Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Tyler, Winona, MN — Fri, 01 May 2009 18:16:46 GMT

Vandalism sucks. I've never seen that tree the only thing I have to really say about it is that if it was out alongside the highway away from everyone and someone cut it down thats crappy. But if that tree was within a mile of someones home they probably had good reason.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Suzanne Magnuson, Los Angeles, California — Fri, 01 May 2009 18:21:42 GMT

Why don't they plant another tree!

(former Two Harbors resident)

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

myla, nampa, idaho — Fri, 01 May 2009 18:28:37 GMT

How sad. Why is that there are always a few people out there bent on destroying what's most beautiful in life? They may think it's only a tree, but those of us with higher intelligence know better. Here's to you, little honk tree.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Areal Person, Sinclair, WY — Fri, 01 May 2009 18:42:53 GMT

Some people have no respect for life of any kind. I'm sorry to hear of your loss.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Dean, Oregon — Fri, 01 May 2009 18:48:44 GMT

You hit the nail on the head, Myla: whoever cut this tree down had little intelligence. That is obvious since this was the only entertainment they could find. But Karma has a way of coming around and you can rest assured it will cut them down as well.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Alan Jacobs Green Bay WI — Fri, 01 May 2009 18:55:27 GMT

OH NO !!! I am North Shore diaspora too. This is worse than the closing of a Sears Store. Although we were Minneapolitians, I spent 5 months of every year on the Gunflint. The honking tree was the Arc de Triomphe of Hy 61...the triumph of fishing lilly pad bays over I94 congestion. What a loss.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Anthony W, Renton, WA — Fri, 01 May 2009 19:08:19 GMT

So now you have a "honk stump". Keep honking or the vandals win! ;)

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

BruceInNH — Fri, 01 May 2009 19:09:35 GMT

I'm from NH and this kind of reminds me of the morning after the Old Man of the Mountain fell. So sad, so unnecessary, so hurtful. You all have my sympathies.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Steve, Boston, MA — Fri, 01 May 2009 19:12:09 GMT

If you believe in karma, the creeps that did this will get repaid. Unfortunately, the problem with karma is that they probably won't know why something bad has happened to them, so they will most likely whine about how unfair life is to them. For one, I hope karma catches up with them quickly. Perhaps a tree could fall on them.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Jimmy Crackhorns — Fri, 01 May 2009 19:14:30 GMT

Probably some kids out partying and to them it was a hilarious good time. Unfortunately sobriety brings bewilderment and hopefully some shame and a guilty conscious. The tree can and should be replaced....it is these little things that give us memories of where, who, and what we are. I am sure the prankster will eventually end up being found out.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Jonathan, Nashville, TN — Fri, 01 May 2009 19:15:41 GMT

That sucks...that sounds like a really cool little tradition. Someone should plant another little tree in the middle of the night...OR put up a little 'in memoriam' at the site and keep that tradition alive.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Mel Cowger, Webster Springs, WV — Fri, 01 May 2009 19:17:31 GMT

I feel for you. Something similar happened here where I live. Some vandals BURNED our sycamore tree. It was the worlds largest sycamore. Now the bridge over to it is blocked. The local government is afraid it will fall and injure someone. It is in a sad shape now. I feel for you and your community on your loss.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

izzy,winnipeg,manitoba,canada — Fri, 01 May 2009 19:20:07 GMT

So sad!We have a honk tree here also!!I wonder how common this is??

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Happy Hawaiian Hilo. Hawaii — Fri, 01 May 2009 19:24:52 GMT

Very sad.....idiots with nothing else better to do!! Please plant another one. It would be a great tribute and the tradition and legacy would live on.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Theresa, Minneapolis, MN — Fri, 01 May 2009 19:26:04 GMT

There are other, younger trees in the median now...but for those who have driven past it hundreds of times, it connected to many childhood memories. When I was a child, sometimes my dad would pull over and we would yell out 'Hi Tree.' Silly, but those are the things I remember from being young.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Maryann — Fri, 01 May 2009 19:27:02 GMT

that SUX's that someone would cutt down that tree, what respect do they have and WHY did they cutt it down just to be mean.....someone said plant a new one but its not the same I understand cause we had a tree like that between where I live and a town like 100 miles away to bad it died and I know it was said they had put a sign on it saying national forest, it was cool. but I am sad for your little community......and who ever did it sux's

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Deb — Fri, 01 May 2009 19:35:28 GMT

I'm so sorry you lost your honk tree. I hope the vandals suffer horrible guilt every time they pass that way for the rest of their lives.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Betty, Austin, TX — Fri, 01 May 2009 19:39:56 GMT

Kinda like the vandals that poisoned the Liberty Oak here in Austin, TX. JERKS!!!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

acg.chicago — Fri, 01 May 2009 19:41:09 GMT

Idiot, yes, but has anyone checked with the Highway Department to see whether said idiot was employed by local government, and decided that it was too close to the road?

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Brett, Madison, WI — Fri, 01 May 2009 19:45:53 GMT

Wonder if there is a new House near by and the owners were getting sick of the honking?

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Wolf, SLC, Utah — Fri, 01 May 2009 19:46:50 GMT

So... When's the party to plant the NEW honking tree?

(Seriously. It's a big deal. A group of people in the area should get together to plant a new tree next to the old location. Then stick a big CEMENT plaque there with it and the stump!)

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Jean — Fri, 01 May 2009 19:47:56 GMT

I live in PA, but feel for you! I'd just have to plant a whole bunch of new trees........so sorry!!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Suzie Hunter, Weedsport, NY — Fri, 01 May 2009 19:55:10 GMT

Deepest sympathies. We had "three sisters" on a stretch of the NYS thruway halfway between exits 39 and 40. They were a daily comfort coming and going to work. They were lovely with their snow-white "skirts" in the winter and wild madras coverings in the fall. Only two remain. I still miss the old girl they had to take down. I'm quite convinced the remaining trees feel the same way.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Craig Ueltzen, Pasco Washington — Fri, 01 May 2009 19:55:20 GMT

Here’s a similar story with a semi-happy ending.

On highway 395, in eastern Washington, between The Tri-Cities and Riztville, there’s a small town called Connell. Just south of the town was a single Juniper tree in the otherwise treeless sagebrush steppe desert land. The tree wasn’t in the median, but about 100 yards off the freeway. Someone planted a sign next to the freeway that read CONNELL NATIONAL FOREST. It was a local joke for many years.

Several years went by, and just like the Honking Tree, some idiot chopped the Juniper down. So, how did that act of vandalism turn into a semi-happy ending you ask? The US Fish and Wildlife Service got involved when it was discovered a protected owl had a nest in the Juniper. The nest was destroyed and the chick within it was found dead, so a full investigation was launched.

They caught the moron after a few months, and now he’s serving serious time in a federal prison because of the owl nest. If not for the owl nest, it’s doubtful anything would’ve happened to the dimwit for his act of stupidity.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

tootsi roll, jonesboro, ar — Fri, 01 May 2009 19:57:14 GMT

We had an elbow tree in college by the running trail around our town's lake. I won't tell you what we did by it, but it was a cool tradition we had a lot of fun. Whenever you saw the looming elbow tree, you knew you were halfway around the lake and could take a little "brake". I will show it to my kids one day (we won't be keeping the tradition alive though!)

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Kathleen, Duluth, MN — Fri, 01 May 2009 19:58:26 GMT

I've lived in this area most of my life and well, the Honk Tree to me was as significant as the Witch Tree in Grand Portage. There was just something special about that tree. We can't replace "that tree", but we could sure plant a new one in it's memory!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

mrob — Fri, 01 May 2009 19:59:54 GMT

First the economy, then the Swine Flu, now the honk tree... how bad can it get?!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Matthew, originally from Grand Marais MN — Fri, 01 May 2009 20:02:01 GMT

This is terrible. My family always honked at the honking tree, from my earliest memory when we would drive to Duluth. Whenever I drove up with my kids from the cities to visit my mom and dad, we would honk too. A happy part of my childhood just died with that tree. To those who said "just plant another tree", you simply don't understand that it wouldn't be same.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Kelly, Wausau, WI — Fri, 01 May 2009 20:06:52 GMT

Honk Honk Love you little tree!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Don Dahlberg, Ellensburg WA — Fri, 01 May 2009 20:07:39 GMT

Hope the vandels are caught, chained to the stump and given a public beat down !
Then maybe just maybe,a little lesson of respect might be taught.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Don Dahlberg, Ellensburg WA — Fri, 01 May 2009 20:09:24 GMT

Hope the vandels are caught, chained to the stump and given a public beat down !
Then maybe just maybe,a little lesson of respect might be taught.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Michael, St Paul, MN — Fri, 01 May 2009 20:10:20 GMT

Its part of the bully mentality in our society, starting in our schools but extending into the corporate world as well. Ignoring the rules, twisting on the little guy, not for any good reason, but just because they can.
These people are making up for something they lack, being brutal to try and make some imprint on life, because they have always been able to do so.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

R Mallory, Los Angeles, CA — Fri, 01 May 2009 20:12:56 GMT

Did it ever occur to any of you honkers that perhaps someone lived close by and the incessant honking was driving them crazy?
Maybe you could have enjoyed the tree without blasting an annoying car horn. That sound always spoils nature.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

ligeia, west monroe, la. — Fri, 01 May 2009 20:14:22 GMT

What goes around, comes around; these idiots will have miserable lives, (obviously, already do, if this is their entertainment), and they will, stupidly, always wonder why they are so unsuccessful...fools.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Patricia Cincinnati, Ohio — Fri, 01 May 2009 20:18:45 GMT

I am so sorry for your communities loss. It frustrates me when someone feels the need to be distructive and unkind to something that meant so much to so many people.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Ron Melvin, Orlando, Florida — Fri, 01 May 2009 20:19:44 GMT

Strange how one tree brings to mind the millions of trees disappearing from our planet...many for paper on which we receive mail-box packing junk. Others for growing illegal drugs. Some for the NY Times. I say plant another tree on that spot. Hopefully, by the time it is a few feet tall the NY Times will be gone.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Mike, Saint Paul, MN — Fri, 01 May 2009 20:24:40 GMT

I grew up in Silver Bay and Two Harbors and remember honking the horn every time we passed that tree. Sucks that now it is gone. To those who did this, you are Jerks, plain and simple.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Mike Shields, Whittier, Ca — Fri, 01 May 2009 20:38:31 GMT

How very sad---both that some jerk cut down a harmless tree, and that you and others have turned the departed tree into some kind of spiritual being. Get a life. Spend your honking time helping someone.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Bridget Burkel, Eden Prairie, MN — Fri, 01 May 2009 20:39:53 GMT

The folklore behind this tree is that you have to honk at it on your way up north to have good luck on your journey, and on your way home to ensure a safe return. I've honked at this tree for year. And every time I went up to Gooseberry or Lutsen at friends, I made them do the same. Many Wuda Woochers at UMD are going to be quite upset about this.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

gcheshier — Fri, 01 May 2009 20:46:00 GMT

Are you sure that someone didnt run into it and get hurt or die...it was very close to the roadway...it may have been removed if it were damaged. Maybe it was sick? cut down by vandals seems to be a stretch

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Larry, Mt Holly, NJ — Fri, 01 May 2009 20:46:55 GMT

I disagree. That tree was unsafe being so close to the side of a highway. There should never be trees that close to the edge of a highway with no guard rail or anything preventing a car from hitting it. Maybe someone felt the same and was tired of seeing such an unsafe situation and took matters into their own hands.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Linda, Hollywood, CA — Fri, 01 May 2009 20:48:09 GMT

What a shame! As a person often subjected to noise pollution (middle of the night thumping car stereos cruising the Sunset Strip), I wonder if it was someone who lived really close to the tree? No excuse of course, but perhaps some reason to it.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Jim,Hutchison,Ks — Fri, 01 May 2009 20:51:12 GMT

It's pretty common Izzy,we have a large cottonwood here in the middle of Kansas between Hutchinson and Wichita. Vandals tick me off also.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

D. Bass — Fri, 01 May 2009 20:52:13 GMT

I get angry when I read things like the cutting down of the Honk Tree. Some folks are determined to kill all that is beautiful in our lives. I live in Montclair, N.J. On a day off the other day, while I was walking around town, I saw this guy ripping up the
tulips in planters downtow. At first I thought he was
weeding or something. Then I realized, after checking him out carefully, that he was just a malicious prankster-idiot. I was abou to say something to him when he looked right at me. I'm pretty big, but the look in this guy's eyes seem to indicate that he was just plain nuts. I told a cop up the street what was going on and he just shrugged and said O.K., even after I described the guy, what he was wearing and the direction he walked away once he realized more than one person had seen what he was doing. I really find this sort of thing maddening. Aggresive lunatics
need to be locked up or forced to take medication. Enough said. Life is beautiful! David B.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Michael, Houston, Texas — Fri, 01 May 2009 20:53:56 GMT

We always held our breath going over the Red River Bridge from Texas to Oklahoma on I-35. last breath of nasty old Texas air for the clean fresh air of Oklahoma. Sounds silly, but I still do it I am 38.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Michael, Houston, Texas — Fri, 01 May 2009 20:57:32 GMT

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

J. Sullivan, San Jose, Ca. — Fri, 01 May 2009 20:57:41 GMT

I would comb the area and look for people living close by. It was probably someone tired of hearing all the honking.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Brian,Lakewood, WA — Fri, 01 May 2009 21:02:37 GMT

It's a sad tragedy that someone can be allowed to remove a landmark such as the "Honking Tree" by just cutting it down without any regards to the affection and relevance for all those people who have passed by it for so many years and have realized that the "Honking Tree" was also part of themselves, if not only for just the short fleeting minutes as they passed by this one and only tree in the median of a 21 mile stretch. This tree will always stand proud for those who remember.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

rick — Fri, 01 May 2009 21:03:01 GMT

There used to be a lone cottonwood tree by the junction of two highways in southeastern Wyoming. It was the only tree for miles in any direction, and it was a local landmark for over a 100 years - people knew they were coming up the the junction when they could see the tree several miles away.

An IDIOT from the Wyo. highway dept. cut the tree down because he thought it was a safety hazard (no body had ever hit the tree and it was several feet off the pavement).

Needless to say, the highway dept. got several irate phone calls from the locals. The rancher that owned land next to the highway got so mad that he planted a big windbreak on his property next to where the old tree used to stand.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

JonBFL — Fri, 01 May 2009 21:05:49 GMT

Wow completely saddening. On the other hand, we don't blink an eye at many other losses.

But, I'm with Steve from Boston, but let's hope its the last act of well-aged tree - Go Ents!

I'll refrain from passing on other appropriate uses of a chain saw that come to mind.

:-)

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

SKI — Fri, 01 May 2009 21:07:59 GMT

KEEP ON HONKING AND PLANT ANOTHER TREE!!!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Nic, St. Charles, Illinois — Fri, 01 May 2009 21:15:53 GMT

Fight back, become a guerrilla gardener. Buy a small tree of the type as the Honk Tree. Plant the tree a little farther away from the road than the original Honk Tree. Be sure to add potting soil around the root ball so the tree gets a good start. For more info, go to guerrillagardening dot ORG.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Tea Time Boston,MA — Fri, 01 May 2009 21:18:58 GMT

I've been climbing trees since 1978 and now run my own tree care business.
This story jumps out at me because it crosses more than one boundary.
First off....you don't JUST cut down trees.
Second....tradition.....you don't cut down someone's "charming tradition".
This was a spiteful act......I hope there's a judge out there who will make the punishment fit the crime when the vandal is found.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Megan Two Harbors, MN — Fri, 01 May 2009 21:20:15 GMT

Thanks to everyone for your sympathy, it's really such a stupid sad thing but I will never stop honking.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

will, Happy Valley, Hong Kong — Fri, 01 May 2009 21:23:09 GMT

Honk the stump!
With a bit of luck, the same idiots will skid off the road on an icy winter night, coming to rest on the same stump. By some freak accident, petrol from a chainsaw in the vehicle spills and catches light. Cellphones, overcoats etc., are lost in the blaze and the vandals are not "rescued" until well frostbitten.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

delia g loas angeles ca — Fri, 01 May 2009 21:29:58 GMT

I'm from Los Angeles but just reading this makes me so angry. all who participated in this should be punished. Maybe they should be given 1,000 hours of community service Planting more HONK trees.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Roberta, Boerne, TEXAS — Fri, 01 May 2009 21:31:39 GMT

This sounds like kids, no matter their age. People today do not respect anything or anyone. Thank you Liberals. When we were a Christian based country, we were better people.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Diane from Milwaukee, WI — Fri, 01 May 2009 21:33:18 GMT

This is so sad and hurtful. I agree with Suzanne and Jonathan from above.....please plant another tree!!! Don't let destructive individuals stomp down your spirit.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Luke, Egypt — Fri, 01 May 2009 21:33:55 GMT

That is sad. Maybe you should plant a tree by the "honk stump." That way you have a new "honk tree." It can be called, "Honk Tree Jr."

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

William R. Cousert, Murrieta, CA — Fri, 01 May 2009 21:35:00 GMT

>Why don't they plant another tree!

I agree! Start a collection. I'll put in $10 towards the effort.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

sundee - texarkana, ar — Fri, 01 May 2009 21:38:29 GMT

i'm so sorry for all the people that won't get to honk at that sweet tree anymore. mean people really suck -- makes me mad when people do things like that. where i live there was a giant rabbit with a saddle on it that sat at the curb for years and years outside of a pawn shop. a few years ago someone hit it with their car (not accidentally either). now the poor thing is destroyed. it was a landmark here - people loved to get their picture taken on it.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Andrew P Bend Oregon — Fri, 01 May 2009 21:40:47 GMT

That's horrible! I have not seen the tree, but I think that someone should beat the tar out of whoever would do something like that!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

TG Vancouver, wa — Fri, 01 May 2009 21:43:05 GMT

Reminds me of silent rocks on Mt. Hood in OR.

Damn them vandals, I'd like to see them try and cut down silent rocks.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

bill mikenis darien, il. — Fri, 01 May 2009 21:44:57 GMT

chain saws are noisy, had to be someone thatlivesclose to the tree. i know it's only a tree, but something that stood for so long, it's a sad story. if another tree is planted, and is allowed to grow tall, better to just wave to it as you drive by and not honk.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Sharon, Owatonna, MN — Fri, 01 May 2009 21:48:19 GMT

I grew up driving past that wonderful tree. My hopes are high that they will do something special with the trunk. Make it into a sign or a landmark. Because in all essence that tree was our landmark up North. I grew up in Silver Bay and I will miss seeing that beautiful tree when I drive up the shore next!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Megan, Indiana — Fri, 01 May 2009 21:56:41 GMT

I am sure some people will read this piece and say, "It was just a tree. Get over it." It was not just a tree. Aside from the fact that it was a living thing that helped clean the air in our environment, it was obviously a part of a lot of people's lives and memories. What was the purpose in destroying it? I see none. I hope you all will either continue to use it as a "Honk Stump", or plant another one in its memory. We have several similar "hallmark" items like that in our small town. I'd be sad if they were missing.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Jim — Fri, 01 May 2009 21:58:34 GMT

I can almost guarantee that some Federal Agency here in the US will prevent another tree from being planted. They will provide some bogus reason but the real reason will be to show the people who is in charge.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

john, cincinnati — Fri, 01 May 2009 22:05:26 GMT

Well you can sit around and be sad or you could plant another tree so the next generation can watch it grow. be bold plant more than one tree good for the planet you know.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Stingray190RS North Brunswick New Jersey — Fri, 01 May 2009 22:16:42 GMT

Why not plant a "few" new Honk trees. It's the green thing to do! :-)

Get some kid from your community to help with the planting, and maybe even a "honk tree" sign

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Rob, Woodland Hills, CA — Fri, 01 May 2009 22:17:16 GMT

My recommendation, plant a new tree for every foot in height lost from the old one.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Terry, Kona, Hawai`i — Fri, 01 May 2009 22:19:24 GMT

You've lost the "one, 'toot', tree" which is a shame. Plant another, make it a big deal & show the vandals.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Proud conservative, guns and religion, Pennsylvania — Fri, 01 May 2009 22:23:12 GMT

Typical America-hating, tree-hugging, elitist liberal Obama-voter drivel. That tree could have provided a hiding place for a terrorist, and you people want it back? Irresponsible!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

A. K. Sandvik, Naperville, IL — Fri, 01 May 2009 22:30:47 GMT

I won't be able to attend, but for those in the area this weekend, a memorial event has apparently been planned (according to Facebook's "Remembering the Honking Tree" group)...

What: "Drive by & honk"
Start Time: Sunday, May 3 at 6:30pm
End Time: Sunday, May 3 at 7:00pm
Where: Rest Area off of Hwy 61 Expressway in Knife River

Personally, I plan to keep on honking...

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

teri — Fri, 01 May 2009 22:32:08 GMT

Mankind can love places and sights and be connected to a place or a tree. Native Americans called them, "spirit places", a place or object that brings peace and joy to the human spirit. Aren't trees beautiful in their own right? This tree signaled they were almost home, and they thought the tree beautiful. This tree was spiritual and brought beauty and happiness to the human soul. We had a tree trimmer trim our sycamore too much, our fault, and I still miss the beauty and peace my tree brought to me. After all, it is all about peace and beauty in our time.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

LeEric Marvin, Anchorage, AK. — Fri, 01 May 2009 22:36:24 GMT

If it is the tree I veiwed on Google Earth at N 46* 58' 12" W91* 44' 25"

Then I can't blame one of the local residents from cutting it down. Who could sleep with car horns honking all night long.

If I viewed the wrong tree, How about providing the corridinates. If it was out in the middle of nowhere, I'd side with the tree. Otherwise , consider a tradition that doesn't infringe on one's persuit of Happiness (for good nights sleep).

Pardon my being a stick in the mud.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Andyb, Palo Alto, CA. — Fri, 01 May 2009 22:37:16 GMT

Hopefully a new shoot will grow off of the stump.
That's why you always leave a foot or two of trunk when you cut down your Christmas tree.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

James, Philadelphia, PA — Fri, 01 May 2009 22:38:51 GMT

OMG! In Jersey, near my grandmothers, we passed this large tower that had these round things on it at the top. We called it "Big Funny Ears" and when we saw it, we knew we were close to her house! We would, as we passed sing "Big Funny Ears, Big Funny Ears, Big Funny Ears......" (which after about 5 minutes does start to get annoying) until we couldn't see it anymore, and by that time we were there! Of course, we always, just as we passed the tower, would honk!! To this day, some 28 years later, Big Funny Ears still gets us singing and honking!!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

T Stone Elmira Oregon — Fri, 01 May 2009 22:43:31 GMT

A Renton and S Magnuson have great ideas. Keep honking at the now "Honk Stump" and plant another tree. Vandalism is selfish behavior, but killing is a whole new story. Those responsible persons should be ashamed and should come forward to help plant the new tree.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Eric Larson, Saint Paul,MN — Fri, 01 May 2009 22:44:49 GMT

As a Former Employee of W.R.E.L.C I drove past this tree many times and even after I stopped working there I still honked every time I went past that tree. Why do people have to be so stupid? It's not like the tree did anything to anyone except to bring a sense of joy to people to or from there destinations on the north shore. No Matter what if you traveled up to Two Harbours you've passed this tree.(except of course if you took the Scenic Route.) I say we plant a new one so one day our children will know the tradition of the honking tree.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

GK, Waikoloa, Hawaii — Fri, 01 May 2009 22:49:47 GMT

What's sad about this is that it may be seem like a small "breach" of humanity but it really is not. The vandals who did this I can assure you - do much more. And what this shows is that people are stupid. Even though I don't want to have laws for every issue we face - I just see this as a microcosm for illegal fishing, deforestation and the vast amount of dumping trash that we do every day. I am sad too but I hope someone goes there and like the nightime gardners plants a new tree and the people that cut this tree down go to Hell.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Randy, Kansas City, Mo — Fri, 01 May 2009 23:07:59 GMT

Destruction for the sake of destruction is a part of a dark side of humanity. I wish we had the same tendencies to build beauty or preserve nature instead.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Heidi Eversley, Denver, Colorado — Fri, 01 May 2009 23:25:33 GMT

So sad that something so charming should be destroyed in such a stupid way. I do think the situation can and should be remedied though. I love other's suggestions of planting a beautiful new tree. Perhaps before that happens, those in the community who care can leave a few flowers.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

ALGORE — Fri, 01 May 2009 23:31:50 GMT

I am sorry to report this, but I cut the tree down. I needed some more lumber to add a new wing onto my cabin up there. I had to have somewhere to store my Nobel peace prize. My Bad. Remember. . Keep buying those carbon credits! Papa needs a new Jet Plane.
Thanks!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Shawn Thomas, Treasure Island, Fl. (formerly Two Harbors, MN). — Fri, 01 May 2009 23:32:26 GMT

Man, that stinks. Every year I visit my family in Two Harbors, and without fail, honk everytime we see it. It's like seeing Sonju on the outside edge of town, lets me know I'm almost home. I do hope they plant another one, so when I (eventually) bring my own kids up there they can have the same tradition.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

JFT — Fri, 01 May 2009 23:38:41 GMT

How tragic that some moron found fit to destroy yet another icon, one of those things that make life fun and interesting. I recently did a landscape of a beautiful eucalyptus grove (I'm in Australia) and was told only yesterday that some jerk had gone down and hacked away at the trees with an axe, leaving deep wounds and defacing them permanently. I'm glad I finished my painting before this happened.

Everyone should now honk as they pass the Honk Tree stump. Don't let the mental midgets win! I can well remember looking for landmarks like the Honk Tree when I was a child and on driving trips with my parents. Let the Honk Tree live on in spirit.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Shannon, Duluth, MN — Fri, 01 May 2009 23:47:54 GMT

I keep hearing comments from people saying, "Hey, it's just a tree! Why are people so worked up about it?" I think it's hard to understand unless the tree's actually been a part of your life. Even as a kid, I always got excited when I saw the top of the tree poking up over the horizon because it meant we were getting close to Two Harbors and I'd get to reach over and honk the horn! Something I've always appreciated but kind of taken for granted on countless trips is gone now, and I'm actually kind of dreading the next time I have to make that drive up the shore. But I'll make sure to lay on the horn for an extra few seconds in memory!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Kim Smith — Sat, 02 May 2009 00:01:05 GMT

Plant another tree!!!! Use an acorn or pine nut or whatever from the original tree, cultivate it until it is a sapling and transplant it. Call it Son of Honk. This kind of gentle quirkiness deserves to be preserved. And if you find out who cut it down, 500 hours of community service cleaning up trash from the highway while wearing a "I Killed the Honk tree" t-shirt should be a fitting punishment.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

virginia Weidenaar — Sat, 02 May 2009 02:01:16 GMT

Trees by Joyce Kilmer. I'm 87yrs old I learned this in grade school,(Quote I think that I shall never see ,a poem as lovely as a tree A tree who's hungry mouth is pressed against the earths sweet flowing breast .A tree that may in summer ware a nest of Robins in her hair, A tree that lifts it's leafy arms as if to pray,. Poems are made by fools like me, but only God can make a tree. Venge is mine I will repay says the God who made the tree judgement awaits the culprit

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

~Rick~ Central, Wisconsin — Sat, 02 May 2009 02:05:12 GMT

I have enough ill feelings towards the wastefulness of paper products, due to all the trees that are cut down for them. Now we have some ID!OTS running around cutting down trees for apparently, just to be JackA##'s!

I will pray that someone will hear about this spiteful act by these lowly waste of the air that they breath, which comes from the trees ironically, and turn their arse in!! I see many great ideas above this comment for continuing your tradition of honking at that lonely tree! Now it's stump, may the vandals have their crotches infested with a million red fire ants, and have their arm shrink so that they can't reach to swat them away!! ;v) Sorry not meant to offend anyone. I'm off the soap box now! Peace to all!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Shannon Ritchey, Hibbing, MN — Sat, 02 May 2009 02:12:27 GMT

Join the Face Book page: Remembering the Honking Tree. There are already 800+ members!

http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=73118228069&ref=nf

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Omega Denver CO — Sat, 02 May 2009 02:25:23 GMT

http://www.roadsideamerica.com/story/8450

growing up in Laramie and travelling back and forth to Cheyenne, this was my 'honking tree' I always made sure to make eye contact with President Lincoln.

Hope a new tree gets planted keep your tradition alive.

:-)

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Douglas Striker, St. Cloud, Minnesota — Sat, 02 May 2009 03:02:51 GMT

When I was little, waiting to see that tree, and have mom honk at it, was the highlight of our trip up the shore. It also meant we were almost to Grandma's house. As I grew up, I thought Mom just had to be a little bit crazy to honk at some ol' tree on our way up to see Gram. But now here I am, almost 30 and every time I've made the drive myself, I too have honked at that tree, the last time not even a month ago. It made me really sad today to think that somebody cut that tree down. I just loved the idea of a little local tradition that not everybody knew about, and it made the North shore of Minnesota just that more special to me. But, I will still honk.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

T. Metso, MN. — Sat, 02 May 2009 03:24:04 GMT

At first I thought this was about our tree on Hwy. 2 west of Duluth, but then we wave at our tree. Although many do honk at the lonely tree standing proud in the middle of a field. It is a loss as it had become tradition within families and a tribute to nature. Perhaps donations could be made and permits approved to replace it near as it was.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Mike, Baltimore, MD — Sat, 02 May 2009 03:30:48 GMT

I always find vandalism so disheartening, especially when it is something so irreplaceable. I too think that the tree should be replaced. Are there any seeds or seedling offspring? If not, maybe izzy from Manitoba could send a seedling offspring of their "honk" tree.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Larry South, Two Harbors, MN — Sat, 02 May 2009 03:53:48 GMT

It is like so many other things that some individual or group, will destroy something that means the world to the rest of us, I suppose much like the values of this once great country.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Rhonda Hatcher — Sat, 02 May 2009 04:28:34 GMT

Know what,sometimes good can come out of a bad situation.For instance,we here in Alabama have seen stumps from cut down trees sprout out some new growth!!!Please preserve it and put some reinforced wire around it and a monument with it's name as you know it and pray,"GOD" LOVES TREES TOO...

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

James Winters, Bangor, Maine — Sat, 02 May 2009 04:31:00 GMT

If the measure of actual intelligence was in appreciating gifts and helping to protect life on earth; then humans, male humans, are the stupidest creatures on the planet.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Mary - San Antonio, TX — Sat, 02 May 2009 04:31:42 GMT

I'm so sorry to hear of your loss. We had a piece of Texas history nearly taken in a similar way. The Treaty Oak, in Austin, Texas, was the last surviving tree in a legendary grove of 14 trees that served as a sacred meeting place for Comanche and Tonkawa Tribes was poisoned. The tree was believed to be 500 years old. It was killed by a herbacidal poison that could have killed several dozen trees. The good news was that people from around the state came together as well as a donation from the herbacide manufacturer and through an amazing effort saved the tree, though it is a shade of its former glory.

I believe in the karma spoken by a previous writer. Our vandal was caught and convicted. Though the tree was serverely damaged, the first crop of acorns were distributed throughout Texas. Life finds a way and justice in the short or long term eventually will prevail.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Miranda Evans, Deltona, Florida — Sat, 02 May 2009 04:33:07 GMT

We had a honk tree on Rte 62 near Jamestown, NY. The tree kept getting more and more bent over but still stayed alive. Always reminded me of a buck with a big rack for some reason! Haven't been there in over 10 years now though....

Here's a theory - perhaps the vandal(s) knew the importance of this tree to someone close to them and they killed it as a way of revenge against that person....

Very sad though.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

RICHARD -- LAKE PLACID, N.Y. — Sat, 02 May 2009 05:02:31 GMT

I THINK THAT I SHALL NRVER SEE
A POEM LOVELY AS A TREE

A TREE WHOSE HUNGRY MOUTH IS PRESSED
AGAINST THE EARTH'S SWEET FLOWING BREAST

POEM BY JOYCE KILMER

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Rick — Sat, 02 May 2009 06:06:39 GMT

WE have a rock that looks like a frog. We do the same thing in the car as we drive ny "Frog Rock". I would donate for a replacement tree.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Minneapolis , MN — Sat, 02 May 2009 06:19:19 GMT

It was probably one of those damned Canadian's!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Ambrose, Calgary, Alberta — Sat, 02 May 2009 08:16:46 GMT

Go... plant a new one. I'd do it myself, but I'm a ways away.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Karen, Beaver Dams, NY - near the NASCAR Race Track. — Sat, 02 May 2009 10:24:58 GMT

How would they like being "cut off at the ankles"? How about planting 2 trees on each side? Maintain this beautiful tradition! Too many trees are being cut down now and it's destroying our beautiful planet. We don't realize how beautiful God made this planet and put us here until I see it from the ISS. Take another look. God is the one who made all this beauty. Let's keep it that way.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Chuck, Moultonborough, NH — Sat, 02 May 2009 10:59:11 GMT

How about a little prosecution? The tree was obviously on either a state or county maintained easement. If caught, fine them and give them an extensive amount of community service hours to repay the damage they have done to the community.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Sandra E, Bakersfield, CA — Sat, 02 May 2009 11:44:58 GMT

It's too bad we don't feel about all trees the way that small town felt about that one tree.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

AVI — Sat, 02 May 2009 12:02:11 GMT

Plant another one, and, place a guard on it. In fact, plant several in case some don't take.
To the vandals: I curse you with "what goes around, comes around," you all shall loose something very dear to you, very soon. Ha.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Ben, Brooklyn, NY — Sat, 02 May 2009 12:18:38 GMT

That is deplorable, inane behavior. And no matter how close it was to someone's property, there was no "good reason" to cut it down.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

TheBobs — Sat, 02 May 2009 13:35:37 GMT

That is just so wrong, but I have to say, sadly, I am not surprised.

I was a "teacher" for 2 years (and I use the term loosely; very little learning goes on in that school). What I see is a generation of children who are not socialized, who are not taught to feel remorse (ahem...parents????), have no manners and live only for the moment.

I see the same thing in many Internet postings. Instead of intelligent discourse, we see people writing nasty comments and replies to each other (and filled with grammatical, spelling, capitalization and punctuation mistakes, to boot). What a world!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

DownWithVandelism, Austin, TX — Sat, 02 May 2009 13:40:06 GMT

My sympathies. I know how it feels to lose a fun landmark like that. We had a "honking tunnel" in the Black Hills (SD) when I was a kid. It was just a short, little tunnel but we always honked when going through it. I did the same when my daughter was little. And then, "they" decided they needed to make that road wider so they enlarged the tunnel and lined it with concrete. They made it ugly in their efforts so, while it's still there, it just isn't the same anymore - it doesn't even sound the same. It makes me mad and sad everytime I drive that road.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Rosa, Hutchinson, Ks — Sat, 02 May 2009 13:52:12 GMT

Some people . . . We have a tree like that here in Kansas as well, I can't imagine driving by and not seeing it. I hope that a new tree will be planted and that the tradition can continue, in some way.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Leeanne Bellingham, WA — Sat, 02 May 2009 13:52:41 GMT

I think the Honk Tree will have the last laugh. A new tree will sprout from the stump and rise majestically upward in nature's fickle finger of fate salute.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

UNCLE HOWIE,NH — Sat, 02 May 2009 13:52:58 GMT

THE TREE IS NOT DEAD AS LONG AS THERE REMAINS THE STUMP. NEW SHOOTS WILL SPRING AND THERE WILL GROW DOUBLE THE TREES THAT ONCE WAS. VIVA NATURE!!!!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Mike N — Sat, 02 May 2009 14:01:34 GMT

My guess it was some frustrated bozo who insists he knows better than everyone, and decided that tree was a hazard. I bet he complained to the your Department of Transportation, and when they didn't do anything about - he "handled" it. It seems a little elaborate for a high school prank.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Jim Dostal Lancaster Pa — Sat, 02 May 2009 14:28:52 GMT

It is not odd to be sad at the loss of a tree. My hometown St. Marys Pa had a Large Pine Tree in the center of town (on the diamond) Every year it would be decorated for Christmas.. Until one year vandals tried to cut it down.. got half way and quit. The town tried to save it until a large wind storm finished the job. That was almost 20 years ago.. and I still miss that tree at Christmas time.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

derek, waconia mn — Sat, 02 May 2009 14:29:45 GMT

Pathetic, wastes of human skin that did this. I'd go as far as to liken it to killing someone's dog. And, I've had dogs better than some of the people I've met over the years-sadly.

This is a human interest story that needs to heard. Coming from my hometown of TH; I really feel for those people there.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

JuliaKatherine, Eau Claire, WI — Sat, 02 May 2009 14:31:02 GMT

it is true that another tree (Honk II) could be planted in its stead, but think of how on-guard and wary everyone might feel the second time around :\ I would want a 24 hour guard or some sort of security system surrounding and protecting the tree! How sad that such a neat tradition was tainted. I agree w/ Anthony from WA - keep honking away, don't let the ignorance of others get your spirits down too much!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

nelson Two Harbors Mn — Sat, 02 May 2009 14:45:37 GMT

Im from Two Harbors born and raised and it is very sad to see this tree go this way. Its a mindless act. Coming home from duluth and seeing the tree ment 5 minutes till home. It to bad. hope they catch who is responsible.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

susan, asheville, nc, usa — Sat, 02 May 2009 14:47:37 GMT

See you in the next life little tree.
very sad.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

CKRLMJR, Oklahoma City, OK — Sat, 02 May 2009 15:27:11 GMT

So sorry to hear about your "honk tree". I hope you catch the people responsible. It would be interesting to know if any locals had complained in the past about honking. If they had, I sympathize with them but, for me, cutting the tree down would never have been an option. I hope there is a monument or something put in it place and that the stump is protected.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

xirus, louisville, ky, usa — Sat, 02 May 2009 15:34:47 GMT

i feel so sad for you all. it is like losing a trusted friend that you knew would always be there for you. i hope plans come up to put something in its place.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Al Scott - Sopchoppy, Florida — Sat, 02 May 2009 15:51:06 GMT

What a shame! Might be it was some local government agency that did this; oh, in the name of "Public Safety" of course! I really hope you find out WHO. ~~~

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Chuck, Grantham, New Hampshire — Sat, 02 May 2009 16:00:43 GMT

My home town is Lebanon, New Hampshire. Around 1965 Peaanie Goodwin planted a blue spruce Christmas tree in our center of town park. Eight years ago two people cut it down. A Local doctor and great man, Dr. Myric Wood, chased them and they were caught. The city replanted a new Cristmas tree in the park and in 2006 we dedicated that tree to Dr. Wood with a granite monument, two days after he passed. Replant another tree and hold a big party to dedicate it!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

David Oss, Shepherd, MT — Sat, 02 May 2009 16:51:32 GMT

Some years ago Montana (and our entire nation) lost an historical and natural rock formation along the bank of the Missouri that was called the "Eye Of The Needle" due to vandalism. It had been enjoyed by river boatmen, tourists, and recreationists for hundreds of years until drunken vandals climbed up the bank of the river and smashed it to oblivion. The perpetrators are lucky that no one ever found out who they were. Stories like these need to be told to school children when they are still young and impressionable, while their hearts can still be reached. Later on the alcohol dulls their senses!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Char Sollenberger, Anchorage, Alaska — Sat, 02 May 2009 16:52:44 GMT

I agree in that the tree should be replaced with another. (I have family in Duluth). Unfortunately, it will probably only be a matter of time before some brainless dipstick will be out there with a chainsaw to destroy another thing of beauty. So, all must be prepared for that strong posibility.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Heather, Trabuco Canyon, CA — Sat, 02 May 2009 16:58:31 GMT

Can't help but be inspired by this story. If I lived around there, I would STILL honk the horn. It is now the "Honk Stump". Those numbskulls may have cut down the tree, but the roots remain!! It still stands, against all of the odds. (^_^)

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Ann, San Francisco, CA — Sat, 02 May 2009 17:03:17 GMT

That's a terrible and shocking loss. So senseless. It might sound small to some, but little traditions are special. During precious childhood Christmas nights, we'd drive along the 605 Freeway in Irwindale and there was a factory next to a quarry on our right. There was always a lighted star on top! The Caterpillar place always lighted bulldozers visible from the lot. The traditions that burn so beautifully into different lives are very personal and brilliant. Bless the honking tree, and may karma do as it will with the vandals.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Eric Maietta, Boston, Mass — Sat, 02 May 2009 17:12:08 GMT

I'm sorry to hear that someone chose to inflict such damage on this local symbol. You could plant a new tree, but it just wouldn't be the same. My advice would be to consult with your nearest greenhouse or agricultural organization about the possibility of grafting a cutting or cuttings from a similar tree to the stump of your old friend. That way, your tree could be given new life. Good luck!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Mary, San Diego, California — Sat, 02 May 2009 17:37:07 GMT

How sad. Some fool probably thought they would have bragging rights or some other sick idea. Eventually they WILL get what they deserve! Maybe a view with no trees.
I too remember the loss of New Hampshire's Old Man of the Mountain. I felt the same way.
Gone forever means . . . . gone forever.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Eddy Beard — Sat, 02 May 2009 17:45:25 GMT

How sad. We have a honk tree between Hutchinson and Wichita, Kansas. It would be sad if someone hurt it. It is decorated for many special events and provides shade on a hot afternoon.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Dave, Salt Lake City, Utah — Sat, 02 May 2009 17:46:06 GMT

Here in Utah we have a beautiful set of Pictograph panels dating from anywhere between 1500 and 3000 years ago: really amazing rock art on canyon walls. Idiot vandals over the years have carved their own initials over the top of these amazing panels, ruining them forever. Why? Nobody knows. But I'm sad for people who can only destroy and not create.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Kale Kansa City,KS — Sat, 02 May 2009 17:47:09 GMT

Maybe they were desparate for firewood.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Marlene Cocchiola — Sat, 02 May 2009 17:48:09 GMT

HONK! HONK!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Sandra Churchwell, Port Orange, FL — Sat, 02 May 2009 18:33:04 GMT

What a pity!! Would planting a row of honk trees along this road help with the loss? That would provide everyone who enjoyed your tree a means to re-take your town's tradition. Good luck!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

John Doe, Seattle, Wash — Sat, 02 May 2009 18:46:28 GMT

I lived next to a park with a gazebo that hosted music concerts. Instead of applauding the people would honk thier horns. I worked 11pm to 7am and concerts were over at 630 or 7pm. Have some consideration. Maybe it wasn't drunk kids.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Lee, Small Town, Nebraska — Sat, 02 May 2009 18:53:13 GMT

Yeah, vandalism sucked....but this tree was one car wreck/death away from being cut down anyway....a massive tree on the side of a major highway is a terrible idea.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Scott Thompson — Sat, 02 May 2009 18:57:22 GMT

Someone ought to go to Lake Itasca and put a blackeye on Paul Bunyan until the vandals come forward.Then they can clean Paul up in front of everyone as a penance for the disgrace they caused, then they can kiss the northend of the south facing Babe.....

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

LostDime — Sat, 02 May 2009 19:11:26 GMT

Tree was probably cut down because of the law suit happy world we live in. The proximity of the tree to the travel lane of pavement is inside the allowed distance for the rate of lane speed. The engineer might have OK'd it at the time but I'll be someone who now has the job for the road works, mentioned it and because of millions of dollars in potential suit. it had to come down! (I know I have to do TOO MANY of these in my line of work. It is a terrible shame!)

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Daniel, St Louis — Sat, 02 May 2009 19:49:40 GMT

Our country is losing it's identity because of idiotic uncaring individuals who simply don't care about anything that might be important to others.
Vandalism is a childish game played by infantile thinking people who have no respect for anything or anybody. But what goes around comes around eventually. These vandals will one day regret it one way or another.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Bob WIlliams, Fresno, CA — Sat, 02 May 2009 19:55:07 GMT

Funny to see how everyone jumps to the conclusion that it was vandalS (plural) or that it was drunk teens. Maybe it was a lone person, who just got tired of driving this patch of road and getting honked at by passing drivers - maybe they wanted the honking to mean what's supposed to be used for - to alert other drivers of impending issues. OTOH, every town DOES have it's local customs and you DO let the "bad guys" win if you don't KEEP honking at the stump. And plant a new tree.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

paul v. lutz, Dunkirk, N Y — Sat, 02 May 2009 20:08:00 GMT

The tallest one piece, free-standing flag pole in the U.S. was in Dunkirk, N Y until some local boobs cut it down while hiding in a heavy fog. Minnesota does not have exclusive ownership of stupid persons.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

brent schomer — Sat, 02 May 2009 20:37:06 GMT

hey c'mon times are tough pine is worth money people. blame wall street... just kiddin'

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Judy, Pleasant Hill, Ca — Sat, 02 May 2009 21:41:30 GMT

Soem people are just hell bent on taking beauty out of the world. I hate to hear stories like this.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Todd B, Wilmington DE — Sat, 02 May 2009 22:16:16 GMT

Well, you can say the vandals were jerks but you can't say that they had little intelligence. After all, they cut down a tree and got away with it. Can't be too stupid. Just because they didn't like the tree, doesn't mean that they are stupid. Maybe they were sick of you honking all the time!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Bob — Sat, 02 May 2009 22:25:28 GMT

Hey, I'll tell you this. I had two young small trees that I transplanted. Thought they died. Looked withered, dry, almost whitish-gray. So I dug up one and threw it in the trash. The other I let stand and finally broke it off at the base. It was about an inch in diameter and about two inches were sticking out of the ground. One day while mowing around it for the 10,000th time (not really) I noticed very small green leaves seemed to sprouting up in the middle of the very small stump. I said to it "if you can make it, you can stay!". About 4-6 years later (approximately), that tree stood over 10 feet tall from being a two-inch stump in the ground. True story. Perhaps the honk tree still has some life in it.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Trainer Tina in Tampa, FL — Sat, 02 May 2009 22:36:53 GMT

So so sad... and it's unfortunate that the lower intellegence life forms in your town do not respect what life or tradition is... i just moved from VA Beach to Tampa and am ABSOLUTELY SHOCKED by the lack of respect for humanity that exists in this multicultural hispanic based community... shouldn't a commonality enjoin and bring people together? A symbol of your town's history & pride & faith in it's own growth and development over the years is now lsot forever... but have your town find the vandals... do many many hours of road side litter pick up and landscaping work in the community and then have those kids or adults earn the money to replace the tree with a memorium and new tree-- and place a honk sign in front of it... or better yet, put up some old stockades and lock them up in it so everyone can honk at them in shame...

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Cody Hughes, Hilo, Hi. — Sat, 02 May 2009 22:45:23 GMT

I feel your loss at the vandalism of your "Honk Tree". Unfortunately, it is impossible to try to rationalize such an action. We should all take heart in the knowledge that people who do things like this are usually trying to capture something in their lives that is lacking. In this case, probably something behind their pants zipper!!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Rob Rinde, Starbuck Minnesota — Sat, 02 May 2009 22:57:24 GMT

How very sad! Mr. Hensley saved and made a tradition. I have been by this tree several times always wondering why the honking, now I know. I wish I had joined in. I am in agreement that though the original is lost, a replacement is greatly needed. My thanks to you Mr. Hensley for saving the tree. Hoping the tradition does not die and a replacement is born, with a historical marker.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Jim Rousch — Sun, 03 May 2009 00:35:00 GMT

It's times like this when I really hate the human race and wish apes had won the Battle of Evolution.

To destroy life and history in such an arbitrary manner is simply inexecusable.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Todd — Sun, 03 May 2009 00:40:45 GMT

people do things in most cases for a reason. I would bet a DOT or road crew worker hacked it down . Whom ever it caused inconvienance Thats your culprit .

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Peter — Sun, 03 May 2009 01:42:31 GMT

In Texas we had "The Treaty Oak", a huge spreading oak tree in Austin that a vandal tried to kill with poison. What kind of a mind could deliberately do something like that? Here's the story. http://www.ci.austin.tx.us/treatyoak/hist1.htm

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Mike Jones — Sun, 03 May 2009 03:49:14 GMT

Hey, it was a TREE. Trees are cut down all the time to build your frickin' homes, for picnic tables, and to burn in your fireplaces. Bet you didn't whine then. Some people have way too much time on their hands and get way too emotional.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

deb chester, montana — Sun, 03 May 2009 03:57:01 GMT

You never know it might sucker up as long as the root system is alive. Then you'd have a brand new tree!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Annie, Northern, CA — Sun, 03 May 2009 04:15:45 GMT

We had a honk tree where I grew up in the Pine Barrens of Southern NJ. Altho I haven't seen it in over 30 years, I would feel a sense of loss of my childhood, if I had heard of this event happening to it. I am so sorry for your senseless loss.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

kid Ashland WI — Sun, 03 May 2009 04:24:52 GMT

It has been a long while since I have last been up that way but I do rebember the Honk tree lovingly HONK HONK!!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Nancy Anne Larsen , Denmark — Sun, 03 May 2009 05:25:09 GMT

I guess all i can say is you can honk at the sight where the tree once stood as a memorial to what it symbolised for you that live in Minnesota.I have driven up the noth shore of Minnesota many times and must have seen the tree, but must admit I never honked at it. If i were to honk at all the beauty around me I would be honking all the time .....smile...but keep the memory alive in your heart ,....and this is something the vandels cannot destroy.
I remember a special tree when I would drive up from Cambridge to Duluth...this tree caught my eye because it was the only tree that just had braches m and never any leaves, no matter what time of year, and the highway department cut down all the trees around it like this one , but for some reason not this one , and still to this day after 60 years that tree still stands, and in its way it symbolizes to me that we can survive anything if we just stand up against all odds. that tree is in my heart and even today it gives me strength even I cannot see it from where I know live.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Erin, Independence, MO — Sun, 03 May 2009 06:05:18 GMT

I'd never heard of the honk tree until now, but I'm angry anyone would just cut it down. Not cool.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Ron, Modesto, CA — Sun, 03 May 2009 06:34:45 GMT

Be patient. That trunk may sprout. The Honk Tree just MIGHT COME BACK!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Linda, Los Angeles, California — Sun, 03 May 2009 07:14:46 GMT

As a child we had a tree we would either honk or shout out "Hi tree" in Big Bear. It is simple times shared with strangers that shape us into a community and friends.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Dave Schreyer — Sun, 03 May 2009 08:04:13 GMT

Stephanie,

Excellent job writing this. Rumor has it that the vandals have been identified and possibly a "rival" of THHS. If this is 100 percent true the repercussions are going to be serious to say the least. Only idiots would think to do such a thing! The mood in Two Harbors has been VERY interesting to say the least. MNDOT told the TV stations here that the vandalism is a FELONY! No doubt this case will be handled very carefully and by people who have some neutrality of feelings. I hope. MNDOT feels the loss as well as it is my understanding that Charlie Hensley was well thought of back in those days. I remember as a little boy when they started clearing the land for that road. Sad day for everyone who had a connection to the area and the community.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

JS in SD — Sun, 03 May 2009 09:11:58 GMT

It is sad that vandals have to go and destroy a thing of beauty that had special meaning to so many. This reminds me of a lone tree in the middle I-64 going into Norfolk, VA that stood in the middle of the jersey wall that separated the east and westbound lanes. This tree was also cut down by vandals some time ago. While I have never seen the tree mentioned in this article, I remember many trips seeing the tree in VA - it was even decorated for the holidays.

I hope that karma catches up with the person(s) who cut down this tree.

Keep Honking!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Bruce PIck, Mystic, CT — Sun, 03 May 2009 11:36:15 GMT

Plant a new tree. And keep honking!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

revenant, minnesota — Sun, 03 May 2009 13:14:22 GMT

According to the rules of Karma, it could be the tree or it's fans got what THEY deserve... and you have no idea why and you whine endlessly about how unfair cosmic justice is....

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Debbie, Yarmouth Nova Scotia Canada — Sun, 03 May 2009 13:23:46 GMT

I don't understand why people do things like this. It seems like some are bent on destroying the beauty to be found in the world. We have to feel sorry for them because they don't see it.
I have never seen the honking tree, but I miss knowing it's in the world. :(

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Nunya Bizness, Planet, Earth — Sun, 03 May 2009 15:11:27 GMT

I was sad reading it. I hope whoever did it if they did it for kicks will get what's coming to them. Karma is a b!tch!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Mutt the Process Server, Colorado Springs, CO — Sun, 03 May 2009 15:31:54 GMT

So very sad. It was a hometown "shrine". I feel for you folks. I have similar things in my hometown in Ohio. I hope you find the perps who did it. Remember the kid from Dayton, Ohio, who did some vandalism in Singapore? Remember the "Caning"? I think they would deserve it. You shouldn't destroy something known to be important to other just because it is not important to you, or because you happen to be a moron!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Vince Quintero — Sun, 03 May 2009 15:36:21 GMT

It is so sad that this tree had to be so needlessly destroyed by very unthoughtful individuals who probably thought it would make a great joke. I hope the people in the area band together and plant a new small "honking tree" so that the "honking tradition" can continue.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Mark, Kiln, MS — Sun, 03 May 2009 16:07:27 GMT

My guess is that it was either mindless vandals, as most of the posts here allude to, or someone who lived within earshot of the tree and finally had their fill of the honking. Either way it's a curious commentary on meaningful things that pass in and out of our lives.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Carrie Large, Pana IL — Sun, 03 May 2009 17:55:59 GMT

I agree wholeheartedly with the idea of keep on honking at the tree stump - or plant a new one - or maybe 2 or 3.

How sad, loss of icons such as this always break my heart.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

kathy y, st cloud mn — Sun, 03 May 2009 18:03:04 GMT

I could not believe it when I saw the news! From my earliest memory, every one I knew honked at the tree. Even my dad, who isn't big on stuff like that, would faithfully honk on our way from Silver Bay to points south (which is just about everywhere from SB!) How sad that someone felt the need to get rid of the symbol of local tradition.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

C Songaila, Sugarloaf PA — Sun, 03 May 2009 18:16:07 GMT

Anthony from WA was right.......keep honking; part of that tree is still there. If you stop honking the brainless twits that did this win. Just keep honking people....the spirit is still alive!!!!!!!!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

DR BK PALMER — Sun, 03 May 2009 18:23:01 GMT

I agree:

Find the idiots who did it & throw them in jail - or, whatever... ...and,

You should plant another tree & continue to honk away...

Dr. Palmer

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Veronica, Aguadilla, Puerto Rico. — Sun, 03 May 2009 18:32:09 GMT

Like Anthony said: Keep honking or the vandals win!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Chris White, Baker City, Oregon — Sun, 03 May 2009 18:36:30 GMT

We have Shoe Trees here in Oregon. Not sure how the tradition started, or even where, but where I grew up, there's a tree covered in shoes...kinda cool. My kids wanted to know if they could find a pair that fit, and trade for their own, as some of the shoes were really nice ones! They can be seen all over Oregon now.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

homegrown,dover,ar — Sun, 03 May 2009 19:00:47 GMT

two wars, millions out of work, brothers and sisters looseing their homes and their retirement they worked all their lives for and your whineing about one tree that could easiely be replaced. give me a fricking break.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

tree guy, ny — Sun, 03 May 2009 19:05:12 GMT

why within a mile did someone have reason to cut it? pine trees are no good for firewood.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Marion G, Thunder Bay, Ontario, Canada — Sun, 03 May 2009 19:09:34 GMT

What a shame! We used that tree as a landmark of "we're getting close to Duluth" on our trips. It saddens me to think it is gone. I hope a new one is planted so we can watch it grow. Why do some feel the need to destroy living things?

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Dana, Goshen, Indiana — Sun, 03 May 2009 19:14:42 GMT

Probably some sad loser trying to impress his "Friends", who're trying to talk him into doing some other stupid stunt just to make fun of him. And the idiot will eventually do it because he can't see what they really think of him.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Mellinpie — Sun, 03 May 2009 19:22:15 GMT

Idiots...pure and simple. Words cannot even convey how sick this makes me.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Morg, Tombstone, AZ — Sun, 03 May 2009 19:27:11 GMT

Are there any houses around there whose residents might be suffering sleep deprivation?

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Arleen, Detroit, MI — Sun, 03 May 2009 19:40:21 GMT

Every time I drive back to Massachusetts (my home state) when I spot the Bragga Bridge in Fall River, I
know I'm almost back "home". How utterly sad that you folks have had your Honking Tree destroyed. Plant another next to the stump for the next generation. The vandals who did this will hopefully mature one day and realize the importance of a seemingly insignificant land mark that broke the hearts of many. And the stump will remind them of the guilt that they will have to live with for the rest of their lives.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

moose ,norfolk virginia. — Sun, 03 May 2009 19:43:34 GMT

IF THE COMMENT ABOUT IT BEING A MILE FROM SOMEONES HOME, MEANS THE PERSON LIVING A MILE AWAY GOT TIRED OF HEARING THE HONKS( TOUGH TUBA). DOES THIS TREE QUALIFY AS A HISTORIC LANDMARK BY PROXY OR ANY OTHER WAY? FIND THE VANDALS AND MAKE THEM PAY $.01 A DAY FOR THE NUMBER OF DAYS THE TREE, MAKE THEM PAY TO THE PLANT A TREE SOCIETY

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Snorky2k, Sycamore, Illinois — Sun, 03 May 2009 21:58:06 GMT

It was more likely cut down by a new tennant who moved in not realizing that they would be bothered by the honking. It is very common for people to build a bunch of houses near a pig farm, then angrily go to court to have the farm put out of business for emitting a smell near their houses. Any new houses nearby? Anyone know the gps coords so we could look on googlemaps for a new house nearby?

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Tom, Crosby, MN — Sun, 03 May 2009 22:12:57 GMT

I would make the closest house my number one suspect! Horns on cars should be illegal. Think about it! What good has honking a horn ever done but piss someone off. I can boldly make this statement, because I saved a similar tree on my property. And if everyone honked their horn at it as they were going by, I would have cut it down years ago.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Marie, Santa Cruz CA — Sun, 03 May 2009 22:16:23 GMT

um, I don't get the last of Tyler from MN comment, "But if that tree was within a mile of someones home they probably had good reason."
Within a MILE they had "good reason???" WHY????
I am so sick of bad, stupid, drunk, insensitive, selfish people! I wish they would just off each other and let the good folks enjoy what's left of this beautiful planet.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

corona, ca — Sun, 03 May 2009 22:57:30 GMT

It was probably the state....from that pic it looked kinda close to the road... Government workers ususally do stuff like that and dont tell anyone...

Coincidentally, my house is the honk house. Some friends of my daughter started honking when they would drive by years ago and somehow it stuck...

I dont really dig it too much but what the heck....you cant let the little things in life bother you too much.....I do agree on the idea to plant a seedling....a little further from the roadside this time...

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Steven Allen, TX — Sun, 03 May 2009 23:00:07 GMT

I agree with Anthony of Renton WA, make it a honking stump or the punks win.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Jack Barclay, Mesilla, NM. — Sun, 03 May 2009 23:01:24 GMT

My condolences on the poor tree and the end of a nice
tradition. Please have a Scout Troop plant another one.
I'm guessing the Forest Service or a local nursery would
donate one to a Scout Troop to replace your lost tree.
It could be an Eagle Scout project, complete with a plaque to recognize the "honk tree".

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Anthony Hollis, ME — Sun, 03 May 2009 23:12:02 GMT

This just totally sucks! I once passed a young cherry tree in Portland, Maine that some idiot or idiots had ripped every single branch from. It was nothing more that a severed trunk, with jagged rips where branches once were. As I passed it I almost started crying, and I'm a grown man. I truly wonder what is wrong with some people that they can be so pathetically heartless.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Leslie, Charlotte MI — Sun, 03 May 2009 23:33:11 GMT

For everything that some thoughtless vandal destroys, the rest of us should stand up together and repair what was broken, replace what is stolen or plant new trees in their place. Never let the destroyers win.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

joe, Marietta, OH — Sun, 03 May 2009 23:37:07 GMT

Sorry about your pet tree. Let's face it .....the mental midgets that would think it was funny to kill a tree that everyone enjoyed has less than a room temperature IQ. The real problem is that these idiots can breed!
Plant a cool new tree and call it double honk!!!!!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Seanne — Sun, 03 May 2009 23:44:10 GMT

You never know, that particular tree may reroot itself in a small way and spread out some new tap roots for new little trees - happens here in the Rockies all the time. Vandals have nothing to do with their lives but destroy htings assuming there is some "secret" maessage of their own personal and meaningful identification that actually says they have the "right" to make thems as they prefer to see the "landscape". That is, until someone does the same thing to something of theirs, such as their car, garage, mailbox, place they own or work, front of home, favorite tree, and then they have hysterical fits for justice to be had. Maybe Tree will have its own revenge upon them one day, you never can tell.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Marion, CA — Sun, 03 May 2009 23:56:28 GMT

What a loss! Unfortunately, Mother Natur would eventually kill it. The good thing is a stump was left...it could send out new shoots. Memorializing it would let the vandals celebrate and/or create more vandals. Planting a new one (with protection) would be good, but would it be the same? For the person in TN, your government leaders are in my prayers...they have no clue to what they did!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Bud in Cincinnati,Ohio — Mon, 04 May 2009 00:28:40 GMT

Erect a memorial that says " Some idiot cut down the 'HONK TREE' honk your horn to wish him bad luck"

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Bud Barnard, Redmond, WA. — Mon, 04 May 2009 01:25:16 GMT

I agree with Anthony, of Renton, WA - (and not just because he's from WA) - even if the vandals should try to ruin the stump, too, - keep on honking as you pass - just as I keep glorifying my wife who passed away, recently - after 57 years of the most happy marriage a man ever had. NO ONE can kill our love or fond memories!!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

rick,drake,co — Mon, 04 May 2009 01:41:44 GMT

Same thing happened to a tree in Wyoming that was a landmark. Everyone was mad when it was cut down, and a neighbor planted a windbreak where the tree used to stand.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Dani — Mon, 04 May 2009 01:52:55 GMT

How sad. Please someone, plant a new tree.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Maris, Honolulu — Mon, 04 May 2009 02:21:49 GMT

That is very sad. I think maybe the community should try getting together to raise money to buy another tree and place a sign by the stump, something along the lines of "Honk Tree and Honk Tree Jr" ^_^
I'm with whoever said keep honking!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

HUNT EM DOWN — Mon, 04 May 2009 02:47:49 GMT

I guess the sad part is that the DNA defective twerp that did it will consider this the crowning accomplishment of his life. He will boast of it to his trusted friends at work at the 7/11 when he is 55. I hope he crashes his Yugo into the stump of that magnificent tree and is paralyzed from the neck up. Oh wait a minute he's already paralyzed from the neck up.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Frogman — Mon, 04 May 2009 03:05:21 GMT

What was the perpetrator thinking? That we're all going to be upset and that he has now achieved some sense of revenge against the world for his horrible life. Not necessarily. What I do think is that he is mentally ill, girls all think he is ugly, with bad teeth, nobody likes him - not even his mother, his dad is in jail, and he's not allowed at his sister's house because she doesn't trust him around her little kids. Kind of like Gollum but worse. Oh yeah, and that town needs to have a party for the tree, put a brass plaque on the stump with a joke about the perpetrators manhood size, or lack there of, and plant "Honk Tree II".

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

MARY ALYS STIEFEL,WINSTON SALEM,NC — Mon, 04 May 2009 03:52:40 GMT

HURRAH FOR THE "HONK STUMP", THE LEMONADE MADE OF THAT LEMON. QUICK,SOME REVERSE VANDAL PLANT A TREE AT MIDNIGHT.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

MC Dighton KS — Mon, 04 May 2009 04:14:02 GMT

Yes you can replace it, but it will never be the same. It is the end of an era, I hope the culprits are caught. It may sound corny, but maybe the community could have a service to "rebuild" with the planting of a new tree. Good luck to you.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Negav Kalanaga — Mon, 04 May 2009 05:00:49 GMT

Years ago, another idiot cut the entire Connell National Forest in Washington State - one tree along US 395. It was on private property, and they had to climb over a barbed wire fence to cut it! The perpetrator was cut, and his excuse was "it seemed like a fun idea". The punishment? He had to buy and plant a replacement tree, and care for it until it was big enough to survive. Since Connell is in a rather dry portion of the Columbia Basin, with only about 6 to 8 inches of rain a year, that means until it's big enough for its roots to reach groundwater, which may be many years! It was nothing but a common cottonwood, if I remember it right, but the locals all loved it, as "wild" trees are almost unheard of in the area.

No, it wasn't a designated National Forest, that's just what the locals called it.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Susan, Springfield, IL — Mon, 04 May 2009 06:18:55 GMT

Some people are simply subhuman creeps who get their jollies being mean and cruel. One day they will get theirs and then will be the first to cry and whine. Retribution is a great thing.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

VIC, NRH, TX — Mon, 04 May 2009 08:13:23 GMT

IF YOU CHECK WITH THE LOCAL HIGH SCHOOLS, I'M SURE SOME KID IS BOUND TO HEAR WHO DID IT!! I WOULD MAKE THEIR PARENTS PAY TO COMPLETELY TAKE OUT THE OLD ONE, AND PUT IN THE NEW ONE, THE NEW ONE BEING A REALLY BIG ONE THAT COSTS USUALLY AROUND 1,500.00 DOLLARS.. I'M SURE THE PARENTS CAN FIND A WAY TO MAKE THEIR IDIOT CHILD COME UP WITH THE CASH!!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Seth, Sydney, Australia — Mon, 04 May 2009 08:22:37 GMT

Ringbark the vandals legs!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

JOHN CATELLIER — Mon, 04 May 2009 09:33:02 GMT

WE HAD THE SAME THING HAPPENE IN CAMBRIDGE NY .WE HAD A TREE IN THE MIDDLE OF THE PLAYGROUND AT THE SCHOOL AND SOME ONE CUT IT DOWN ONE NIGHT. KEEP ON HONKING.THEY WILL GET THERE PUNISHMENT.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

C.K. Holton — Mon, 04 May 2009 09:47:50 GMT

Whomever had the urge to cut down that tree is a common IDIOT and has to be PITIED.
EVRYBODY THAT HAS A BRAIN KNOWS THAT A TREE IS THE EARTH'S GIFT TO THE SKY !!!

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Noman, Hippyville, OR — Mon, 04 May 2009 10:20:26 GMT

This was sad for about one second; I'm pretty sure that first person got it right, if the vandals lived close enough to hear excessive honking all hours of the night year after year than who's the real vandal? - in that case they didn't cut it down, the noise polluters slowly but surely ensured it's destruction. People need to remember that trees don't hear and any honking is for your own benefit. Do you actually miss the tree or how great it made you feel about Minnesota/home? Maybe next time people can keep their hands off the horn and this won't happen.

maybe it's just me but who cares?...if you want trees move out of the midwest like I did.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Delean Bindl, Riverton, Wyoming — Mon, 04 May 2009 10:58:57 GMT

I feel for you, Your lucky it has stayed this long. Don't take Idiots long to do things like this. Must have had other things to do first. I hope you either plat a new tree or put up a monument in it's place. I hate to see Idiots win.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Protodog, Detroit, Mi — Mon, 04 May 2009 12:26:48 GMT

It was probably the state DOT that removed the tree for being too close to the road. With people not paying attention to their driving with such distractions such as cell phones, texting, eating and navigation screens, the tree was a potential road hazard and had to be removed.
It wasn't vandals that caused the tree's demise, it was all those who can't stay off their cell phones or have all the latest electronic gadgets in their vehicle.
"GET OFF THE PHONE OR GET OFF THE ROAD!"

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Joyce H. Crapsey — Mon, 04 May 2009 12:41:21 GMT

I guess we all have a honking tree, in a way. We in South Carolina had a beautiful section (Mile Marker 117 and 118) of the interstate I-26 near Columbia. Large old trees. Everytime I drove that section, I thought that we certainly have one of the most beautiful states. I thought this in summer and winter. Well, one day, I went through that section and it was gone--all cut down to put a barrier cable there. My husband said that the large old trees were a natural barrier. To add insult to injury they came back and planted the most hideous trees you have ever seen.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Joyce H. Crapsey, Columbia, South Carolina — Mon, 04 May 2009 12:55:45 GMT

We also have a Sycamore tree. The county wanted to widen the road, so they cut the sycamore tree down. They replaced it, plus a roadside park and ceremony. Not the end of the story. This tree was a landmark (long before road signs. The Sycamore tree was there to mark the turn in directions. I was reading a book about the family during civil war times and it mentioned the Sycamore tree. A real loss.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Shannon, Wpg. Mb — Mon, 04 May 2009 14:01:32 GMT

I would say that some people are rude. I can't say that there may have been a valid reason for the destruction of this tree. But if people truly care about what has happened, not so much that it was a tree but a mark of somethin that made you happy, I'm sure planting a new one, beside the old one may bring some good state of mind. I know my family has a moose tree.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

cdugga — Mon, 04 May 2009 14:27:46 GMT

Terrible. Here is my latest tree story. There is a small black church on a main road in my town. It was a totally unremarkable little rectangular building in a small grassy field next to a chicken shack. But it always caught my attention because of a truly remarkable oak tree with 3 massive trunks and a crown that extended over half the church. I'm guessing that it had to be close to or more than 200 years old. I have no doubt that it was one of the reasons for locating the little church where it was. A couple of weeks ago they cut it down and put a small car port over a concrete slab where the tree used to be. They have a new church van that they park there. I guess they had their reasons but it still is just as sickening to me as the vandalism of the honk tree. Trees are important, but I am constantly reminded that they are symbolic also.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Doug O, Two Harbors, MN — Mon, 04 May 2009 17:53:29 GMT

It was a sad day for all of us in the Two Harbors area. Yes, another tree could be planted, but it will take generations for it to reach the stature of one that was cut down. Hopefully justice will be served and those responsible will be caught. Nice story Cuz! Thanks for bringing some national attention to our story.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

KAT M DO CINCINNATI OHIO — Mon, 04 May 2009 18:12:46 GMT

SOME OF YOU JUST IRK ME. jUST ONE TREE??? TELL THAT TO THE AMAZON...AND THE AIR WE BREATHE, AND THE BIRDS THAT NEST,OR THE BUGS THAT CRAWL.aLL OF THESE ARE 'life' MAY THOSE WHO MURDERED THIS TREE BE SAD AND ASHAMED.....ALWAYS

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Gina B, Bozeman, Montana — Mon, 04 May 2009 19:21:40 GMT

It's so sad when vandals destroy something you care about. Here in SW Montana we had a rock formation called "Eye of the Needle". It took hundreds of years for nature to create it, and one drunken night for some teenagers to destroy it. The memories are still there, but it can never be replaced or rebuilt. So sad.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Kurt N — Mon, 04 May 2009 19:26:17 GMT

I think the felling of the tree is eventually going to be discovered to be the work of THHS Class of '09 prank...much like when the TH Chicken was abducted a few years back. At least the chicken was found and repaired.

I hope whoever is responsible is caught, and I think their crime should be punished by having to volunteer their time with the forestry department planting new trees for the entire summer, pay all costs incurred to city/county crews in the clean up, removal and disposal of the tree carcass, and lastly be forced to stand at the site of the crime wearing or holding a big sign saying they're the guilty party. If for safety reasons, they should be publicly shamed at some accessible location in Two Harbors while wearing a dunce hat.

Goodbye to the ‘Honk Tree’

Cathy — Mon, 04 May 2009 20:16:05 GMT

Although it won't be the same, I hope your community will plant another tree.