‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Sharon, Grant, AL — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 12:50:26 GMT

John's story echoes many survivor's stories in the sense that everyday is a struggle. 9/11 is with with them everyday...I was shocked to turn on the television this morning and find no mention whatsoever about the events of 9/11. Have we forgotten that day and how those events transformed us? Have we closed the book on honoring all those who died that day? I guess we have. I for one will never forget what it did to me.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Michelle Lee, Newport News, VA — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 12:56:25 GMT

Today is a day of remembrance for all Americans who have fallen for our glorious nation whether here at home or away in a foriegn land. I am truly humbled by the courage, the will to continue living (not just existing) and the sheer determination to to show America's enemies that we are united, strong and will protect democracy whenever and wherever it is threatened. Our country has gotten a rude awakening but I am confident that we are now prepared for any future attempts to attack against our homeland.
I am so very proud of the progress that Mr. John Yates had made since the attack at the Pentagon. May God continue to bless you and your family, strengthen you and fill you with peace. God bless America!

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Carol Verra, Surprise, Az. — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 12:56:39 GMT

Great story of survivel and strenght. My hat is off to John for going back to work and not letting the terrist win. Today is a day to remember a very painful time for our country and to say a prayer for all the Americans who died, their families and those like John who survived. I pray it never happens again. God Bless America

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

leftistdestroyer — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 13:34:07 GMT

As an American, I still feel the impact of 911 emotionally. This day, 7 years ago, truley live in imfamy for me. It makes me remember that there is good and evil in the world and that America still has enemies. Most Americans are sorry for what they did to you John, and many, many others. God Bless you all and long live America.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Bill Roppoli, Jessup, MD — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 13:46:38 GMT

I agree. I turned on the radio this morning and heard nothing about what happened 7 years ago, just regular radio talk show personnel going about their daily routines. The only mention of what happened was the voice of the Washington Post explaining what you can find in their paper today. Just one small article about that day. Some people say it's condemned to show images of that day because it doesn't respect those thousands of family members and U.S. citizens who died then or lost their loves ones in it. I say it embraces their names and should never be forgotten.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Becky Peer, Louisville, KY — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 14:06:37 GMT

I think many Americans often forget those who suffered horrible injuries on that day, but survived. Those folks have not only had to try to recover from their physical wounds, but to heal their psychological ones as well. We only seem to talk about the victims who were killed on Sept. 11. I am happy for Mr. Yates and his family that he has recovered his health and can look to the future.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

C Schmidt, Richboro, PA — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 14:06:50 GMT

John, thank you for sharing your story. YOU ARE MY HERO!

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Rick Briarcliff, NY — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 14:29:38 GMT

I think we need to keep this day as a memorial that the USA must remain vigilant in a world filled with terrorism. Since radical Islam seems to be getting stronger, and no Muslim seems to be moving those people to change their way of looking at all "infidels", then we need to watch our backs at ALL TIMES. WE need this remembrance; maybe there are those who don't believe that, but when the next thing gets blown up and destroyed will they volunteer to help or say we weren't prepared???

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Debbie Flynn — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 14:31:13 GMT

John, is such an insptration to many peole who are struggling with the events of 9/11, teh strength he and other survivors have shown goes to show you that our faith in our country will survive!!!! It's time for everyone to take a minute and remember what occured that day, and thank the MANY people who lost their lives in this terrible act of violence, we need to start satnding up and unite as one and never let our country go through this again, we as AMERICANS need to take a stance and do what ever we have to do to keep this from happening again, we need ot prepare more then we are. Since that horrible day I for one have always flown a flag for this country and will contiune to do so until I die, I attend every memorial in our city to pay my respects to the fallen, so please I ask all of you as AMERICANS to say a prayer for our contry, the fallen HEROS and the one s serving this great nation.

" GONE BUT NOT FORGOTTEN "

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Nellian Slowley, Jamaica — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 14:33:13 GMT

I am so happy there is a survivor, it still horrifies me. I am not there but I feel John's pain. Be strong John, no evil is greater than God's power.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Theresa Cook, Johnstown, New York — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 14:35:22 GMT

I know John Yates - a remarkable man, remarkable family. I know what I felt that day - miles away from he, and his wife...the pain I felt as days progressed. The pain of so many families across our country. Tears shed for the feeling of so many emotions. Every American should always remember how deeply moved, and changed, we were that day. For the lives lost, lives saved, heros honored and our basic sense of humanity and patrotism. Our hats should be off everyday ...and our hands over our hearts.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Margaret Parmer — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 14:42:36 GMT

We listened to Imus in the Morning today and his program observed a moment of silence at the time the first airplane hit the first tower. He also had Warner Wolf on today. Warner went on the air with Imus (who was on radio WFAN at the time) and told him what he was seeing from his apartment window which was a few blocks from the WTC. It is a day that will always be remembered by each of us in our own way. I pray for the families of those who died.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

lou pomponio — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 14:42:46 GMT

as a retired cop i am not surprised that america has gone back to baseball applepie and all that crap. maybe when we get hit again it will stop

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Ed Campbell, South Amboy, New Jersey — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 14:46:23 GMT

I went to high school with John. He was a leader even then.He was the type to greet the new kid even when that was not the cool thing to do. John is the type of person we should all look up to. I thank him for serving his country as a soldier and patriot. His heroism should never be forgotten. Thanks for being my friend

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Jill, Wichita, KS — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 14:46:27 GMT

God Bless America.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Linda Nichols — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 14:49:28 GMT

Stories like John's is what makes Americans different. I pray for peace for him and his family. It angers me when I see all of these people waving American flags; which is a symbol of who we are, and feel disgrace with Barack Obama since he will not salute this flag or wear a lapel pin of the American Flag. God Bless America

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Belinda Richnow, Texarkana, TX — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 14:54:56 GMT

I am touched by his marvelous story. All of us adults remember that day well. My 12 year old did a report about 9/11 yesterday to read to the class today. All of the feelings and terror related to that day overwhelmed me as I tried to describe them to my daughter. I hope we can leave them with more than the "facts" of the attack. The children of today need to feel the emotion of the attack as well.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

D, Riffel, Enterprise, KS — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 14:55:57 GMT

We need to remember the events of 0/11/08, and also not forget the unsung heroes of both 9/11/08, but all the others from previos wars (1& 2), whot gave us this great country. God Bless them all and this country, we need God's help for sure.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Nancy Beard, Findlay, Ohio — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 14:57:40 GMT

I know some of the families who had loved ones killed dread this day but what a sad state we would be in if we didn't honor those who paid the ultimate price for the freedom's we take for granted. It would be a worse sin on our part if those same families thought no one cared anymore. It should be a day of remembering fallen heros, those in the Towers, on planes, first responders, and the people who worked tirelessly during the aftermath, those who were so very injuted and are still trying to put their lives back together. GOD HELP US IF WE LOOK ON THIS DAY WITHOUT REMEMBERING THE HORROR, THE EVIL THAT CAME TO OUR SHORES AND THE UNSURMOUNTABLE COURAGE SHOWN BY SO MANY.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Marianne, Burke, VA — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 14:59:58 GMT

I consider myself blessed to be John Yates' colleague, to be able to work with him on a daily basis. John approaches every challenge with the determination to make things better - and that motivates us all. His courage to keep moving forward is truly inspirational!

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Kaley, Travese City, MI — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 15:09:37 GMT

I would like to say that i too am shocked and dissapointed with the lack of reverence shown on this aniversary. Why has it dissapated? why are we not still showing the same amount of respect to the men and women who put their lives on the line that day, as well as those who lost theirs? And the Survivors...it seems that with every year that goes by, there is less and less rememberance shown. i know that i was not directly/indirectly affected by it, but i realize that there were so many that were. I know i still think about that day very often- even though i was only in 8th grade when it happened. i guess that i just want to say "god bless you" to the men and women who lived and died in new york on that day, as well as the many that continue, seven years later, to continue with their pain.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Shannon Fargo, ND — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 15:10:23 GMT

I am profoundly changed by the attacks on 9/11/01. That day changed the way I view the world. I always thought those things would never happen in our country. Then it did.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Wiriamu Guren — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 15:17:39 GMT

This is a blatant crock of s--t! I am more than sure that over half of these comments are manufactured in some way. The building was hit by a missile and there was no evidence whatsoever that a plane hit that building in any way, shape, form, or fashion. You guys are the biggest idiots under the sun. No fuselage or anything. I am not surprised that America is back to eating apple pie and having fun. I am surprised that there are this many stupid people in one country.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Dale Hall Mobile, AL — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 15:35:56 GMT

Does anyone remember listening to the radio of reports of a terrorist attack? I remember thinking to myself that America is under attack and that we should all be afraid for our lives. Then a report of a second attack came over the radio. I knew from the report of the first attack that this was real.

Growing up as a kid my mother got me interested in reading Tom Clancy's novels. In one of the novels a terrorist flys a plane into the capital building. As I was listening to the radio I knew we were under attack. And I was scared. What was going to happen next?

As we head into this election year we should all remember that we are Americans. Shipping jobs overseas firing employees for petty differences, causing grief for others as a result of our own immaturity should stop for the sake of our nation and each other. The fact that your black and I am white means nothing, we are Americans. We are on the verge if not in a depression. We need to put this great nation back to work and help others as best as we can.

This is just one of the reasons I like John McCain. He stood up to the Vietnamese and said "Do what you want; I love my country and my family." I don't think I could have done that....I would have done whatever I could just to come home. My grandfather served thirty-one months in Europe during WWII and I could not have been more proud. He really was part of the greatest generation that grew up without running water, electricity, telephones, A/C, microwaves, and video-games. What will the next fifty years be like in this country?

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Michael Todd, Chicago, IL — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 15:45:36 GMT

I also applaud people like John Yates for enduring the painful recovery from 9/11 as he has. however, I also recognize that this happened 7 years ago, and that everyone grieves and remembers differently. 9/11 was an historic moment in our nation's history, but so was Pearl Harbor. Do you harbor the same resentment for people who don't bring their lives to a halt to remember those killed on December 7th?

9/11's impact will have been way worse than the day of if we are incapable of moving on and letting go, which is different than not caring or forgetting. If the whole country was constantly crippled by the emotional impacts of 9/11 we would have lost even more than we already did.

Much respect to those who survived and continue to recover from their physical and emotional injuries, but the Giuliani-type mandate that we all live our lives as though 9/11 is the only day in our nation's history (or future, for that matter) that has any importance or relevance is counterproductive and will keep us mired in a state of fear that, last I checked, was NOT the American way.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Susan K, Florence, SC — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 15:55:34 GMT

We will never forget. For some, the pain and devastation is still so great perhaps they don't want to revisit it every year. It doesn't mean they don't care or don't fear another attack. I personally will always feel grief over 9/11 but I do not want to continue to see pictures etc. It's too much for me.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

KIMM — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 16:02:33 GMT

FOX NEWS HAD WALL TO WALL CONVERAGE UNINTERRUPTED FROM 6-8 (CENTRAL) THIS AM SO THERE ARE DEFINATLY PPL TALKING ABOUT THE EVENTS OF 9/11 AND REMINDING US ALL THAT WE ARE BLESSED.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

KIMM — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 16:04:33 GMT

FOX NEWS HAD WALL TO WALL CONVERAGE UNINTERRUPTED FROM 6-8 (CENTRAL) THIS AM SO THERE ARE DEFINATLY PPL TALKING ABOUT THE EVENTS OF 9/11 AND REMINDING US ALL THAT WE ARE BLESSED.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Diane Hamilton, NJ — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 16:08:49 GMT

Hoorah for you Michael. If we live in fear, then Radical Islam has won. We must move onward, stop attacking other countries, creating more enemies and mind our own country! Maybe then, we can stop being the hated enemy of 25% of the worlds populace!

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

L. Bauer CleElum Wa — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 16:20:02 GMT

Way to go John, I'm greatfull that you are a survivor and are able to move on with your life. I don't think I will be abel to forget that day, and I'm not sure I want to. We all need to remember. Peace to all...

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Deanna Scott, Tallahassee, FL — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 16:25:09 GMT

Oh my gosh!!! I can't believe the audacity of W.G. What kind of sicko is he. How dare you! Keep your stupid comments to yourself. Crawl back under the "rock" you evidently live under.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Melissa Murawski, South Bend, IN — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 16:40:10 GMT

To the individual who called this story a crock of s--t: What do you mean no proof. People watched the planes crash into the towers and the pentagon. I don't know where you get your info from but we don't appreciate your attacking the comments of others. Your comments make it sound as if it was Mr. Yates's fault for his injuries. Not one person killed...aside from the terrorists who planned, plotted and followed through with these attacks...asked to die on 9/11. I personally am moved every September 11th by the memorials held in my community. WE MUST REMEMBER THIS DAY forever.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

John Anderson, Richmond VA — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 16:45:37 GMT

Why am I not surprised that in this commentary of remembering that terrible day, we would have a demented conspiracy theorist chime in and call us names like idiots? Because you theorists oppose and deride anything that doesn't fit your narrow and warped point of view. Regardless of WHAT hit the Pentagon, plane or missile, whatever your belief, the fact remains that our citizens DIED on that day. People that woke up that day like any other and went to work to provide for themselves and their families. People who were undeserving of the fate that awaited them on that day. THAT is what we should remember. Not get mired in what exactly happened, or who know what and when did they know. We lost good hardworking men and women and innocent children on that day. Remember that and show some respect instead of coming on here, calling names, and acting like a spoiled rotten ill-behaved 2 year old.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Kindra — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 16:55:09 GMT

Thank you for sharing this story. John I can only imagine how hard it has been for you. Just know many people all over the world have been remembering what happened that fateful day. You and your family are in my thoughts and prayers. God Bless You!

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Dee-STL — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 17:10:24 GMT

Hey Wiriamu Guren...Your idiotic comments don't even deserve a response, go back to your cave with your brother Osama. God Bless America!

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Joe.. Manassas, VA — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 17:13:04 GMT

I suppose the message from Guren was entered to get a rise out of the readers. Too bad we see right through him. My wife's childhood friend (Todd) perished aboard this airliner (he wasn't riding a missle).

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

SFC BP, Maine — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 17:21:47 GMT

Yes Wiriamu Guren, the pictures were made up, the plane was a hologram and Santa really does come down your chimney. When you get back to Earth let us know and we will get together and buy you a ticket back to your planet.

On another note: don’t forget to thank a veteran! Only in America can you have this opinion and get away with it. If you were in the country that the terrorist came from you wouldn’t have the freedom to have this opinion.

SFC P.
God Bless

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Simon, Gotham USA — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 17:31:19 GMT

I have an idea. Let's honor the events of 9/11 without bringing politics into it. I'm talking to you, "Linda Nichols." Not a classy move.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Robert M. Corridan, Riverside, Calif. — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 17:47:59 GMT

I said this before and I will say it again...as a Nation we tend to go about our daily lives all too soon after a major tragedy. I told a friend of mine back in 2003 "stay mad and never never forget". These people are animals and they have no regard for the life of anyone who is not of their beliefs and background. Age and gender means absolutely nothing to them.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Joe Reynolds, Palm Coast FL — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 17:48:06 GMT

Regarding Wiriamu Guren's comment, what planet are you from? Or you need to go back on your meds.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Robert G, Atlanta, GA — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 17:55:08 GMT

So many opportunities in the short history of this great nation to honor courageous men & women who have sacrificed much... even to pay the ultimate price! Is any one less important then another? Each person has a name, family, story... but in common all are Americans! How better to honor our heros/heroines but to live our lives to the fulless. To forget is to dishonor... but to move on is living. It's how we live our lives that determines who we are as individuals, and compositely as a nation.

The very core of our existence flows from God Almighty... not from any evil force which desires to destroy us in body, mind, and spirit. That we would return to our First Love, the lover of our souls... then we and our nation would be healed... and how sweet the eternal reunion will be!

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Kathy Bell - Fort Worth, Texas — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 18:02:20 GMT

John, I am so happy to see you improve daily. I was with you everyday that you went through all the medical procedures, you see at the time of the 9/11 attacks, I was in the U.S. Army, stationed at Walter Reed Army Medical Center. I was tasked to find out the names of all of the Pentagon victims and follow them from the lawn clear throughout their care. I did just that, and I think that you were the last person to be discharged from the area hospitals, mid November or December timeframe. I thank God everyday for my children and for the life that we have in America. I think of you and the other victims of the Pentagon almost everyday and I say a prayer for all of you. I have often wondered how you were doing, I am glad to see that you are healing over time. Remember - that you and the others at the Pentagon will NEVER be forgotten. God Bless you and America!

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

susan huy — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 18:04:36 GMT

Get over it folks...terrorism is not an American tagedy..nor is John and American hero. There have been many survivors of terrorism the world over..in Belfast, in Bali, in London, Madrid. Almost no country has been left out of terrorism of one kind or another (an no folks, it is not all Mulim terrorism...rmember the Irish Republican Army? the ETA??) Util you stop acting like you "owned" the grief, you can never truly combat terrorism. My thoughts are today with victims of violnce all over the world, and with the brave survivors of terrorism, wherever they may be in the world!

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Melissa UT — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 18:07:48 GMT

To the STUPID idiot Wiriamu Guren, there was evidence of a plane, they found landing gear among other things. Last time I checked missiles didn't come with landing gear. Obviously you belong to the same mentalitiy of people who don't believe that Aushwitz existed either. Grow up and pull your head out of the sand.

As far as people forgetting what happened, the ones that will forget are the ones who really don't care about much else except themselves. We don't do a memorial service every year on Dec. 7 for Pearl Harbor, but that doesn't mean that people forget about it. I don't think we need to keep ripping the bandaid off every year. There are ways of memorializing it without rehashing it every year.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Corbi Bahel Dover, DE — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 18:17:05 GMT

Wiriamu Guren and his comments are ridiculous! How could MSNBC allow this comment to be printed? Today is not the day to allow an idiot to air his opinion about what he feels did or didn't happen. I know my dad was almost killed that day, 7 years ago and how he has struggled emotionally and physically since then. He is to be celebrated for his bravery and strength. I love you Dad!!

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Della, Key West, FL — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 18:17:59 GMT

On MSNBC they reran their TV coverage starting with the Today Show coverage of the first plane going into the tower and continued running the footage until noon. It was powerful to see it all over again. To see it play out knowing what we know now, but seeing Tom Brokaw, Katie Couric and Matt Lawer work through what was going on until the pieces started to come together, then the realization of the enormity of what had happen. Listening to Bush say how we'll get who caused this (and now seven years later, Bin Ladin is still alive, well, free and we, the US, are in a no-end war, economically struggling, etc., etc.). I'm glad MSNBC ran that footage. We should never forget that horrible morning.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

elizabeth brooks laguna hills ca — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 18:20:06 GMT

I am still surprised this has not been designated as a Day of Rememberance, but then some stores would turn it into another reason to promote a sale. So there probably is no reason to make it official, yet as an American I will never forget. I too was shocked that there was so little mentioned on the morning TV shows, especially because most of them air from New York. Regis and Kelly, the Today Show etc. maybe they should have spent the time interviewing those survivors or rescuers who felt they had something to say.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Lunchbox — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 18:28:22 GMT

To Wiriamu Guren;

You sir are a moron. Anyone who believes that conspiracy theory B.S. should just be labeled as too dumb to live and left in the desert to fend for themselves. I have been wounded in the war resulting from this attack, and have watched friends get blown away in front of me. This kind of idiotic rhetoric has no place in intelligent conversation. Please go back to lining your house with aluminum foil, and leave the rest of us to our rememberances.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Marie York,Pa — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 18:39:32 GMT

John:thanks for sharing your story, it reminds me to pray for survivors still struggling with recovery as well as for the families of those who died;I will not forget Sept 11th, we do not need to be emotional wrecks but we need to remember what happened ;I did not live during WWII but still remember their courage on Pearl Harbor rememberance day.
this message is for Wiriamu Guren: Conspiracy theorists making this claim ignore several facts:

The remains of the bodies of the crew and passengers of American Airlines flight 77 were found at the Pentagon crash site, and positively identified by DNA.
The flight’s black box was also recovered at the site.
Numerous eyewitnesses saw the plane strike the Pentagon. Some saw passengers through the plane’s windows. Missiles don’t have windows or carry passengers.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Marie York,Pa — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 18:45:49 GMT

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Jamie, Chicago — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 18:54:08 GMT

What a great testament this man is to the power of fighting back! It would have been so much easier for him and all the others to sit back, feel sorry for themselves, and not deal with the pain. The fact that these people can stand up and move forward gives me hope. The images of that day are forever engrained in my mind, but as I sat glued to my tv looking for hope that day, I realized this is it...the way we fight back is by moving on. This day should always be remembered and honored, but I think the best way to honor those who lost their lives is to get up and live our lives. The terrorists wanted to instill fear in American hearts, but we have faced that fear and conquered it through men like this. My deepest appreciation goes to the survivors, the families, and the soldiers, all of whom fight every day to keep that hope alive.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

WYONNA BELL, HEMET,CA — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 18:58:38 GMT

LET US NOT EVER TO FOR GET 9/11, A LOT OF GOOD PEOPLE DID FULL THAT DAY. JOHN HAD A LONG HARD FIGHT BACK, BUT HE MADE IT, GOOD FOR YOU JOHN YATES. MAY GOD ALWAYS BE WITH YOU AND YOUR. GOD BLESS AMERICA

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Roxie Baber, Buena Vista Colo. — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 19:13:09 GMT

God Bless John Yates and all the survivors and victims of that day. They were put on the front line of a war they had no idea was about to happen and they are all heroes. I think we need to remember and honor them each year - a few minutes out of our busy schedules is not too much to ask for the many who paid the ultimate price and the many who continue to bear the scars of their injuries and their grief at their losses.

Many years ago I was a 1st responder and my grief at seeing so many of those dedicated to saving others lose their lives has lessened over the years, but will never go away entirely. I, for one, will always keep the memory of their sacrifice in my heart, whether or not there are any memorials, ceremonies or notice paid to the day.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

c.j., salem va — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 19:21:33 GMT

John thank you for yur story. My heart goes out to all the family's that lost loved ones but also to the survivors. I wish there were more. There is so much anger in the world. where is peace we all need? Such innocent people killed for nothing. The devil is alive and well in the world.Pray for God to pprotect us and our children. We will grow old and die but our babies will be left in the place with evil people. I wondered what we ever did to deserve this treatment from people we have never met. It is so sad and scarey.We teach our children to love everyone but the terrorist are teachng their children to hate . They never know love just hate. Lord help them.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

M. Young, Phoenix AZ — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 19:23:12 GMT

I read here where many of you say there was no mention or very little mention of 9/11. Here in Phoenix AZ it was the first thing I heard when I turned on the TV news this morning and the radio at work. I guess it just depends on where you live on the coverage it gets. We will never forget, God Bless America

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Lauren Malone, Largo, FL — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 20:11:58 GMT

Thank you John for sharing your story. I thank all of you who felt strongly enough to share your private thoughts about 9-11. I have struggled with the events of 9-11-01 and I was surprised that I had to dig around my TV channels this morning to find coverage of the memorial services at Ground 0 and in DC.
I used my last day of vacation today to honor and remember the people and events of 9-11. I hope that so long as there is a living individual with a memory of 9-11 that we support that person and take a moment to remember the day the great American bubble burst. I no longer have a strong sense of security. Oh sure I could go broke and become homeless but at least there had not been a war on American soil with close to 3,000 innocent hard working people gone in one morning.
I'm from NY state and after living in the south for 30 years I just happened to be working in NYC the week of 9-11. My younger sister was at her job between me and the Trade Towers. I was working in a Federal building so we were evacuated to the already crowded streets of the city. I knew my sister could see the Towers from her office window but I wasn't certain just how close she was. So I was one of hundreds of thousands of Americans wondering if someone they loved was safe. I was in my third year of surviving breast cancer and feeling fragile from that fight.
On 9-11 my sister was able to get the last train heading north out of Grand Central Station. I was on the street for a long time that day so I have relied on watching reruns of the attacks in order to recreate the day I feel America changed forever. Last year after thinking I was able to get on with life as many folks like to assume we all should do, I experienced a meltdown. I was depressed, angry, sad and again scared. I'll always be proud to be an American but I will never take security for granted and I will always remember. Thanks for all your thoughts even the off the wall ones. This is America and we do have freedom of speech. God bless.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Randy — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 20:25:39 GMT

On this terrible day back in 2001, it's nice to see a man like him come back to life. God Bless him and the others!

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Rory OBrien, Manhattan Beach, CA — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 20:37:13 GMT

One way to ensure we never forget those who gave their lives is to start petitions to acknowledge this day. Currently there is a petition available to sign for the suggested National Firefighter's Day - http://www.petitiononline.com/91101/petition.html

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Karen, Douglas, GA — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 20:41:49 GMT

I will always remember 9/11 and the victims and everyone involved in that will be in my prayers. Remember God knows your needs.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Linda, Minneapolis, MN — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 21:11:44 GMT

Thank you John,
Your story is very inspiring.
I wish you all the best as you recover from your injuries you received that day.
You are a hero to me, Just as my F-I-L was during WW2.
God bless you and your family and God Bless America!!!

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Susan, Mesa, Az — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 21:48:55 GMT

Ditto to Deanna, John, Melissa & Lunchbox regarding your comments on WG letter-----I agree wholeheartedly with each of you---truly moved by your story Mr Yates----God Bless You !!!!!!!! You are an inspiration to us all.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

C. Gacioch RN, RHIA, Pinebluff, NC — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 22:01:10 GMT

Thank you John and all those others who were injured and burned on that horrible day. You are truly a hero in my eyes and in many others eyes. It is wonderful to see how much progress you have made. We have no idea what pain you have suffered for us and I am truly grateful you are doing so well. We must take care of those injured and elevate them to sainthood as you and many others are what makes us proud to be American. May God continue to bless you and keep you strong and never let us forget about you struggles. Keep on doing what you need to do and know that I have been praying for all of you even though I don't know all the names. I lived in New York when this all happened. I think any New Yorker knows how we all felt that day. I really don't think any other state knows how it affected us. I am sure those in Pa and in DC. felt thr same. We will never forget it.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

JerseyFran, Cherry Hill, NJ — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 22:32:05 GMT

As an American, I am proud of all the good that this country was built on and for which we continue to strive. My heartfelt prayers go out to all of the families friends co-workers who lost people on the infamous day 9/11/2001. "When will we ever learn?"

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Michael , Rockalnd,maine — Thu, 11 Sep 2008 23:23:17 GMT

Saddly i belive that is the election that this isn't getting the full coverage that it deserves. I know thats not a good reason tho. This was a devistateing attack aginst each and every amercian both child and adult. But I don't belive that people should get so upset because its not plastered all over the news. Each and every town do better hommage to the attacks on there own then the media could do. My home town has allowed several off duity emergency responce members to sit outside the station and meet with young and old and hear there thanks and praises for their work and that of there brothers who lost there lives. To me that is more knowing that its happening accross the U.S then a Media event. That shows that We the people, still care and remember.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Johannes Orange, CA — Fri, 12 Sep 2008 00:12:27 GMT

I attended a memorial ceremony today in the City of Santa Ana held by the Orange County Fire District and City of Santa Ana's Fire Department and it was an honor. I was supprised not to see any houses with flags this morning nor cars and trucks like 2001 when the 9/11 event occured. America has not forgotten, we have just toned it down to memorials such as the 12/7 ceremoney like one writer mentioned. I did remember when there was so much talk and pictures showing how the damage to the Pentigon looked as though it had been hit by something other then a plane. Even video footage taken from a camera near the Pentigon. W.G must have also seen the same program and is convinced our country possibly played some part in covering up some facts. But needless to say, W.G went over the top. Many people died as a result of 9/11 and thats what honoring these people on the anniversary is all about. John, I pray that your wounds will heel completely one day both physically and emotionally,.. until then may God continue to bless you and your family. Flight 93 I salute all of you for taking out those how would have done even more damage, you were all heros !!!!

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Mike Arienti, Fairfax Station, VA — Fri, 12 Sep 2008 00:17:07 GMT

I was working just miles away, in Olde Towne Alexandria, VA that morning. Seeing what I believe was flight 77 go by my window with the landing gear still up is one memory I'll go to my grave with.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Angela, Austin,Texas — Fri, 12 Sep 2008 00:47:19 GMT

Kudos to his wife, Ellen. She truly mirrors the character that John exhibits. It takes a strong love between two individuals to deal with what has been handed to them. They both have shown a great deal of grace. Instead of taking something as horrible as the attack and the resulting injuries and using it for a pity party; they have taken the opportunity to turn life around and make goals out of simple gestures the rest of us take for granted. You are an inspiration John and Ellen and you truly are an example of the undying American spirit.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

BROOKE,WEWAHITCHKA,FLORIDA — Fri, 12 Sep 2008 00:56:46 GMT

thank you john you are my families HERO!! WE LOVE YOU!!!

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

brenda myers, belding, mi — Fri, 12 Sep 2008 01:05:54 GMT

I am very insignificant but believe in the American dream, pursuit of happiness and live for God. We have all forgotton why we are here, some people do not have the opportunity to have their own thoughts or speak their mind, they sure can here. I must say John I hope you continue to heal and love of God will keep you at peace. We all have our opinions and none should make us to where we want to hurt another. If you are miserable seek the Lord. I love my country but not above my God, he does and always will come first. John, there was a reason for you to still be here and I am sure you want to know why, someday we all will know why. Don't let the negativity of someone else make you feel bad or ashamed because there was a point every single person around the world felt anguish at this day of ignorance for a few. I will never forget, no one else should either.
Thank you, God Bless America and our leader.!!!

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

DD — Fri, 12 Sep 2008 02:14:57 GMT

What an inspiration!! Best wishes and God Bless you on your journey of recovery!

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

John Brown — Fri, 12 Sep 2008 04:33:00 GMT

I find it funny how more than a couple of you have said that 'the united states' is 'good' and 'the terrorists' are 'evil'. It might feel nice to think of a group that you think your part of as being the good guys, and its nice to think that the people you're killing are the bad guys. The 9/11 attacks were evil, but what conditions have produced this large group of often unassociated peoples you uniformely label 'terrorists?' What has made them choose to be, in your eyes, 'evil?', and are we going to change the conditions that make them choose that path through war? True patriots should be brave enough to not just cheer for their country, but take a stand when it has a problem. Our foreign policy is really messed up if you look into it at all. The best way to fight terror is to stop sponsoring it. Israels treatment of palestine is, in the words of Jimmy Carter, apartheid. They are freakin nazis and we treat them like their our little sister that we have to protect and sell jet bombers to.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

JRS California — Fri, 12 Sep 2008 05:04:02 GMT

Never ever ever forget. Since that day I read the news with a different posture. I am asking myself "Is this the day when I will need to take action to defend my country?" There are many cynical haters in this world. Some hate in the name of religion. They look down their noses at the west with envy and anger. They ask themselves "Why has Allah given the west the blessing that we were promised?" They reason within themselves "He must have given it to these gullible ones so that we can have the glory of taking it away." They fail to realize that the trustful and law abiding citizens that appear to be naive in their goodwill, are the backbone of the prosperity which they can never truly obtain or produce within their oppressive anarchist culture. God Bless America and God bless the meek for they shall inherit the earth.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Edward, Sun Valley, NV — Fri, 12 Sep 2008 05:04:30 GMT

Does anyone have any pictures of the plane that hit the pentagon?

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Luke Wylie, Redmond, WA — Fri, 12 Sep 2008 07:08:27 GMT

Im only seventeen, yet i still remember September 11th just like everyone else. I remember what i was doing, where i was at, how i felt. And now i sit here thinking, what will my children think of when i talk about 9-11? Will they only remember it as an attack on American soil by terrorists that led to a war, or something more? Something we remember it as? A day when we didnt speak... just watched. Watched the towers burning. Watched the people jump to their deaths. Thats how were going to remember it... As the day when America stood still.

God Bless America

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Ruby Smyth, Vancouver, Canada — Fri, 12 Sep 2008 12:50:22 GMT

Thank you, journalist John Rutherford, for a very human and humane portrayal of John Yates. You clearly got close enough to Mr. Yates to hear the truth of what it's like to live with injuries like that, to struggle for years and possibly a lifetime, in an attempt to regain one's identity and sense of security. Many news pieces just give you a flash of the story, a nice quote about survival, and leave you with the impression that everything is ok or doomed. But by the way you wrote John Yates story, we can all learn about the life in between - the daily commitment to improvement, the struggles with depression and self-doubt, and the importance of support from family and community to help the afflicted get back to work and regain a sense of hope for the future. It is in the real John Yates that we find our hero. Thanks for sharing him with us.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

IloveAMERICA — Fri, 12 Sep 2008 13:40:54 GMT

I did not know that the state hospital allowed patients internet access, but see never assume anything, as Wiriamu Guren proved that patients can and do use the internet, we need to send someone a memo on that, and God Bless America, and all those devastated by 911.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

D. R. Armstrong, Dixon, California — Fri, 12 Sep 2008 14:36:18 GMT

Hello John Yates,

Thank you for sharing your continuing story of survival, determination, recovery and healing. For me, your story embodies the limitless scope of human potential, while you are an inspiration as a fellow American to boot.
Life goes on after 9/11, to be sure, and your shared experience can help so many others out there in similar situations, or those just wondering what it's all about. It would be an honor to shake hands with you, but in a real way it feels like you've already extended yours in greeting, through your story. I can sense your grip on life, and it is most inspiring!
God Bless,
Dave A., Dixon, CA

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Cory Baron, NY — Fri, 12 Sep 2008 15:21:57 GMT

Not bring politics into this? But fifty years of increasing American appeasement in the Mideast have led to fifty years of increasing contempt in the Muslim world for the U.S. The climax was September 11, 2001. American appeasement is run by American leadership that is run by American politics. To ignore politics is to ignore and evade what the cause is of these emboldened terrorist attacks.

What happened in New York was not a criminal act. It was an act of war. It is wrong to call it criminal activity, or to treat it as a criminal matter. It is wrong to consider it as a matter in which the people responsible must be arrested, brought before a judge and tried. This is war (what else do you call foreign sponsored attack on the US military headquarters?). The attackers must be destroyed. This is a war against America, her core values, and the prosperity that has followed from our pursuit of those values. The enemy is first and foremost any government who supports the active opponents of those values. This is the material fact that we must face.

Instead of wallowing in self pity, call the enemy for what he is and identify him correctly (states that sponsor terrorism). Instead of blurting out truly empty religious catch phrases of "God bless America" and realize that militant Islamic terrorist also shout out that they are being blessed by God as well.

If I would identify an act that people and our leaders do that undercuts a proper retaliatory reaction to these attacks is calling the people who lost their lives in 9/11 HEROES, this misidentifies what they truly are: VICTIMS of an act of war.

Remember what Bush said in his last State of the Union address “We exercise power without conquest, and we sacrifice for the liberty of strangers. “ Yes, we will continue to sacrifice our solders on an alter to give liberties to militant Islamic people who will vote themselves back into a theocratic dictatorship. However, I want and pay (with taxes) our solders to defend our country by making our enemies (militant Islam) die for their cause. But he didn’t say that, did he. Instead we sacrifice our wealth and our solders lives to rebuild nations and bring them democracy. US forces should bring them the opposite that they correctly deserve for a war we did not start: rubble and destruction. This is the correct way to honor the victims of 9/11.

The US military certainly has the power but what is stopping them: politics and the bad ideas that are currently supporting them.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

M. R. Chase — Fri, 12 Sep 2008 15:37:13 GMT

I do not think the day is so much forgotten as it is feared. We do not like being reminded of our true vulnerability. That is why those of us who do remember it, every day and often in our nightmares, must remind those who hide from it. I, too, deal with PTSD from that horrible time. I spent the first nine days at Ground Zero, hoping to find life. It is a memory I would wish on no one. I am finaly recovering but I refuse to forget. We are a strong nation but it requires vigilance and preparedness to remain so.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

M.R.Chase — Fri, 12 Sep 2008 15:43:39 GMT

And Lunchbox, I could not have said it better myself. I listen to the conspiracy garbage all the time. Here it is people: I was THERE, I SAW how those towers fell, and I know what caused it. LARGE FLYING MACHINES DID IT! I was there because I hold a degree that includes a big backround in engineering. When a building collapses because its' central supports are basicaly demolished and melted from within it bares a resembalance to implosion. This was not a prearranged detonation, it was a tradegy orchestrated by evil, single minded men.
And Lunchbox, one soldier to another, glad you made it home.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Maureen Martini, Memphis Tn. — Fri, 12 Sep 2008 18:45:13 GMT

I also remember watching with my husband who was dying at the time of Lung CA. Knowing I was losing him my heart broke for all who lost a loved one that day...then on 11/11/2001 he joined them all in heaven.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Denise Lombardo Detroit Michigan — Sat, 13 Sep 2008 00:31:57 GMT

It has taken me 7 years to come to grips with what happened on September 11th. The CEO of our company was on the plane that crashed into the Pentagon. For months afterward, my coworkers and I were raw with grief. He was a wonderful man, boss, friend, husband, father of two, a good son,and was filled with faith for God. He will always be remembered. Thank you John, for sharing your story. You are incredibly brave and an example to all of us. God bless you, everyone who is reading this, and God Bless America! Usually on September 10th, I go to bed and pray it will be September 12th when I wake up. I stay away from any media (radio, newspaper, or TV). Reading your article did help. Thank you.

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Steve Graham, USMC — Sat, 13 Sep 2008 01:50:44 GMT

How Many of You Remember the Oct 23rd, The Beirut Bombing? Will the Media remember or is it not "Press Worthy"?

I will never Forget my Fallen Brothers, so said that we didn't learn from it.

Veterans/Family Groups Remember Fallen Heroes 25 Years Later

Beirut Remembrance Will Be Held Oct. 23, 2008 in Jacksonville, N.C.

Families and fellow service members will honor fallen heroes who were killed 25 years ago on October 23, 1983 in Beirut, Lebanon. On that day, a terrorist truck bomb exploded in a barracks, killing 220 Marines, 18 sailors and 3 soldiers and injuring many
others.

Thousands will attend the 25th Remembrance October 23, 2008 near Camp Lejeune, in Jacksonville, N.C., home of the Beirut Memorial.

The memorial includes a wall with the names of American service men killed during the multinational “peacekeeping” mission in Beirut, Lebanon from 1982-84 and during the Grenada humanitarian rescue mission in October 1983. In all, 273 gave their lives in the name of freedom and peace there between 1982-84 and many others were injured, some permanently.

The city of Jacksonville, N.C. and Marine Corps Base Camp Lejeune have facilitated the Remembrance each year since 1984.

The Remembrance also honors the service of those who participated 50 years ago during a similar 1958 Beirut operation.

At the time of the 1983 bombing, it was the most serious terrorist act against Americans ever experienced, and a precursor of what was to come. Parallels have been drawn between it and the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks in New York, Washington D.C. and Pennsylvania. Some of the same terrorists were involved in both.

The 1,000-member Beirut Veterans of America is a veteran’s group formed in 1992 to ensure that the service men killed in Beirut are always remembered. The Beirut Connection is a group of families who joined together soon after the bombing to mourn their deceased men in Beirut and have stayed together since.

The 25th Remembrance will feature a candlelight vigil at the Memorial at 6 a.m. on October 23rd, where all the names on the wall will be read aloud.

“Reading their names aloud ensures that these men are remembered for their courage and their sacrifice,” says Bob Jordan, a retired Marine Corps major and the founding president of the BVA. This sentiment echoes the BVA motto, “The First Duty is to Remember.” “For just that brief moment, they walk again among us,” said Jordan.

Those interested in more information or photos about the U.S. in Beirut can go to the official BVA website at www.beirutveterans.org.
-

‘Ups and downs’ for Pentagon attack survivor

Diane Brisbane Queensland Australia — Mon, 15 Sep 2008 12:24:07 GMT

I am an Australian and I will say that on 9/11/08 we did have some old fottage of that day 7 years earlier shown on our screens which still brings tears to my eyes. I still pray for the families of the victims as well as those who survived. I will never forget that date and will always show respect and rememberance on the anniversaries of that fateful day