mans honor. The outstanding soldier above who sacrifice everything for this country and was harrassed by an ignorant bureaucrat demanding his proof of citizenship is absolutely a thousand percent pathetic. I am an ex-marine from a foreign country who served in the Korean conflict. I understand all the pain of those family members of servicemen who are not duly recognized for their efforts. Leave Obama and McCain alone, remember we had a President who was a draft dodger but did good for the country. God Bless U.S.M.C. and the courageous men and women who served this great country. Semper Fidelis

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Kevin Synnott, ND — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 14:00:26 GMT

Kurt of Apple Creek, OH,

My comment is in no way intended to minimize your uncle's WWII accomplishments.

Your uncle situation of being cut-off from his unit and being surrounded by the enemy is similar to McCain's story. The main difference is that the European evnvironment was more friendly for your uncle's skills that was that of Vietnam. Usualy pilots are seriously wounded when they are shot down.

There is more respect between pilots and grunts than is shown in your comment. Grunts know the pilots are those who risk their lives to provide close in air support for the men on the ground. The pilots know that the grunts are the ones who will risk their lives to rescue them if shot down. Combat has all military personnel working together; both to stay alive and win the war. Bar room brawls, not-withstanding.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

DevilDog2565 — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 14:03:08 GMT

Semper Fi Brother!!! May you walk the streets of Heaven in glory because you served your time in Hell. The watch is ours now and we're PROUD to carry on the tradition of the United States Marine Corps...Ooh! Rah!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Mr. John Taylor 76 Greenbush st. Pittsburgh Pa. — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 14:05:49 GMT

Manny immagrants have come to america searching for the freedom that exists here like nowhere else on earth.Once here manny decide this freedom is worth fighting for,I thank you all!!!Semper. Fi.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Kevin Synnott, ND — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 14:07:05 GMT

Only 2 soldiers were able to escape from enemy captivity during the Vietnam War.
One: Colonel Nick Rowe escaped after 5 years of captivity. Rowe was killed in the Philippines in the 1980s by Islamic-Communist terrorists.
Two: Deeter, a helicopter pilot. Deeter was the son of immigrant parents.

Rowe had been held in South Vietnam & Deeter in Laos. There were no escapes from captivity in North Vietnam. Many attempts were made, but 6 foot white menor 6 foot Black men stand out in a land of 5 foot peoples. I am not aware of any Oriental being shot down and attempting escape.

I am greatful for all who have served their country, especially for those that paid the ultimate price.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Bob Meola, Toms River NJ — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 14:07:18 GMT

Great Story

Semper Fi Marines

Sgt Bob Meola

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Patrick, Juneau, Alaska — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 14:12:02 GMT

I will be eternally grateful for all the servicemen that have served and given their lives to preserve the freedom of the United States. I have stood in Punchbowl and Arlington to view the rows of white crosses and stone markers--so many from WWII. So many that lay under those white crosses at Punchbowl are too young. Why do we take so long to honor those who have fought for us? May God bless all those who have given their life for us and those who are now fighting to preserve our freeedom.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Kevin Synnott, ND — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 14:12:27 GMT

Congressional Medal of Honor.

Gina & another commenter.

Gina, the military likes to reserve the Medal of Honor for those in front-line combat units. Many soldiers & Marines in support roles ended up performing heroic & life saving roles, but didn't receive the M of H because of that technicality.

the other commenter,
Why the Congressional Medal of Honor. Congress has the habit of inserting itself into any situation where there is a good photo op or PR benefit.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Aren Self — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 14:21:32 GMT

Semper-Fi Marine !!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Tim Weisse, Phoenix, AZ — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 14:22:21 GMT

I have what I have because of this heroic stranger. Thanks to all our brave men and women who have given their lives expecting nothing in return. All gave some... some gave all.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Emily Arbes — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 14:29:06 GMT

Read "Flags of Our Fathers" by James Bradley (son of one of the flag raisers, John Bradley) for the full story about the flag raising and the battle for Iwo Jima.

My dad fought in the Pacific and the only time he ever let on the horrors that he witnessed and the pain he suffered was when he was awaken screaming from nightmares.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

W.R. Milford III, Agua Verde, Texas — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 14:32:00 GMT

The first flag raised on Iwo Jima is at the New Marine Corps Museum in Quantico, Va. It IS awesome.
It is across the aisle from the display of thousands of Marine Eagle-Globe-Anchor insignia, representing each Marine killed on that horrible little island.
Suggested reading: "Flags of our Fathers" by James Bradley. His dad was the Corpsman with the Marines.
And...it's the 'Medal of Honor' It is awarded in the name of Congress by the President.
And I just finished McCain's auto-biography 'Faith of My Fathers" and he details how he was shot down, not in the countryside, but in downtown Hanoi. He never had a chance to escape, especially with a broken leg, broken arm and dislocated shoulder.
Nice to see this adjustment to history by one Marine for another Marine. Semper Fi !

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Frank Bandy CMSgt, Springfield, VA — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 14:37:33 GMT

About time. Freedom isn't free.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

L.A. O'Donnell — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 14:40:16 GMT

Having been blessed to visit Iwo Jima not long along, and raise a flag on Mount Suribachi to honor my beloved Marine who died during the battle, this story has great meaning for me. As Audie Murphy and so many other Veterans stated -- the true heroes are the ones that did not come home.

God Bless those who wore the uniform in World War II. And God Bless those who volunteer to wear it today. I will be eternally grateful for your service.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Robert von Esch,Fullerton,California — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 14:47:00 GMT

I'm a WW2 vet who served in the European Theater;but I am so proud of all those Marines who served in the Pacific. I am also proud to be an American when I read the comments made herein that recognize the bravery and dedication of those Marines

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Sheldon Levy USN RET, Orlando, FL — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 14:52:32 GMT

<What about the Congressional Metal of Honor?
Mark, Memphis, TN (Sent Wednesday, July 30, 2008 3:11 PM)>

The Medal of Honor is for "Heroism Above and Beyond The Call of Duty". While impressive in stature, the raising of the FLAGS on Iwo did not constitute that. I believe that 27 Medals of Honor were awarded for actions on Iwo. At least 13 were issued Posthumously as the recipient either died in the actions cited or later in action on IWO.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Sheldon Levy USN RET, Orlando, FL — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 15:03:03 GMT

The names of the flag raisers in the Rosenthal photograph are as follows:
Sgt. Michael Strank USMC
Cpl. Harlon H. Block USMC
PFC. Ira Hayes USMC
PFC. Franklin Sousley USMC
PFC. Rene Gagnon
PH2 John Bradley USN

Both Michael Strank and Harlon Block were killed on March 1st which was D +10 or the 11th day of Battle.

Navy Hospital Corpsman John Bradley was wounded 2 days later on March 3rd.

On March 21st D +30 and only two days before the end of the fight, Franklin Sousley was killed.

Only Rene Gagnon and Ira Hayes survived the battle without injuries.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Sheldon Levy USN RET, Orlando, FL — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 15:09:02 GMT

<Yes, Strank was a hero, as were all those who served in that war and the present one. Let's never forget to honor those who defend our country whether we agree with the cause or not. They did not choose the fight then and they did not choose the fight now, but they have chosen to fight for our country. That's bravery.
Peter Beck, Charleston, SC (Sent Wednesday, July 30, 2008 8:21 PM)>

With respect sir, but those who were US Marines in WWII CHOSE to fight. They knew what was expected of them because of the events of December 7, 1941. They drove, walked ran...whatever to enlistment centers around the country to join up and fight. They did not have to be told what to do.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Rufus McGinnis,Ruston,La — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 15:09:37 GMT

as a veitnam vet i am proud of these men that led the way to my freedom and thanks to the ones today

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Awayne, Cleveland, OH — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 15:10:44 GMT

The reason we still have war is that people have short memories. When peace becomes part of our evolution, maybe then we can really come to appreciate the horror our men went through to get us to a better place. In the meantime, we should take to our hearts, those who have fought to get us this far.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

wally, Houston, Tx — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 15:16:05 GMT

The Medal of Honor was established by act of Congress July 12, 1862. The Prsident presents the Medal of Honor in the name of Congress. It is the Congressional Medal of Honor. God bless our servicemen and women and may he continue to watch over them and our great country.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Fred Koos — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 15:21:25 GMT

God bless this man, Vets gave us freedom and G. Bush took it away.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Trista Kane — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 15:32:52 GMT

Mr. Oswald you should be ashamed og your comments about POW. I hope that one day you will have to look a POW in the eye and say that. By the way, you better hope there isn't another serviceman there because that is his brother/sister in combat that you just belittled.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Proud retired FMF Corpsman — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 15:34:28 GMT

No Congressional, just Medal of Honor. The WindTalkers were a "Top Secret" item and were not declassified until much later after WWII. Sgt Strank WAS an American citizen, he just did not receive the papers saying he was one.
I had occasion to talk with John Bradley, the Navy Hospital Corpsman (Pharmacist's Mate) who aided the flag raising and he felt he wasn't a hero but essentially was at the right place at the right time for such a momentous occasion. He felt that all those he served with were the real heroes. He was also wounded on Iwo Jima.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Dale Russom, Jackson, TN — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 15:38:46 GMT

It is wonderful that Sgt. Strank's family has finally received his citizenship papers. It's too bad that this was overlooked for so long. To the idea that his father was an illegal immigrant, that would not be correct. Immigrants coming into American in the early part of the last century were automatically documented. They didn't sneak over or thru any fences and disappear into the country without being documented. The government knew who they were and where they were. Sgt. Strank's father had a wait for a time before being granted his citizenship. They came and they worked and were never a drain on our resources. They didn't expect government handouts, unlike these illegals today. They learned the language and became part of the melting pot. They truly wanted to be Americans, not just enjoy what America had to offer while still remaining a citizen of another country. There is a right way and a wrong to do anything. If you truly want to be a real American, you will do things the right way instead of breaking the law and, basically, becoming a fugitive in a foreign land. I do not hold with automatically making thousands of illegals citizens, when many other thousands have had to wait five years then take a test to be eligible to become citizens.
God Bless America and God bless Sgt. Strank's family.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Roman,Atlanta GA. — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 15:49:39 GMT

All this jingoistic "God bless" stuff...recall "Gott Mit Uns" was also inscribed on WWI German belts...the unfortunate soldier was engaged in warfare - violence, a violation of any god's principles and yet we celebrate his passing as something glorious and honorable...Freedom some shout !! Japan was not attacking the US but engaged in an emulating plan of expansionist imperialism pushing the influence of Dutch, British and US out of Asia. The US proceeds to counter by incinerating the populace of Japan with incendiary and atomic bombs so that we can all still be speaking English ?? Recall that when Japanese attacked Pear Harbor so as not to be hecotred by marauding US navy, Hawaii was a forcibly occupied territory of the US, not a state of the US.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Corporal Michael A. Standridge, Newberg, Or — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 15:55:21 GMT

To all of you who have seen this article and decide to jump to conclusions based on the title. Shut the hell up, and read what the article says before you speak. He would have already BEEN a citizen first of all. Second, Nobody noticed that he WASN'T a citizen until a Marine Gunny noticed just recently. It wasn't the government trying to not make him a citizen all of these years, it was them not knowing. Quit bringing your political issues into a discussion about an American hero. This is about him.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Larry, Raleigh, nc — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 15:56:51 GMT

to Rita in MN...You are right about it being the Medal of Honor, however it is Congress that authorizes it, so they do have something to do with it.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

anthony, warm springs, OR — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 15:59:38 GMT

"I'm no hero, all the heroes are buried on that island."

Did one of the flag raisers (Cpl. Hayes, Ire H.) say this, or is it legend? IMHO they are all legends.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

JOSEPH E. HUERTA — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 16:04:01 GMT

THE MARINE CORPS -THE FEW - THE PROUD - THE MARINE.
HE WAS ONE OF MANY WHO SERVED OUR COUNTRY AND THE MARINE CORPS. SEMPER FI
AKA APACHE JOE USMC RET'D 32 AND SIX.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Jim, Hummelstown Pa — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 16:16:19 GMT

God Bless Sgt. Strank and his family. Thank you to all VETS.
JR
USAF

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Mary Shellaby, Rockport, Texas — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 16:23:58 GMT

Some of these coments mention WW2 was a different time, different war. The only difference I see, is the new service men and women are all voluntary enlistees. They are there because they love their country and want to keep it free. They are still giving their lives so the rest of us can enjoy this great country we live in. The least we can do for them is to back them 100%. Just remember, the ones doing the criticizing,. reap the same benifits as the ones standing up for our service men and women. God bless these brave men and women.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Bob Garcia, Rapid City, SD — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 16:31:05 GMT

It is particularly pleasing to see that the Marines' tradition of "Semper Fideles," Always Faithful, is still very much in the hearts of today's Marines who will look after another who served so long ago. Although I served a career in the US Air Force, I remain proud of all my brothers and sisters who serve this great nation wherever and whenever they are called.
Bob Garcia
MSgt, USAF (Ret)

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

E Horton — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 16:34:06 GMT

There are two types of people in this world...STS people and STO people...STS =Service to self
STO= Service to others
There are a lot of STO people in our fighting forces and in reading the book FAITH OF OUR FATHERS you will see a lot of the STO people there.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Chatles Balent, Kentwood MI — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 16:44:29 GMT

An award long overdue !
I am a Vietnam combat veteran & I served with GI's from other countries who enlisted to attain American citizenship. I hope all of them have been rewarded for their efforts. The same goes for those who are in Iraq & Afghanistan.
Semper Fi, Sgt. Strank !

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

WJ Breslin, Coral Gables, FL — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 16:46:15 GMT

Let's remember this when we talk about immigrants today. This man made the ultimate sacrifice for this country but was born elsewhere. The millions of people here, who like Sgt. Strank were not as lucky as the rest of us to be born in the best country in the world, are also overwhelmingly good people who quietly aspire to the dream that is America.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Major Ron Bennett USMC, Retired — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 16:46:28 GMT

Semper Fi

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Daughter of a WWII vet — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 16:47:28 GMT

God Bless Sgt Strake! He legally immigrated with his family and became a US citizen. He loved and appreciated this country so much that he fought for Her and he helped to raise Her flag in a momentous battle. Sgt. Strake is an American Hero.

I have no respect for those who come here illegally, raise the flags of their own countries rather than the US flag, and then condemn this country for not giving them what they want.

There is a big difference in the attitudes of today and the attitudes of those who came before us.

May God bless all our military men and women, we cannot thank you enough!!!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

An American — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 16:48:03 GMT

It IS also known as the Congressional Medal Of Honor because it is presented by the President of the U.S. in the name of Congress

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Larry,Springfield,TN — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 16:58:45 GMT

About time someone saw the mistake made and corrected it. This man deserves all that can be given to him and his family. I am a navy veteran from the vietnam era and also know of the hardships the military puts on its men,women, and families. God bless all of them.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Tom, Largo Fl — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 17:01:53 GMT

My dad was part of the 32 div which spent the most time in combat in WWII. He was in combat 33 months!My son is heading out for a second tour in Iraq. Be proud of the men and please think carefully before the next war. We better have a damn good reason

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Allen,Monticello,MN — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 17:04:03 GMT

We (people that are born or traveled to America to stay) should be thanking our present and past service men and women daily. Everyone is given a chance to better themselves and their family because of sacrifices of many who have served. It doesn't matter if a service person on the front lines or behind a desk they all deserve thanks.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Scott Davidson, TSgt, USAF (Ret), York New Salem, PA — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 17:08:28 GMT

I am glad to see the US Government has finally made this Hero a US citizen. 63 years is a long time to wait, but at least he is a citizen. I wonder why it took so long???

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Velandy Manohar, MD FAPA — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 17:10:20 GMT

May God bless Sgt Micheal Strank, USMC and keep him in His loving embrace foever. Semper fi for ever. May God bless the Armed forces of the United States of America and keep them from harm. No greater love has a person than to lay down his or her life for his /her country. I am proud of being a citizen of the United States and deeply grateful to the great heroes who have made the supreme sacrifice on the altar of freedom.I am a proud parent of a Marine( active duty) and stand humbly before them and God for their sacrfice and uncommon valor which as Admiral Nimitz eloquently described as a common Virtue on IWO. I mourn the 6000 dead on Iwo. There is a replica of the Flag raising monument in CT that is visible from Route 9, Visiting the inspriing vent for the ages and driving by the monument sends shivers down your spine and brings tears to your eyes. The sand admixed with the blood sweat and tears of the Marines who conquered Iwo is interred in the base of the monument. Their sacrifice and heroism will never be forgotten. However it is important that we must never forget the source of such valor and self sacrifice in the cause of freedom
We have to kneel before God and offer our love, gratitude and respect to His Divine Majesty for His grace and protection. These verses accurately describe my sentiments and verbalize my prayers -Numbers 6:25 and 6:26.(MAY) "The Lord make His face shine on thee and be gracious to thee." Numbers 6:26 (MAY)" The Lord lift up his countenance on thee and give thee peace."
Psalm 44.3 " For by their own sword they did not possess the land, and by their own arm did not save them. But dear Lord it was by your right hand, your arm and the light of your presence, for you favored them... ( this is the reason why we are free citizens in free nation under God - the United States of America. Semper Fidelis

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Don, Novato, Calif. — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 17:15:48 GMT

My father was the navy corpsman who helped put the flag up. He never talked about it much except to say that every one of those men were injured in some way when the put it up. I am a vietnam vet and I still get tears when I see that picture.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Ginger Tahlequah, OK — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 17:18:53 GMT

If we are going to honor one person who raised the flag on Iwa Jima then we should also, remember our Native American Indian Ira Hayes. The Native Americans are very proud of Ira who served our country. We also, lost one brave young lady not to long ago who felt that she should protect AMERICA.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Cpl C.J. Newell - USMC (Ret) New York, N.Y. — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 17:24:55 GMT

Semper Fi! Sgt Mike Strank - Cpl Harlan Block
Pfc Ira Hayes - Pfc Rene Gagnon - Pfc Franklin
Sousse & Navy Corpsman John Bradley and all
the Heroes of Iwo Jima. You are the True Essence
of the words The Marine Corps builds Men.
Semper Fi to ALL My Marine Brothers, past and
Present. Saddle Up, Lock and Load.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Alice — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 17:32:05 GMT

This man and the others who raised the flag have been honored over and over throughout the years during and after World War II. I am surprised that so many do not seem to know that. He recieved his citizenship when he was just a child when his father was naturalized. It was just the papers that somehow were never given to him. This is a case of correcting a clerical mistake made many years before the war, not a case of not hornoring him.

Regardless of your political beliefs, to downgrade McCain's service is a little silly. You act as though as a pilot, he was not in harm's way, and yet he was shot down and captured by the enemy and held as a prisioner for years. Have you never read any stories of what those men endured in the Vietnam prisons? Do a little research and find out how many men escaped from those prisions. Your ignorance and lack of respect is astounding.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Navy Vet Who CARES! — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 17:33:31 GMT

I'm sorry...I feel that as a requirement for president you MUST serve on Active Duty in the Armed Forces, much like those in line for the throne in England all due their time! How can one POSSIBLY be the Commander-In-Chief if he / she HAS NO CLUE??? That doesn't make this November's election a sure thing, but I'll vote for the PERSON who HAS A CLUE iof what's it's like to have ben there, done that! Community service and a sting in the Illinois Legislature or even the U.S. Senate is NOT releveant to the be the one in charge! I am a Democratic, but I will not vote for either of them!
Where are the true caring people who were elected to serve US not themselves? a.k.a. kennedy, Roosevelt, etc.? Oh I forgot, it's all about the money, power and one's own goals, not to SERVE THE PEOPLE... unlike this Marine who wasn't even born here!!! GRRRRRRRR

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Randy Bazal — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 17:44:15 GMT

THE VETERAN

Be proud to be an American,
fly Old Glory everywhere.
But folks, in case it slips your mind,
A VET helped keep her there.

I ask, "You like your freedom?"
and you answer, "Yes, you bet!"
and then I ask of you, my friend,
"Have you ever thanked a VET?"

There are thousands of VETS around you,
they fought for you and me.
Some lost their arms, legs, and life
so all of us could be free.

So when you think you have it bad
you can take this to the bank,
You don't have it bad at all,
and you have a VET to thank!

Sgt. Randall Bazal,
1964-68 USMC M.O.U.T

We will always remember these brave souls:
Block, Bradley, Gagnon, Hayes, Sousley, and Strank

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Salg, boise, idaho — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 17:50:53 GMT

Fantastic that his citizenship was finally recognized with that valued document.

Strengthens the fact that we are a land of immigrants who are willing to give what it takes to be recognized as citizens of this great country!!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Anand Maharaj Norfolk Va — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 18:15:41 GMT

Every single man and woman serving or has served in the United States Armed Forces are Heros. Whenever I see one of our citizen in uniform, I always look them in the eye and say "Thanks for serving our country"

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Ron Moraca — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 18:22:44 GMT

This is for Maria: The CMO originated in Congress during the Civil War, which is why it's called the Congressional Medal of Honor.
I agree with many of you who responded. The CMO or a man's war record should NOT be politicized.
I'm pro-McCain, not because he's a retired war vet, as I am, but because he won't sell America down the river, like Obama will, once elected.
As for Sgt Strank, I've readed Flags of Our Fathers by James Bradley, and I recommend that it be required reading by high school students nation-Wide and for all students in our service academies.
It's a beautifully-written book; it's one of my favorite books and I'm proud to have it.
Sgt Mike Strank and Jack Bradley are two of my heroes, for they fought for our country. Sgt Strank died for our country.
For the record, the other flag raisers were Harlon Block, USMC, Rene Gagnon, USMC, Franklin Sousley, USMC, and Ira Hayes, USNMC.
May they all rest in honored glory forever.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Janicemary D'Arcy — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 18:30:51 GMT

It is uplifting to learn that Sgt. Strank is finally
honored for his courage and patriotism! In this
anti-military/anti-american environment here, it
gives me hope that so many people realize the sacrifices the men and women of ALL wars made so
that we can continue to live in freedom...despite
what the Media and Bolshevik Hollywood propagate
to the public !

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Steve House London, Kentucky — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 18:32:27 GMT

Great story about a great marine! But of course,all the men and women who have served in the armed forces of the United States of America are worthy of our respect! Remember our veterans! SEMPER FI!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

ANON — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 19:00:36 GMT

Actually, the first flag that was raised on the mountain, but they thought it was too small to be seen so they raised the second one.
Better late than never for issuing the papers.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Leo Barton, Roseburg, OR — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 19:06:21 GMT

God bless you Sgt. Strank.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Obama Fan — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 19:30:37 GMT

Obama is awesome! and your next president

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Nicki Rifle, CO — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 19:40:01 GMT

Let us be ever thankful for all who have served, all who are serving, and all who will serve in the future. Our country will only ever be free as long as all of us fight to keep it that way whether it be on foreign soil or right here in our own back yards. We ALL are AMERICA!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Dana Keene — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 19:47:06 GMT

It's the Mike Strank's of the world that made this country as great as it is. Lets not forget they gave their all.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

jone — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 19:47:55 GMT

Yeah, Ira Hayes was Native American Indian, and he was recognized there for helping to raise that flag. I wonder if his people were even recognized at that time, by the gov't(and country) that he fought for.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

John Richardson — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 19:53:07 GMT

My grandfathers plane was shot down during WWII, when flying between England and Germany. He survived, was captured and escaped several times, making it closer to home each time, but then the war ended while he was still a prisoner.

He was a brave, strong, honorable man; Only one of his decendants is in prison on a regular basis, and that's because he's working as a guard. His wife has an autographed picture of Bush/Cheney.

I noticed he got a lot of advertisement mail covered with patriotic symbols, and things like "If you served in World War II, you qualify for benefits!"... Thing is, he served in the Luftwaffe.

So if my grandfather could become a fully documented US Citizen, It's the least that could be done for Marine Sgt. Michael Strank.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Cat-Colorado — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 19:53:53 GMT

I may be only in my twenties, but every time I look at that image of those men raising our flag, I do not see individuals; what branch of the military, what color, what political views, what nationality or religion. Those men didn't stand up to have their picture taken as individuals, they didn't FIGHT to be viewed as indivual heros, no they fought side by side with their brothers and held those who selflessly gave their lives to protect the IDEA of freedom! And then those faceless men raised the ultimate symbol of pride, honor, and sacrafice as ONE, the way it should be to honor every single soldier past, present, and future. And then, they returned to thier brothers-in arms and contiued to fight for our rights as human beings. Thank you Sargeant Strank and all the men and woman who protected my right for life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. God bless you all!!!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Paul, Millown, NJ — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 19:55:44 GMT

No one who was ever a Marine is an EX-Marine, you're a Marine until the day you die! Semper Fi Sargent Strank, rest in peace brave Marine, brave American.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Paul, Milltown, NJ — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 19:58:59 GMT

Rita, it is called the Congressional Medal of Honor because it is awarded in the name of the People of the United States, however it is referred to as The Medal of Honor.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

JIM KING — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 19:59:08 GMT

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

JIM KING — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 20:05:07 GMT

A WONDERFUL AND DESERVING TRIBUTE TO A BRAVE AND UNSELFISH MARINE. MY WISH IS THE GOVERNMENT WOULD PREPARE THE PROPER AWARD FOR IRA HAYES-A FULL
BLOOD PIMA INDIAN. HE ASSISTED IN THE FLAG
RAISING OPERATION AND WAS A HERO. HE DIED
DRUNK IN AN ARIZONA PRISON STILL SUFFERING FROM
THE EFFECTS OF THE WAR. A FORGOTTON MARINE.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

SSgt Mac McCurdy, Cherry Point, NC — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 20:05:42 GMT

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

John Doe Seattle washington — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 20:11:53 GMT

Michael Strank was a true American hero. Unfortunately, he was killed in a friendly fire incident. An Allied ship was shelling the Japanese when a shell landed short and killed Michael Strank

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Cherriez95 Romulus MI — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 20:17:44 GMT

I think all the men in Iwo Jima should be honered also.
Read the book/movie "Flags of Our Fathers" by James Bradley and Ron Powers. IT'S REALLY GOOD!!!!!!!It is about all the men who rose the flag.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Daniel M Crowley — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 20:28:57 GMT

Kurt Oswald Apple creek Ohio, you are a true idiot, your comaparitive and lack of a genuine respect for content of this article is Embarrasing and Sad.
God Bless America, God bless or Troops.
Semper FI - URAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Robert, Kernville, CA — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 20:32:04 GMT

The Medal of Honor is the highest award for valor in action against an enemy force which can be bestowed upon an individual serving in the Armed Services of the United States. Generally presented to its recipient by the President of the United States of America in the name of Congress, it is often called the Congressional Medal of Honor.
The Congressional Medal of Honor Society

Sorry Rita,
The Medal of Honor is given in the name of Congress, and although we have had some pretty poor Congressmen, they were all duly elected by a citizenry that owes this freedom to our soldiers.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Mike, Olney, MD — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 20:38:46 GMT

Actually, Crosby, Stills and Nash said it best when they sang, "Find the cost of freedom, buried in the ground. Mother Earth will swallow us, lay your body down." The cost of freedom is sacrifice, toil and many times blood. You can discover the cost of freedom, buried in the hallowed grounds of Arlington. God bless the USA!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Viet Nam Era USMC Sgt E-5 St. Louis, Mo — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 20:38:50 GMT

A Navy Corpsman is a Marine

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Ken Coye, Malden, Ma. — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 21:12:02 GMT

I read about Mike Strank in the the great book, Flags of our Fathers. He is the model along with Pat Tillman of selflessness. We live in a society where even presidential candidates can't tell you about their service to the country.Whether it be the Peace Corps or the Marine Corp, we must return to the notion that all of us, especially healthy, young males have an obligation to service.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

charles leo n.y. — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 21:18:03 GMT

as a ww2 vet i think our usa is going down the drain god bless our vet

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

charles leo n.y. — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 21:18:04 GMT

as a ww2 vet i think our usa is going down the drain god bless our vet

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Don Waldorf, Md — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 21:23:04 GMT

My Dad was a Marine on Iwo too, he watched the flag raising from the base of Suribachi. From what he told us (not until we were adults) it was hell on earth there! I also had several Uncles and cousins that served in the Marines, Army and Navy in WWII, Korea, Vietnam, and Iraq. What Sgt. Strank and the rest of the Marines and Navy corpsman did on that island in 1945 saved a lot of lives in the long run and helped to give us the freedoms we have today.And politics shouldnt be involved in this discussion. To the guy that disrespected Senator McCain for being shot down and then captured, Have you ever flown a fighter jet with anti-aircraft fire/flak coming at you or been in a dogfight with an enemy pilot? You dont know the circumstances of his capture. He may have crash landed in a field full of Vietnamese for all you know. He may not have had the opportunity and blessing and good fortune your relative had in evading capture. That was an uncalled for statement on your part. How can you question his courage if you werent there? The hell he and others went thru as a POW is well documented. If you dont like him as a candidate fine vote for whomever, but dont say things like that about his service that you dont know squat about! The article is about Sgt. Strank and I wish he had been honored with his citizenship before but these things happen sometimes. At least his sister has some comfort and solace in the honor. And great kudos to the Marine Gunny that found the problem and helped give a little dignity and honor to a fallen hero and his family. Thank you to all servicemen and women, no matter when you have served! Semper Fi!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

N8TV TEXN not in Texas — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 21:43:39 GMT

It is so interesting to see how much emotion these types of stories still invoke in people. For the most part, I believe Americans are PROUD of our military, and still get teary-eyed when the Star Spangled Banner is played because they think of the sacrifices of those on Iwo Jima, Normandy Beach, and those at Gettysburg and those who fought the British in the early years of our country- hundreds of years of sacrifice for freedom.

Someone posted that many of the men who fought in WWII were drafted, therefor they did not really GIVE their lives. Maybe so, I don't know the statistics on that, but I know my grandfather enlisted on Dec. 8, 1941- the day after Pearl Harbor was bombed. I know my other grandfather enlisted 2 days after that. I know one of them fought in Germany, France, Africa- and the other one was on Normandy Beach on D-Day. I know one of them was one of the first Americans in Dachau to liberate that concentration camp. I know my great-Uncle survived the Bataan Death March. (By the way, read "Ghost Soldiers" a GREAT book about the Bataan Death March and those that survived it and were sent to a POW camp.) I know my father-in-law was in active combat during 2 tours in Vietnam as a Marine. I know my daddy was in the Air Force for 25 years, and my little brother just returned from his first tour of duty in Iraq as a sniper in the Army in one of the most dangerous neighborhoods in Baghdad. I know my niece left today-just hours ago-for her first tour in Iraq as an Army medic.

My children are being raised to understand that freedom isn't free, that many have GIVEN their lives for it, and that if afforded the opportunity, serving our country is an honor. There are so many men and women serving out there who believe in what they are doing, the mission, this country- no matter what is happening politically at home, they get up every day not knowing if it will be their last, but they are doing it willingly.

I'm glad Michael Strank's sister was given his citizenship papers, all these years later. Thank you to all of you who have served and are serving this wonderful country. None of us would be speaking English without you!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Ed Melanson,So Plainfield NJ — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 21:44:58 GMT

God Bless any US soldier who lost his life in defense of his country...and his fellow soldiers...my dad was in North Africa and Italy in WWII, never talked about his time was proud to serve..I served during the Vietman Conflict..once a solder always a soldier...God Bless Sgt Strank one of the many who gave the ultimate sacrifice

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Lt.Col.Ken Patterson .USMC (retired) — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 22:30:04 GMT

"Semper Fi" Mike

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

hfinney, Philadelphia, PA — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 22:34:30 GMT

Yes! there would be. Patton

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

AC — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 22:37:08 GMT

Isn't the correct title of the memorial the USMC War Memorial and not the Iwo Jima Memorial?

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Anyonmous — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 22:51:22 GMT

you kill one your a murder
you kill ten your a monster
you kill 100 your a hero
you kill 1000 your a legend

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

John in Moapa — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 22:53:17 GMT

God bless him. A member of the "Greatest Generation!" Thanks from a "Baby Boomer" and my sons that belong to "Generation X".

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Mark, Everett Wash — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 23:20:13 GMT

An earlier post plagarizes - actual statement of then Sec'y of the Navy James Forrestal to Lt Gen Holland (Howlin Mad) Smith - USMC Commander - on a ship watching the flag being raised: "The raising of that flag on Suribachi means a Marine Corps for the next 500 years." Read "Flags of our Fathers" - wonderful and tragic account of the men involved.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Rich Vettraino,Phila.Pa. — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 23:22:03 GMT

God Bless Sgt.Strank and all of the service men & women who have been giving there all ss we may be free. Semper Fi, from a former Marine and USAF vet.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

scir91 from youtube — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 23:25:03 GMT

it's too bad that the US treats all military members pathetically. how about raising pay or making lives better for their spouses? these young men give their lives for $800 a month of pay. then they come home with a lifetime of stigma (you're a crazy marine) or PTSD or domestic problems. who would want to work for a company like that?

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Christopher Nelson — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 23:47:53 GMT

The bravery of these men is beyond my comprehesion. If I ever found myself in circumstances like his, I wonder if I could even be 10% the man Michael Strank and his comrades were.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Wayne Macaulay, Sgt. USMC — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 00:00:20 GMT

Very colorful and interesting comments. It is the exercise of free speach being exhibited that also honors Sgt. Strank. Without men like him the rest of us would probably not have that freedom today. As my DI in boot camp in 1967 said "It is not so important that you be some kind of war hero when you go to Viet Nam. It is enough that you showed up when duty called." Sgt Strank showed up.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

A "2112" Angelton Texas — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 00:30:34 GMT

To the Gunny who found this oversite I say"You kept the faith, you honor the code". It is unfortunate that oversights like this happen, but it shows that we as Americans try as best we can to make it right. To the "greatest generation" this is but another valadation of the challenge you faced. To those of us who came after, this is the standard we should try to strive for.Articles like this remind us what true greatness looks like. And when you look at the picture of this Marine,and then look at a picture of those who are serving us now, the names are different, but I see the same look of a patriot there. Thank you. Bless those who have served, and are doing so now.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

e.schmitt,detroit,mi — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 00:46:14 GMT

the freedom to boo ,was earned by the blood of heros.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Peter Rollin Altus OK. — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 01:09:27 GMT

God Bless all our troops past and present.There should be more news on what they do for the countries
that they are in and stop trying to degrade them as the news media does all the time.God Bless all of you from me and my family.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

G. Brewer (USAF. Ret.) Carthage, Ms. — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 01:19:59 GMT

These kind of mistakes are many. As Americans and veterans it angers and makes us sad. We can only be thankful that there are those who see the wrong and make it right. Servicmen need the support of their families and countryman. We may not all give our lives willingly but it must be understood that we have given ourselves if called upon to be placed in harmes way knowing full well it could cost our lives. So I say to you,yes they did give their lives because they loved their country and undersood it would have to be defended with lives, theirs if necessary.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

B. Pruitt, Babson Park,Fl. — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 01:29:14 GMT

If only today's generation took the time out and learned what their relatives did for them. My father was paratrooper the 101st Airborne, in the BATTLE OF THE BULDGE,in WWII. He served our country in the worst conditions, in far away places, giving, so we may enjoy FREEDOM!!
Pray each night thanking God for what we have.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Myra Parrott, Lochbuie, Colo. — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 02:03:43 GMT

One of those men at Iwo Jima was a young Native American, Ira Hayes. He was one of the brave soldiers to raise that flag. He went home to the Navaho reservation a hero, and to all of us this brave soldier sacrificed in too many ways for the United States of America that he loved and never felt part of, and I am proud for him. He was a hero, he died a hero, and still is an American Hero.
God Bless America and all our boys & girls fighting for the love of country, family, and home. Thank you.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Myra Parrott, Lochbuie, Colo. — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 02:24:40 GMT

I have heard stories about WWII and Korea, Viet Nam, and Afghanistan, and Iraq. In all of the stories I have heard there is one word that stands out. HERO! Webster's dictionary describes "HERO, as a mythological or legendary figure often of divine descent endowed with great strength or ability, one that shows great courage." I define a HERO as my father, uncles, brothers, sisters, neices, nephews, cousins, friends, who left thier homes and family, all they knew to spend lonely nights wondering if tomorrow would be their last day on earth. To all the soldiers who have had to swin in water and muck, to drag fallen comrades to safety, the ones who lived on to take care of the jobs they had to do at home, the ones who fell on foriegn soil, grieving mothers and fathers, living now and then. To these men and women I say you are the HEROS, described so eloquently in Websters. I SAY THANK YOU!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Steve, St. Louis, MO — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 02:30:10 GMT

We should always honor and thank the men and women of all the branches of military service, even when we don't agree with our government's actions. I have to stand on my little soapbox here and say I think it is appalling that so many Americans today are buying so many products, particularly automobiles, made by the descendants of the very people we were fighting against in WW2. To me that isn't a very good way to thank our WW2 veterans and those who lost their lives fighting for our nation.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Myra Parrott, Lochbuie, Colo. — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 02:34:54 GMT

Dennis Cook, Vancouver, B.C.; I say this, God bless YOU, your family, and Canada for sacrificing in a conflict that you did not have to be in, for a country you did not have to fight for. Thank you from myself, my family, and my country, you are truly one of our HEROS! GOD BLESS THE USA AND CANADA!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Andras Zaborski Spokane Washington — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 02:42:13 GMT

My deepest respect for all those who are the real heros the ones who give the ultimat, their life.
It can not be higher heroism than that

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Chris Lund Wichita, Ks — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 03:06:11 GMT

I'm glad someone mentioned the Women Vets as well, as my Father was a Marine on Guadacanal and had 30 years as a Marine, My Mother was a Combat Nurse with the 10th Army 76th Field Hospital. They were in the battle of Saipan which is where the Marines left from to go to Iwo and as Iwo was too small to have a field Hospital on it only Batallion Aid Stations, the wounded were brought back to Saipan, She the landed on Okinawa on 4 April 1945, the first nurses on Okinawa and for 3 months watched the Kamakazis strike the fleet in Naha bay. She was always amazed by the Marines that were brought into the Hosptial and had tickets back home for their wounds would generaly, after being patched up and got their strength back, they would sneak back to the front to rejoin their unit. That is one big reason she married my Dad. Also, When they left Seattle in early 44, it was for the "duration". She went on to be in the Occupation of Tokyo until Feb 46.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

John, Phoenix Arizona — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 03:35:56 GMT

Many people talk about the bravery these men had and what they wouldn't do for their country back then, and it is true times have changed. Back then everyone wanted to pitch in any way they could, even if it didn't mean fighting. It seems that today people are too self focus'd to make sacrifices for others without personal gain. God bless these hero's.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Paul B Walker, Minot ND — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 03:51:21 GMT

Hey Roman,Atlanta GA you are in SERIOUS need of a mental health eval. Little of what you say is grammatically correct. Do you seriously believe the BS you wrote?? You know, the part where you say that "Japan was not attacking the US but engaged in an emulating plan of expansionist imperialism pushing the influence of Dutch, British and US out of Asia.".
You need to get back on your lithium and STFU you clueless liberal POS.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Alan Kaplan, Walnut Creek, Ca. — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 04:02:09 GMT

A true hero. God bless America and God Bless the Marines.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Chris, Victoria, TX — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 05:05:05 GMT

<<Let us not forget that the only people who gave their lives for us were Jesus Christ and the American Serviceman.>>

Oh gimmie a break....

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

USMC Sniper, Idaho — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 05:20:19 GMT

John McCain was shot down and captured with two broken arms, one broken leg, his shoulder was crushed by a rifle butt and he had been stuck with a bayonet. I challenge any of you morons who think he was wrong because he did not escape to re-think your comment. Maybe he should have tried for the 1968 Olympics. What scares me about some of your comments is that legally you morons can vote. God help the rest of us.

Regarding the USMC Sgt. Strank his family was given papers confirming his citizenship because they previously had not been issued to him. The papers complete what is probably the family's record of his life. No more no less. Many Vets and their families keep and maintain military records. It was a big event in most of our lives.

As with all those who served in WWII, either draftee or volunteer, those of us alive today owe them and huge Thank you and may they rest in peace. The heroes of that generation answered the call. Semper Fi.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

V.S. Chicago, Il. — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 05:28:34 GMT

Now if the Fed's would learn how to and care better for the vet's that would be much better, for other countries honor and respect their vet's much better then we do our own. Pitty on our government for not treating vet's better.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Heather Fisher, Hanford, CA — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 05:56:34 GMT

God bless this great country and the men and women who serve so selflessly. It's pathetic that they are not remembered more, treated better, and thanked more often for the service they give. This country will only remain great so long as there are men and women defending our rights and freedoms. Unfortunately, there are many who would disband our Armed Forces. If that ever happens, amen to all that we have been blessed with. "It is easy to take liberty for granted, when you have never had it taken from you." ~Dick Cheney
Thank you, current and former service people, and the families who support you, for all you have done, do, and will do.

My God! How little do my countrymen know what precious blessings they are in possession of, and which no other people on earth enjoy! ~Thomas Jefferson

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Richard-Orcas Island, WA — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 06:07:01 GMT

I can track our families military service back to the Revolutionary War.I feel the armed services men & women, who have died,in Iraq, were wasted in a botched oil grab by Bush/Cheney. They did their duty but the War in Iraq was based on a premeditated lie!
I feel that Bush/Cheney should be drug before the world court,in the Hague, for crimes against humanity and the murder of over 4,000 American soilders,sailors and marines! The real war is stil in Afganistan but Bush couldn't bring himself to 'Get Bin Laden' because of the close working ties between Bush Sr. & the Bin Laden Family. Those who have died did so with honor & integrity even thou the war in Iraq is a sham. Good people died in a bad war. Now, The Iraqi Government is asking us to go home. Obama has a plan to get our troops out in 16 months; McCain wants to keep troops there for 100 years! God help us.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Dave Wieland, AZ — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 06:16:45 GMT

As it says on the monument in Washington, "Where uncommon valor was common." Thank you Sgt. Strank and to my Dad who was a Marine in the South Pacific. Semper Fi.......

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Bob,Dingmans Ferry — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 06:39:34 GMT

SEMPER FI

Killing the enemy makes you a hero,not being shot down and captured.

Sgt York and Audie Murphy are people I think of when hearing the words 'war hero' used.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Catherine, Oregon — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 06:39:48 GMT

My 19 year old daughter is a USMC LCpl serving in Iraq. Semper Fi & God bless each & every one of our men & women in uniform.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Wayne Jones, USN, ENC, ret., Kirkland, WA — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 07:00:34 GMT

Does anyone realize that our service men and women are ambassadors of the USA around the world? Our armed services along with the Stars and Stripes let the despots know that their actions will not tolerated by a country that believes in life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Sgt Phil, Evergreen Colorado — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 07:04:32 GMT

Semper Fi.
Without The United States Marines their would not be an America and the Land of the Free.
Thank You.
God bless all of our men and women in uniform past and present.

7th US Cavalry (Army) Vietnam Veteran and proud to have served in time of need. Garry Owen!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

BM3, Baltimore MD — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 07:36:29 GMT

R Tesch, Salt Lake City, Ut- What does knowing about the military have to do with being elected prez. I service my country but I will be voting Obama. Shoot if Clinton and G.W. can be voted in with no service ( bush so called service doesn't count).

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Daniel Cox, Wasilla, Alaska — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 07:39:16 GMT

My Uncle Al was at Iwo Jima and throughout the Pacific campaign. My father was a Navy Airdale all across the Pacific, as well as Korea, and Vietnam. I Played in the Sandbox with Desert Storm 1 Aas well as operation Iraqi Freedom. It hurts me to think that anyone whom is willing to lay down their life for their country would ever be forgotten. God Bless all of our men and women that paricipated and participate in the defense of our great Nation.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Daniel Cox, Wasilla, Alaska — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 07:46:55 GMT

My Uncle Al was at Iwo Jima and throughout the Pacific campaign. My father was a Navy Airdale all across the Pacific, as well as Korea, and Vietnam. I Played in the Sandbox with Desert Storm 2 As well as Iraqi Freedom. It hurts me to think that anyone whom is willing to lay down their life for their country would ever be forgotten. God Bless all of our men and women that paricipated and participate in the defense of our great Nation.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Nathan Baxter, Colorado Springs, CO — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 08:04:09 GMT

I am proud to be a former US Marine. Men like this inspire me and others to do what we have done, and give hope that this nation is still what it was. 4 generations of us, all US Marines. Semper Fi, and rest in peace.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Ray , Anawalt ,WV — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 10:56:45 GMT

As a veteran who was never in harm's way I am honored to say Thank You to this fallen hero. Why does it often take decades for these heroes to be recognized for their contributon to and their family's loss. Again I applaud the efforts of all involved in this recognition.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

unknown, michigan — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 11:05:13 GMT

I'm crying over the words wrote about him, I tryed to join the service when I was younger and I could'nt get in. War is hell, all the lost souls that had their chance at life taken from them. I had always wished to join.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

GF — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 11:27:34 GMT

This recognition is well-deserving for Marine Sgt. Michael Strank. He made the ultimate sacrifice for all of U.S. Thank you.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Roy Berry, Albany, NY — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 11:43:05 GMT

I wish people would stop downplaying this story by trying to introduce political views. This isn't political. These gentlemen served their country to the fullest.

If you have a problem with a politician, vote him out. If you voted for him previously, DON'T VOTE FOR HIM AGAIN. Let's not tarnish these person's belated moment. It has waited long enough.

I once had a college professor who wrote:
It is sometimes better to appear the fool, then to open ones mouth and remove all doubt. Stick to congratulating one of our own that made the ultimate contribution to his country.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Courtney Dawn Mckenley Winnipeg Manitoba, Canada — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 11:48:17 GMT

I would like to comment if I may. I believe that after the war there was alot being done for the men and women who served over seas. The logistics of bringing all those men back and their equipment was a major undertaking. Can you really blame anyone for the oversight of not having the papers done for a fallen hero. All the men and women who served during the two world wars and the conflicts since are heros not just the ones who did flag raisings and other things that set them apart. I am happy that there are still those in positions where such oversights can be found and corrected. I am 27 years old, my father has a German handgun that was surrendered to my Grandfather by a German officer in Holland. I am Canadian but I too have a deep respect for solders from all nations who served over seas. Not only in whe world wars but the wars that have been fought since. Noone truly wants war. I would like to thank all who served from the United States and from all other Allied nations.

Thank you.
Courtney

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Ken Hays, Birmingham, AL — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 11:50:20 GMT

Every high school student should be required to read, and every adult American should also read, "Flags of our Fathers" to gain insight and understanding of what the WW II generation committed and sacrificed. read it and you'll understand why the vets don't talk; and keep a box of tissue handy, it is heart rending. I am the son and nephew of 6 WW II vets, two didn't come home. Too late now to thank most of those Vets but I ask everyone to display the guts to thank everyone you see in uniform today, loud enough for everyone around you to hear, especially in public places: "Thank you for serving our Country, thanks for doing the job".

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

joe Halpern — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 12:14:40 GMT

we must not forget these brave men who saved western civilization. I for one make sure I say "Thank you,"
every time I meet one of them

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Gary, Texas — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 12:23:57 GMT

The brotherhood of all Marines is very strong, and even the time can not replace it, Semper FI, America should be proud to have men and women in its ranks, Remember Freedom has a Flavor that the Protected will never taste. As for the comments of Mr. McCain, I was on the ground as a Marine in Vietnam, and would not have traded places with him, some should read the accounts of the things that were done to the Men that were there, Facing the Possibility of getting shot, and getting beaten every day till you pass out is alot different, lest we loose sight of this, we will not honor those that gave alot of themselfs to safe guard any ops and plans that the North was trying to find out, Why do they have General Orders when captured, Semper FI to all that server, and those who gave there life so I could be blessed in a country that will allow point of thought, not met with jail time to express my views, thats John McCain, and Mr. Strank, for the freedom and the flavor of knowing what it taste like.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Steve Schofield Tyler, TX — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 12:51:48 GMT

According to the book Flags Of Our Fathers, written by flagraising Corpsman Bradly's son, Mike Strank was a just an every day sergeant taking care of his men in an extraordinary way during horrible times. The book also says that when the movie Sands Of Iwo Jima was made with John Wayne, his character was based on Mike Strank. Semper Fi Strank.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Larry, Crossville, TN — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 13:02:03 GMT

I honor this man too,but let's get one thing straight: Having been in a war (field medic Vietnam 1968-69) I can tell you than soldier/sailor "gives his life for his country". He puts himself in harm's way in defense of country and that is the noblest of sacrifices. He is not a hero because he died there and then, he is a hero because he could be counted upon to be there when buddies (and SECONDLY his country) needed him. For that, and all veterans of every war deserve our thanks and loyalty bto them when they need us. Having been in combat, I can tell you that soldiers,for the most part don't have grandious ideals, they have love for their fellow soldiers that that few understand who haven't been there. THEY ARE ALL HEROES. I exclude myself from this elite corps because all I did was save the ones I could.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Archie C Haase — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 13:11:37 GMT

I am a combat (former) Marine who also fought in some of the Marine Corps major battles as a Lance Corporal. I hate these type of press releases. What is happening here is our government trying to make us feel better about how they treated combat veteran. while not costing them any money.

How many veterans of Iwo Jima died in sewage gutters drunk like Ira Hayes while their neighbors thought they were just drunks with weak character disorders unable to deal with life? Americans are stupid. Remember not long ago Joe Foss a former state governor and founder of the old American Football League and Marine Corps “Medal of Honor” winner who had his Medal of Honor taken off him when boarding a plane because it was considered a weapon. They did not even know what a Medal of Honor was.

These feel good fuzzy actions like giving this deserving man a citizen certificate is nuts. And self serving to anyone not in his family..

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Daniel A. Bachrach, Sgt. USMC Nashville, TN — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 13:27:00 GMT

I agree with the other writers - please don't politicize this. As for the writers asking why it took so long to honor this Marine. He was honored officially 63 years ago with the Medal of Honor. The presenting of his official citizenship papers was simply an act showing a) A brother Marine looking out for one of our own and b) Reminding people of the sacrifices of our brave troops.

I am proud to know that as a Marine, regardless of what is going on around us, there is another Marine looking out for me as I would for him. The Gunnery Sgt. who discovered the mistake was doing no more or less than is expected of a US Marine. He was taking care of one of our own. This is the code we live by and that we accept the day we earn our Eagle, Globe and Anchor.

There is but one thing to say to both Sgt. Strank, the Gunny, and Sgt. Stranks' family - and we say it loud and strong: SEMPER FI

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Larry, Crossville, TN — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 13:29:31 GMT

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Beth, Norfolk, Virginia — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 13:35:19 GMT

Bless Sgt Strank and the gift he and countless others gave (and give to this day). And by that I mean not just his life...but his patriotism, his time, his courage and his honor. I agree that immigrants should get citizenship upon honorable discharge. Perhaps that is how so many of the illegal immigrants should find their path to citizenship. Join our military and see what being a member of this country is all about. I appreciate the 70,000 immigrants who are members of our armed forces now and hope that they move to the head of the line in getting their papers. As far as politics...it can't help but creep in to almost everything. Americans are on edge about a number of things and want leadership they can believe in. Unfortunately I don't like either one of our candidates. Obama just doesn't have the experience, no matter what a great orator he is. His voting record while seriving as a JUNIOR Senator is almost nonexistent. Voting 'present' doesn't count in my book. And McCain just seems to be talking the same talk as the current administration does. Congress can't seem to get a single thing done, and there are no 'details' about plans from either McCain or Obama to fix things. Personally I thing Congress should have to STAY in session until they figure out a way to work together and get something done about this energy issue. No break for them until they perform their jobs. That's how it works out here in the REAL world. Job performance based. Can't do your job? You're fired.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Gary, Santa Clara, CA — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 21:55:13 GMT

Great stuff. My grandfather was born in a covered wagon on the Oregon trail and also served as a U.S. Marine from '38-'46 including action at Guam, Pelilui, Tulagi, and a few other places.

Many years later (60's) he wanted to go on vacation but the State Dept. wouldn't issue him a passport because he didn't have a birth certificate. His mother had to go down to the State Dept. office in SF to vouch for him being born in the U.S...his honorable discharge papers apparently weren't enough for them back then either.

I don't know how this GySgt tracked this down but Semper Fi for his accomplishment. Someone buy him a beer if ya run into him!!!

Garrett B.
former USMC

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

J. Quantico, VA — Sun, 03 Aug 2008 00:32:33 GMT

Rob W... technically Strank was NOT a soldier but a Marine-- there is a difference! So it would be better to say "thank our military"

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

DD — Sun, 03 Aug 2008 18:53:57 GMT

Semper Fi! We stand on the shoulers of those who have gone before!

USMC 1961-1968

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Richard B. Smith — Mon, 04 Aug 2008 11:52:17 GMT

Hi... How we care for our veterans?... well last friday I spent $30.00 for medicine after a doctors appointment I am 67 years old now and served for 24 years 7 months in the United States Navy... the V,A, won't help me... the Military treatment facilities are so far away that any visit is impossible... the paperwork is of an unimaginable complexity and continually changing nature... the folks that took my money in the drug store never thought about a veteran paying for his medicine... and why should they... they never saw my service and they never served... they have the same notions of patriotism that four and five years olds have while riding in a wagon at our little forth of July parade... and the frequently remind each other "God Bless America" when in fact, this god they worship didn't just make America, he made the whole world... I say "god bless the whole world without exception"

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Richard B. Smith — Mon, 04 Aug 2008 12:06:00 GMT

Hi... to Rita in Minneapolis... the Medal of Honor has everything to do with congress... like it or not, know it or not, it is and can be authorized only by congress... it cannot be awarded by a branch of our military... it cannot be awarded by our president. it can be recommended by our military and it may be presented by our president, but is is only authorized by an act of congress... that perhaps explains why it is usually referred to as the Congressional Medal of Honor... that is however a misnomer, it is the Medal of Honor, and referring to it by a different title does not change it's title... But, Rita I thank you for your good thoughts, I know that you also are a good server... and that you love our country as much as I or anyone else does...has god blessed America?... yes, he has blessed it with people like you!

Warm regards Richard

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Thom, Alaska — Mon, 11 Aug 2008 23:31:22 GMT

Would the British rather be speaking German or be grateful for the Americans that kept England from invasion by the Nazis? Everybody hates war, None more than those of us that served.
Ian Musgrove from Cambridge England said: "WAR a great word,for old men to sending young men to their deaths "

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Mike, Hendersonville, Tennessee — Tue, 12 Aug 2008 00:48:23 GMT

Politics has no place in the discussion. Anyone that thinks otherwise needs to pay a visit to Washington DC, pay a visit to Arlington, the Wall, the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier, and the other memorials to our fallen heroes. I have two flags in my possession that I will not fly. One covered my grandfather's casket for his service in WWI. the other covered my Dad's casket for his service in Korea. Both were honorable men that served their country like countless others.

When you see a vet, thank him or her for their service. Without their integrity and dedication, we would not enjoy our freedoms today. I'll challenge anyone that can see a military funeral, hear the bugle, and the shots from the rifles. If you can walk away with a dry eye, there is something wrong.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Boyd , U.S.A.F. Vietnam and Thailand — Tue, 12 Aug 2008 02:19:02 GMT

Mr. Oswalt, you need to rememer that John McCain was
injured before he got out of his aircraft and the
vietnamese beat him even more. Yes, your uncle had
good training and was very fortunate to get him and
his comrade back to his own lines. You leave a lot
out of the story....And I'll leave out the story of
my 2d cousin that sold his farm,joined the Marines,
only to be in the hold of a troopship that was sunk
by the Germans off of Iceland. Most of the troops
went down with the ship. and those that got off froze
in the water before they were rescued...All those that didn't come back are the true Heroes Mr. Oswalt!
So God Bless all of them that didn't come home and
those that did. and oh yes, may God Bless You also &
help you to understand the other guy's story before
You get in his case!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

angelhelp, Danbury, CT — Fri, 15 Aug 2008 21:10:31 GMT

My Marine, currently stationed in Okinawa, mailed me some sand from Iwo Jima. What a privilege to share some of that sand made holy by the blood of Marines so long ago! Semper fi, Marines! Come home safe! Oohrah!

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Patrick Knoxville, TN. — Sun, 24 Aug 2008 23:23:13 GMT

Thank You.

Iwo Jima flag raiser gets citizenship papers

Christopher Keys, Lewisville, Texas — Wed, 19 Nov 2008 00:45:52 GMT

Mike as well as all Marines on Iwo were amazing. Remember what Nimitz said 'Uncommon valor was a common virtue.' Any vets of WW2 or any other war thank you so much for your service to our country.